The 2010s File Feature
The One
The Chainsmokers and the Making of "The One" "The One" by The Chainsmokers arrived in April 2017 as part of one of the most commercially dominant periods in …
01 The Story
The Chainsmokers and the Making of "The One"
"The One" by The Chainsmokers arrived in April 2017 as part of one of the most commercially dominant periods in the duo's career. Alex Pall and Andrew Taggart had spent the preceding twelve months establishing themselves as arguably the most commercially successful act in electronic pop music, with their debut studio album Memories...Do Not Open released on April 7, 2017 — the same month in which "The One" made its chart debut. The album debuted at number 1 on the Billboard 200, making The Chainsmokers only the second electronic act to achieve that distinction, following Daft Punk's similarly historic debut position with Random Access Memories in 2013.
"The One" was included on Memories...Do Not Open, a fourteen-track collection that consolidated the duo's sonic evolution from DJ-focused electronic production toward fully realized pop songwriting with vocals at the center. The song debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on April 22, 2017, entering at number 91 before climbing to its peak position of number 78 the following week on April 29, 2017. Its two-week chart run represented a modest commercial moment by the standards of the broader album campaign, which was simultaneously producing far larger chart hits through other singles.
The context for "The One" was shaped by the extraordinary commercial trajectory The Chainsmokers had established with the singles "Closer" (featuring Halsey) and "Something Just Like This" (featuring Coldplay). "Closer" had spent twelve weeks at number 1 on the Hot 100 in 2016, making it one of the longest-running chart-toppers of that decade. That level of commercial precedent meant that any track associated with the same album period was evaluated against an unusually demanding benchmark.
The Album Campaign and "The One" Within It
The Chainsmokers' approach to album construction on Memories...Do Not Open reflected the prevailing commercial logic of streaming-era pop, in which albums functioned as platforms for multiple potential singles rather than as unified artistic statements in the traditional sense. Each track was produced with radio and streaming viability in mind, resulting in a collection with significant variation in tempo, emotional register, and production approach but consistent sonic polish throughout.
"The One" occupied a specific emotional space within the album, addressing themes of romantic longing and the question of whether a particular connection is singular and irreplaceable. Andrew Taggart provided the lead vocal performance, consistent with the duo's increasing emphasis on Taggart's voice as a primary artistic vehicle, a direction that had accelerated with "Closer" and continued through the album's other vocal tracks.
The production of "The One" was handled by Pall and Taggart themselves, alongside collaborators who had contributed to other tracks on the album. The sonic palette combined elements of their established electronic pop framework with some of the organic instrumentation touches that characterized the album's broader production aesthetic. Guitar textures, live-sounding drums alongside programmed elements, and careful attention to the emotional coloring of synthesizer choices all contributed to a sound that felt warmer and more acoustically grounded than the duo's earlier purely electronic productions.
Commercial Context and Reception
The song was released at a moment of significant critical and commercial scrutiny for The Chainsmokers. The enormous success of "Closer" had generated a level of mainstream visibility that also attracted skeptical attention from music critics who questioned whether the duo's commercial appeal reflected genuine artistic merit or simply a talent for producing efficiently targeted pop product. Reviews of Memories...Do Not Open were mixed in ways that reflected these tensions: many acknowledged the album's commercial professionalism while questioning its depth.
The YouTube video for "The One" accumulated approximately 51 million views, a figure consistent with the album's overall digital performance across platforms. The Chainsmokers had built a particularly substantial presence on streaming platforms by 2017, with their total stream counts ranking among the highest of any act in their genre, and "The One" benefited from the algorithmic tailwind of audiences who had demonstrated affinity for their work through engagement with "Closer," "Paris," and other releases.
The Duo's Standing in 2017
By April 2017, The Chainsmokers had achieved a commercial position that was almost without precedent for acts from an electronic music background. The success of Memories...Do Not Open and its associated singles placed them in a tier of commercial popularity that had historically been dominated by artists from rock, hip-hop, and country backgrounds rather than from electronic production. "The One" was a small component of this larger achievement, a track that added to the breadth of their catalog even if it did not independently approach the heights of their biggest singles. The duo would continue releasing music in subsequent years, though the commercial peak of the 2016-2017 period proved difficult to replicate consistently.
02 Song Meaning
Singular Love and Romantic Inevitability in "The One"
"The One" by The Chainsmokers engages with one of the most enduring preoccupations in popular music: the belief, or the hope, that a particular romantic connection is uniquely suited to oneself in a way that no other connection could be. The concept of "the one" as a romantic ideal has deep roots in both popular culture and philosophical traditions concerning love and destiny, and the song channels this familiar vocabulary while investing it with the specific sonic and emotional textures that characterized The Chainsmokers' approach to pop songwriting in 2017.
The thematic content addresses the intersection of desire and uncertainty, the experience of being deeply drawn to someone while also being unsure whether the feeling is reciprocated or sustainable. This ambivalence, the simultaneous intensity of attraction and the vulnerability of not knowing if that attraction will be confirmed and returned, is one of the most commonly addressed emotional states in popular music, but it requires careful handling to avoid descending into cliche. The song attempts to navigate this territory through the specificity of its emotional observation and the sincerity of its vocal delivery.
Andrew Taggart's Voice as Emotional Vehicle
By 2017, Andrew Taggart had established himself as the primary vocal voice of The Chainsmokers' recorded output, a transition that had accelerated with "Closer" and that positioned the duo differently from their earlier identity as producers who featured guest vocalists. This shift was commercially significant because it aligned the duo's sound more closely with the singer-songwriter emotional directness that was proving enormously successful in mainstream pop, while retaining the electronic production infrastructure that was their defining technical strength.
Taggart's vocal approach on "The One" is notable for its restraint. Rather than the more dramatic delivery that characterized some of the duo's bigger commercial moments, the performance here is conversational and intimate, appropriate to the lyrical content's investment in personal feeling and genuine uncertainty. This tonal restraint creates a sense that the speaker is genuinely grappling with his feelings rather than performing a pre-resolved emotional state for the listener's entertainment.
Production as Emotional Architecture
The production design of "The One" reflects the broader evolution The Chainsmokers had undertaken in the period surrounding Memories...Do Not Open. Their earlier work had been characterized by more obviously electronic production choices, with synth stabs, four-on-the-floor kick patterns, and drop-oriented structures that marked the songs as products of EDM-influenced pop. By the time of this album, the duo had moved toward production that incorporated more acoustic elements, warmer synthesizer textures, and structural approaches that foregrounded the emotional content of the vocal performance over any specifically electronic spectacle.
The song's production creates a sonic environment of warmth and intimacy that serves the romantic thematic content effectively. The use of layered guitar textures alongside electronic elements creates a sonic palette that bridges the organic and the produced in a way that resonates with listeners who might find purely electronic production emotionally cold while also satisfying those who appreciate the sonic precision of carefully crafted digital production.
The "The One" Trope in Popular Culture
The concept of a singular romantic partner, the idea that among all possible human connections one person can be uniquely and cosmically right for another, has been a recurring subject in popular music since at least the mid-twentieth century. The Chainsmokers' treatment of this theme participates in a long lineage that includes countless ballads from multiple genres and generations. What makes each iteration of the theme valuable or interesting is the specific emotional intelligence and creative execution it brings to the universal subject rather than the novelty of the subject itself.
In the context of 2017 pop music, "The One" sits within a moment when romantic vulnerability and emotional directness were being widely embraced as commercial and artistic values, partly in response to the ironic distance that had characterized much of the millennial-generation indie and alternative music that preceded this shift. The song's willingness to engage sincerely with the desire for a singular connection reflects this broader cultural recalibration toward emotional transparency.
Cultural Reception and Streaming Legacy
The song's accumulation of approximately 51 million YouTube views reflects its sustained presence within The Chainsmokers' catalog as an album track that found its audience through streaming platform discovery rather than through extensive radio play or single-focused promotional activity. Album tracks that succeed in the streaming environment often do so by finding listeners through playlist placement and algorithmic recommendation, genres where The Chainsmokers were particularly well-served given their overall streaming profile in 2017.
In retrospect, "The One" represents a specific moment in The Chainsmokers' creative development, a point at which they were attempting to balance the commercial imperative of their status as one of the most-streamed acts in the world with a genuine interest in deepening the emotional and compositional qualities of their work. Whether individual listeners judge that attempt successful or not, the song stands as honest evidence of that creative aspiration.
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging