The 1970s File Feature
What Is Truth
Johnny Cash and the Making of "What Is Truth" (1970) By the spring of 1970, Johnny Cash occupied a singular position in American popular culture. He had surv…
01 The Story
Johnny Cash and the Making of "What Is Truth" (1970)
By the spring of 1970, Johnny Cash occupied a singular position in American popular culture. He had survived addiction, personal collapse, and critical dismissal to emerge as one of the most respected and commercially powerful artists in the country. His weekly ABC television program, The Johnny Cash Show, reached millions of viewers each week and gave him a platform that few performers of any genre could match. It was from that platform, and from the turbulent social atmosphere of the Vietnam era, that "What Is Truth" was born.
Cash wrote the song in direct response to what he observed happening in the United States during a period of extraordinary generational conflict. The country was bitterly divided over the Vietnam War, student protest movements were intensifying on campuses across the nation, and older Americans were watching younger ones challenge virtually every institution they had built. Cash, who had always maintained a complicated political identity that defied easy categorization, found himself moved to speak on behalf of a generation that he felt was being dismissed and condemned unfairly by itsThe song was recorded at Columbia Recording Studios in Nashville and released on March 16, 1970, appearing on the album of the same name. It entered the Billboard Hot 100 on April 11, 1970, debuting at number 66 and climbing steadily through the spring. The record reached its peak position of number 19 during the week of May 23, 1970, spending eight weeks on the chart in total. For a country artist in the rock era, that kind of pop crossover performance reflected the degree to which Cash's moral authority transcended genre boundaries.genre boundaries.
The production approach was deliberate and somewhat spare by the standards of Nashville at the time. Producer Bob Johnston, who had worked with Bob Dylan and Simon and Garfunkel, understood that Cash's voice and the directness of his message required an uncluttered arrangement. The backing track gave the words room to breathe and land with force, which suited a song that functioned almost as a spoken sermon set to music.
The timing of the release was not incidental. The United States had recently witnessed the Kent State shootings on May 4, 1970, in which National Guard troops killed four students at Ohio's Kent State University during an antiwar protest. The event galvanized public opinion and deepened the sense of rupture between generations. Cash's record, already climbing the charts as Kent State occurred, suddenly carried an even more acute resonance. His decision to defend the young and challenge the comfortable assumptions of established authority felt, to many listeners, like a necessary act of witness.
Cash had always been drawn to the margins of American life, to prisoners, to the dispossessed, to those who felt the weight of judgment without the benefit of being heard. In "What Is Truth," he extended that sympathy to the youth counterculture in a way that was notable precisely because he was not a young man himself and not a rock musician. He was the Man in Black, already a symbol, speaking across the divide and refusing to condemn what he saw.
The record performed well on the country charts simultaneously, reaching the top five in that format and demonstrating that Cash's audience was willing to follow him even into controversial territory. The dual chart success underscored the breadth of his appeal and the degree to which his credibility operated independently of any single genre's gatekeeping.
The album version of the song was accompanied by spoken passages and contextual material that reinforced its message of generational understanding. Cash used his television show around the same period to host artists from both country and rock backgrounds, a practice that reflected his genuine belief in the importance of dialogue across the cultural divide.
"What Is Truth" remains one of the most explicitly political recordings of Cash's career, a document of a specific historical moment when one of America's most trusted voices chose to spend his credibility on behalf of the young and the questioning. Its chart performance confirmed that his audience shared, or at least respected, his willingness to take a stand.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning Behind "What Is Truth" by Johnny Cash
On its surface, "What Is Truth" poses a simple question, but the song's power lies in the way Johnny Cash constructs the inquiry as a challenge to established authority rather than an expression of nihilistic doubt. The question in the title is rhetorical, directed at those who claim to hold truth while refusing to listen to the voices of the young. Cash does not undermine the concept of truth itself; he demands that those in power account for their own failures before judging those who are protesting against them.
The song operates through a series of portraits. Cash presents figures at various stages of life and examines them through the lens of authenticity. A young boy asks honest questions about the world around him. A young man refuses to fight in a war he does not believe in. A young woman challenges social hypocrisy that she can see plainly even if her elders prefer not to acknowledge it. In each case, Cash positions the young person as the one asking legitimate questions while the older generation reacts with dismissal or condemnation.
Cash's perspective here is notably compassionate rather than confrontational. He does not condemn the older generation with bitterness; instead, he asks them to look more carefully at what is happening and to recognize the sincerity of those they are dismissing. The song functions as an act of mediation, with Cash using his own stature and credibility as a bridge across a divide that was tearing the country apart during the Vietnam era.
The generation gap that Cash addresses was not merely a matter of musical taste or clothing. By 1970, it had become a crisis of legitimacy. Young Americans were dying in a war that many did not understand and fewer and fewer supported. They were watching institutions fail them on multiple fronts simultaneously, and their protests were being met with increasingly harsh responses from authorities. Cash saw in that situation a genuine moral question about where truth actually resided, and he answered it by siding with those asking the questions.
There is also a class dimension to the song that Cash brings naturally from his own background. He grew up in poverty in rural Arkansas, and his instinctive sympathy was always with those who lacked power rather than those who wielded it. The young people he describes are not privileged rebels; they are ordinary people confronting a world that does not match what they have been told. Cash understood that experience from the inside.
The title phrase itself carries theological weight that would not have been lost on Cash's deeply religious audience. "What is truth?" echoes the question Pontius Pilate asks of Jesus in the Gospel of John, a question posed by a powerful man confronting someone whose moral authority he cannot entirely dismiss. By invoking that echo, Cash subtly aligns the questioning young with a figure of spiritual integrity, and the dismissive authorities with a figure who allowed injustice to proceed despite knowing better.
The song also demonstrates Cash's understanding that artistic courage has a cost. Taking a public position in defense of antiwar protesters and countercultural youth in 1970 was not without risk for a performer whose audience included many conservative Americans. That he made the record anyway, and that it succeeded commercially, speaks to the depth of trust his audience had placed in him over the preceding decade of honest, unflinching work.
→ More from Johnny Cash
View all Johnny Cash hits →
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging