The 2010s File Feature
Black Or White
Black Or White: The Glee Cast's Tribute to Michael Jackson By 2012, the television series Glee had established itself as one of the most commercially potent …
01 The Story
Black Or White: The Glee Cast's Tribute to Michael Jackson
By 2012, the television series Glee had established itself as one of the most commercially potent music vehicles on American television, regularly placing covers of popular songs onto the Billboard Hot 100 through the combined force of digital downloads, streaming activity, and its dedicated fanbase. The show's business model was built on licensing, covering, and reimagining existing material, and its most successful episodes were often those built around the catalogs of major artists. The Michael Jackson tribute episode, which aired during the third season, was among the most anticipated and commercially successful of these themed episodes.
"Black or White," Michael Jackson's original recording of which was released in 1991 as the lead single from Dangerous, was one of the most iconic songs in his catalog, having debuted simultaneously in multiple countries and immediately reached number one on charts worldwide. The Glee Cast's cover brought this song to a new generation of listeners in the context of the show's dramatized high school setting, filtering its message of racial unity through the lens of teenage experience and the show's established character dynamics.
The Glee Cast version was released through Columbia Records, the label partnership that handled the show's extensive catalog of cover recordings. The Glee franchise had developed an extraordinarily efficient pipeline from television broadcast to digital release, with songs typically available for purchase and streaming within hours of an episode airing. This immediacy was a significant driver of the show's chart success, as fan engagement was at its highest immediately after broadcast and the ability to purchase the tracks while the emotional connection was fresh translated directly into sales spikes.
The Michael Jackson tribute episode generated strong ratings and considerable media coverage, as the Glee team had secured cooperation from the Jackson estate in assembling the tribute. The estate's involvement lent a degree of official legitimacy to the project that not all tribute-based entertainment achieves, and it ensured that the arrangements and interpretations met standards of quality that the original recordings' legacy demanded. The episode featured multiple Jackson songs, but "Black or White" carried particular symbolic weight given its original message about racial and social unity and its connection to some of the most ambitious visual work of Jackson's career.
The Glee Cast cover performed solidly on the Billboard Hot 100, benefiting from the show's established pattern of converting fan enthusiasm into purchase behavior. The Glee model demonstrated during its peak years from roughly 2009 through 2013 that a television series could function as a genuine commercial music entity rather than simply a promotional vehicle, with its releases competing directly with original recordings from major pop artists on the primary sales and streaming charts.
The cultural significance of the episode and its musical content also extended into conversations about Michael Jackson's legacy in the years following his death in June 2009. Those years saw sustained and intense reassessment of his artistic contribution, his cultural influence, and his complicated personal history, and tribute projects like the Glee episode occupied a particular space in that conversation, celebrating the music while bringing it to audiences who may have been too young to have experienced it during Jackson's lifetime.
Production on the Glee version of "Black or White" maintained the essential elements of the original arrangement, including its famous hard rock guitar riff, while adapting it to the vocal capabilities and stylistic approach of the show's cast. The result was a version that was clearly respectful of the original while also having the characteristic Glee polish and accessibility. For many younger viewers, the Glee version served as a gateway to the original recording and to Jackson's broader catalog, a function that tribute covers have historically served across generations of popular music.
02 Song Meaning
The Themes Behind "Black Or White" (Glee Cast Version)
"Black or White" carries at its core a message of racial unity and the rejection of prejudice, framed through the lens of personal relationships and shared humanity. Michael Jackson wrote the song during a period in which his own racial identity had become a subject of public fascination and sometimes cruel commentary, and the song's insistence that racial categories are irrelevant to love and connection had personal as well as universal resonance. The Glee Cast cover, situated within a television series that regularly addressed themes of acceptance, inclusion, and the experience of outsiders, found a natural home for these themes.
The Glee series had from its premiere in 2009 built its narrative around characters who experienced exclusion and discrimination based on various aspects of their identity, including race, sexuality, disability, and social status. The selection of "Black or White" for the Jackson tribute episode was therefore not arbitrary but rather a thematically coherent choice that allowed the show to use music as a vehicle for reinforcing its own core values. The song's message about seeing past surface differences aligned directly with the show's ongoing thematic concerns.
The Glee interpretation also carried an implicit commentary about the role of popular culture in shaping social attitudes. Jackson's original 1991 music video had been one of the most watched television events of its era, and its morphing final sequence, in which human faces dissolved from one racial identity to another, was a bold visual statement about the constructed nature of racial categories. The Glee version, by placing the song in the context of a diverse cast of young performers, made a similar point through different means, suggesting that the next generation had internalized Jackson's message.
Within the context of Jackson's catalog, "Black or White" occupies a particular position as one of his most direct and unambiguous statements of social purpose. Much of his later work engaged with themes of social justice and global unity, but "Black or White" combined those themes with an irresistibly commercial hard rock energy that gave the message maximum reach. The Glee Cast cover honored that combination, preserving the essential musical character of the original while making it accessible to listeners who were primarily fans of the television series rather than existing Jackson devotees.
The song's enduring relevance to conversations about race in America meant that every cover version or tribute performance carried implicit contemporary significance beyond nostalgia. The Glee Cast's 2012 interpretation arrived at a moment when these conversations were very much alive in American public life, giving the music a renewed urgency that the show's writers and producers were clearly aware of in selecting it for inclusion in the tribute episode.
→ More from Glee Cast
View all Glee Cast hits →
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging