The 2010s File Feature
Should've Been Us
Tori Kelly and the Breakthrough Moment: The History of "Should've Been Us" Victoria Loren Kelly, known professionally as Tori Kelly, spent years building an …
01 The Story
Tori Kelly and the Breakthrough Moment: The History of "Should've Been Us"
Victoria Loren Kelly, known professionally as Tori Kelly, spent years building an audience through YouTube covers and self-produced music before signing a major label deal and releasing the music that would introduce her to mainstream audiences. Her journey from independent YouTube artist to major label recording act was both unusually extended and unusually transparent, with her audience watching and participating in her development across years of internet-native content creation. "Should've Been Us," released in the summer of 2015, was the breakthrough moment that translated that built-up audience goodwill into genuine commercial chart success.
Kelly signed with Capitol Records following a trajectory that had already made her a recognizable figure in the YouTube music community. Her 2013 EP Handmade Songs by Tori Kelly demonstrated her vocal range and songwriting instincts, and her 2014 EP Foreword included early versions of material that would appear on her debut album. Capitol's investment in her development was substantial, and "Should've Been Us" was the lead single from her debut studio album Unbreakable Smile, released on June 23, 2015.
The production of "Should've Been Us" was handled by Nathan Chapman, a producer whose prior work included significant contributions to Taylor Swift's early albums. Chapman's production sensibility was well suited to Kelly's particular combination of pop accessibility and genuine vocal depth. The track's arrangement provides a platform for Kelly's voice without overwhelming it, featuring a mid-tempo pop structure with acoustic guitar elements and rhythmic pop production that was characteristic of the mid-2010s mainstream pop landscape.
"Should've Been Us" was written by Tori Kelly along with Ed Sheeran, a collaboration that reflected both artists' shared sensibility for emotionally direct, hook-driven songwriting. Sheeran, by 2015, had established himself as one of the most commercially successful songwriter-artists working in pop, and his involvement gave the track both creative credibility and commercial potential. The songwriting partnership produced a lyric that was emotionally specific enough to feel personal while universal enough to resonate with a wide audience, a quality that is the mark of accomplished pop songwriting.
The song entered the Billboard Hot 100 on August 1, 2015, debuting at number 90. It then climbed steadily over subsequent weeks, reaching its peak position of number 51 on the chart dated September 19, 2015. This ascending trajectory over a 10-week chart run is characteristic of breakout singles that build through radio play and word-of-mouth rather than through massive first-week streaming spikes, reflecting a pattern more common before streaming fully dominated chart calculation methodology.
The chart climb from 90 to 51 across ten weeks demonstrated radio's continued relevance as a discovery mechanism in 2015. The song received significant airplay support from pop and adult contemporary radio formats, which helped build the track's cumulative audience across the summer. Radio performance contributed to the sustained chart presence that distinguished it from streaming-driven tracks that often debut high and drop quickly, giving the song a more organic quality in its commercial trajectory.
Kelly's vocal performance on "Should've Been Us" was widely cited as the track's defining element. Her voice is technically exceptional, with a range and control that set her apart from the majority of her pop contemporaries, and the song gave her ample space to demonstrate these qualities. The vocal runs and dynamic shifts in the track's second half particularly drew attention from critics and listeners alike, establishing her vocal identity in the minds of listeners who were encountering her music for the first time through mainstream channels.
Unbreakable Smile, the album that housed the single, received generally positive reviews, with critics praising Kelly's songwriting, vocal performance, and the album's emotional authenticity. The album debuted at number 2 on the Billboard 200, demonstrating that the audience Kelly had built through years of independent activity was prepared to translate their support into album purchases and streams. "Should've Been Us" was the commercial engine driving that album's visibility, and its 10-week Hot 100 presence sustained attention on the project across a significant portion of the summer.
The song's music video, which accumulated substantial views on YouTube, reinforced Kelly's visual identity as an artist whose presentation emphasized authenticity and emotional directness over the highly choreographed spectacle associated with many of her pop peers. The video's relatively simple visual approach put the focus on Kelly's performance, which was consistent with the priorities of an artist whose reputation had been built primarily on vocal and songwriting ability rather than elaborate production value.
In the context of 2015 pop music, "Should've Been Us" offered something relatively rare: a mainstream pop song anchored by a genuinely exceptional voice and co-written by two credible songwriters. The song's success validated Capitol's investment and established Kelly as a major voice in contemporary pop, setting the stage for subsequent projects that would deepen her artistic identity and expand her audience. Its 54 million YouTube views across the years since its release confirm that it has maintained its appeal well beyond its initial chart moment, continuing to attract new listeners through platform recommendation and the enduring appeal of its emotional core.
02 Song Meaning
Regret, Self-Worth, and the Aftermath of Loss: The Themes of "Should've Been Us"
"Should've Been Us" belongs to a specific and well-populated category of pop songwriting: the song that processes the end of a relationship not through anger or indifference but through the specific, painful acknowledgment that things could have been different. The song's central emotional stance is one of reflective grief, a looking back at what was and what might have been, with the recognition that the loss was not inevitable but rather the result of choices and circumstances that could, in retrospect, have gone otherwise.
The thematic sophistication of the song, which benefits from the collaborative songwriting of both Tori Kelly and Ed Sheeran, lies in its capacity to hold multiple emotional registers simultaneously. There is anger in the song, frustration at the outcome and possibly at the other person, but there is also tenderness and even a kind of gratitude for what existed before the end. This emotional complexity prevents the song from collapsing into simple bitter complaint, elevating it above the considerable number of break-up songs that populate the pop landscape.
The title phrase itself is doing significant thematic work. The conditional "should've been" implies both a judgment about how things ought to have gone and an acknowledgment that they did not. It is a phrase that belongs to the vocabulary of regret rather than to the vocabulary of acceptance, and it situates the narrator at a specific point in the emotional arc of loss: past the initial shock, not yet arrived at resolution, caught in the evaluative middle space where comparison between what is and what might have been is unavoidable.
Tori Kelly's vocal performance amplifies the emotional content of the lyric through its own expressive qualities. Her voice carries warmth and sincerity that prevent even the song's most emotionally heightened moments from feeling melodramatic. This is a significant achievement, because the subject matter of "Should've Been Us" could easily tip into excess in less skilled hands. Kelly's vocal temperament, combined with her technical control, allows her to navigate the song's emotional peaks without losing the listener's empathetic connection.
The theme of self-worth asserting itself through grief is another dimension of the song that merits attention. The narrator of "Should've Been Us" is not simply lamenting a loss; she is also, in the act of acknowledging that "it should've been us," asserting that she deserved the kind of relationship the song describes. This is a subtle but important distinction: the song is as much about claiming one's worth as it is about processing sadness. The emotional arc moves toward, if not quite arriving at, a position of self-validation.
The collaboration with Ed Sheeran is relevant to the song's thematic architecture. Sheeran's songwriting at this period was characterized by an ability to write emotionally specific material that maintained broad accessibility, and his contribution to "Should've Been Us" aligns with that capacity. The song's lyrical precision, the way it captures particular emotional textures rather than settling for generic sentiment, reflects the standards of craft that both Kelly and Sheeran brought to the writing process.
The song's continued relevance, evidenced by its accumulation of 54 million YouTube views across the years since its 2015 release, reflects the universality of the emotional experience it addresses. The end of a relationship that felt right, the haunting sense that things might have worked out differently, is an experience that crosses demographic lines and generational boundaries. Songs that address this experience with genuine emotional intelligence tend to maintain their resonance across time, and "Should've Been Us" achieves this through a combination of compositional craft, vocal performance, and thematic honesty that distinguishes it from the large number of break-up songs that populate the pop tradition.
Within the context of Tori Kelly's career, "Should've Been Us" also functions as a statement of artistic identity. By choosing to launch her major label career with a song of this emotional depth and vocal ambition, she signaled that she was not interested in the safer, more formulaic approach available to a young pop artist eager for immediate commercial success. The risk paid off commercially and artistically, establishing her as an artist whose work would be defined by genuine vocal and emotional craft.
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging