The 2010s File Feature
Smooth Criminal
The Production and Chart Performance of "Smooth Criminal" by Glee Cast Featuring 2Cellos The television series Glee, which aired on the Fox network beginning…
01 The Story
The Production and Chart Performance of "Smooth Criminal" by Glee Cast Featuring 2Cellos
The television series Glee, which aired on the Fox network beginning in 2009, developed a distinctive commercial identity through its practice of recording and releasing popular music covers performed by its cast. The show's music department worked with skilled arrangers and production teams to reimagine existing songs within the dramatic and musical context of the series, creating recordings that simultaneously served the narrative needs of the show and functioned as commercially viable singles in their own right. By its third season, the series had established a substantial track record of chart-performing singles derived from covers of well-known popular music catalog.
Michael Jackson's "Smooth Criminal" was originally released in 1987 as part of his album Bad, one of the most commercially successful albums in recording history. The original song was distinguished by its propulsive rhythm, Jackson's distinctive vocal performance, and one of his most memorable music videos, which featured elaborate choreography and cinematic production values that became iconic within popular culture. The song had achieved renewed cultural visibility in the years following Jackson's death in June 2009, and its status as a classic made it an attractive candidate for reinterpretation.
The Glee version of "Smooth Criminal" featured an arrangement that incorporated 2Cellos, a Croatian cello duo comprising Luka Sulic and Stjepan Hauser, who had gained international attention through their own viral video covers of rock and pop songs performed on classical string instruments. Their approach to the cello as a rock and pop performance instrument, rather than strictly a classical one, made them natural collaborators for a project that sought to present familiar popular music in unexpected instrumental configurations. The arrangement placed the two cellos in the foreground, giving the recording a distinctive sonic character that differentiated it substantially from both the Jackson original and conventional pop cover versions.
Within the narrative context of Glee, the song was featured in an episode that created a competitive scenario between characters, and the unusual arrangement with 2Cellos served the dramatic purpose of establishing one side of that competition as possessing sophisticated musical taste and unconventional creative ambition. The show's writers and music producers understood that the choice of arrangement was as meaningful as the choice of song, and the 2Cellos collaboration accomplished both musical and narrative objectives simultaneously.
"Smooth Criminal" by the Glee Cast featuring 2Cellos debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on February 18, 2012, entering at its peak position of number 26. The song spent two weeks on the chart, a brief but notable appearance that reflected the pattern common to Glee recordings: strong initial chart placement driven by fan engagement and single purchases in the immediate aftermath of the episode's broadcast, followed by a rapid descent as the same fan base moved on to the next episode's featured music.
The Hot 100 entry at number 26 was a commercially significant moment for the recording, representing a top-thirty appearance on the most comprehensive American pop music chart. The chart methodology in 2012 had incorporated streaming and digital download data in ways that allowed television-driven singles to chart quickly and prominently based on the burst of fan activity that followed episodic broadcasts. This dynamic was particularly pronounced for Glee, whose dedicated fan base, known widely as Gleeks, engaged in coordinated purchasing and streaming activity that reliably produced chart impacts in the days immediately following each episode.
The recording demonstrated the show's continued ability to generate chart-performing singles from its catalog of cover recordings, and it brought additional attention to 2Cellos as an ensemble, expanding their international audience through exposure on one of the most widely watched entertainment programs on American television at the time. The collaboration between a prime-time television cast and a classically trained instrumental duo was an unusual commercial configuration that nonetheless produced a result with genuine popular music chart presence.
02 Song Meaning
Themes and Cultural Context of "Smooth Criminal" by Glee Cast Featuring 2Cellos
Michael Jackson's "Smooth Criminal," first released in 1987 and reimagined for the Glee television series in 2012 with a cello-forward arrangement by 2Cellos, is a song built around a narrative of crime, violence, and dramatic confrontation. The original lyrical content depicts a scenario in which a woman identified as Annie has been attacked by a mysterious, unnamed criminal figure, and the narrator describes this event with urgent, cinematic detail. The song's imagery is drawn from hard-boiled crime fiction and film noir traditions, presenting a world of sudden violence and moral ambiguity.
The figure of the "smooth criminal" functions as an archetype within the song's narrative, representing a threat that is both physically dangerous and aesthetically compelling. The word "smooth" in the title carries connotations of effortless menace, describing a criminal whose competence at harm-doing is paradoxically admirable in its execution, even as the results of that competence are devastating. This tension between aesthetic admiration and moral condemnation is a characteristic feature of crime fiction and film noir, and Jackson's deployment of it in a pop music context gave the song a dramatic weight unusual for the genre.
Within the context of the Glee adaptation, the thematic content of the original song was somewhat displaced by the formal novelty of the arrangement and the competitive narrative context in which the cover was presented. The 2Cellos arrangement drew listener attention toward the unusual sonic texture of cello-performed rock instrumentation rather than toward the lyrical narrative of criminal violence, effectively reframing the song as a vehicle for demonstrating musical ingenuity and cross-genre experimentation. This is a characteristic feature of the Glee approach to cover material: the show frequently deployed familiar songs in ways that prioritized the dramatic context and the performance's formal qualities over strict fidelity to the original's thematic intentions.
The cultural significance of covering a Michael Jackson song on the Glee series in 2012, less than three years after Jackson's death in June 2009, carried its own weight. Jackson's catalog had entered a period of intense cultural reexamination following his passing, with audiences and critics revisiting his work both to mourn his loss and to assess his legacy. The choice of "Smooth Criminal" for the Glee adaptation was not culturally neutral, as it implicitly participated in the broader project of preserving and transmitting Jackson's music to younger audiences who encountered it through the mediation of the television series rather than through the original recordings directly.
The 2Cellos dimension of the recording added a layer of cultural meaning related to the ongoing conversation about genre boundaries and the relationship between classical and popular music traditions. Their presence on the track suggested that the formal vocabulary of classical string performance was not incompatible with the expressive demands of rock and pop material, a proposition that their viral YouTube videos had already advanced and that the Glee collaboration helped extend to a broader mainstream audience.
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging