The 2010s File Feature
Drinkin' Problem
Midland's "Drinkin' Problem": A Honky-Tonk Revival That Changed Country Radio "Drinkin' Problem" is the debut single by Midland, the Texas country trio consi…
01 The Story
Midland's "Drinkin' Problem": A Honky-Tonk Revival That Changed Country Radio
"Drinkin' Problem" is the debut single by Midland, the Texas country trio consisting of Mark Wystrach, Jess Carson, and Cameron Dudley. Released in 2017 on Big Machine Records, the track became one of the most significant debuts in country music in years, arriving at a moment when mainstream Nashville was dominated by a bro-country hangover and the early stirrings of a broader sound that many listeners felt had drifted from country's roots. Midland's sound, deeply indebted to the Bakersfield sound, classic honky-tonk, and the Texas country tradition, felt like a corrective that was also genuinely contemporary rather than merely nostalgic.
The song was written by Mark Wystrach, Jess Carson, and Shane McAnally, with McAnally serving as a crucial creative link between the trio's organic sound and the professional infrastructure of Nashville songwriting. McAnally, one of the most decorated and in-demand songwriters and producers in country music, had already been involved in landmark projects across the country landscape, and his participation in Midland's development was instrumental in shaping their debut toward the kind of commercial accessibility that would make "Drinkin' Problem" a genuine radio hit without compromising the vintage aesthetic that defined their identity.
"Drinkin' Problem" was produced by Dann Huff and Shane McAnally. Huff, a highly accomplished Nashville producer known for his work with Keith Urban, Taylor Swift, and others, brought technical excellence and commercial awareness to the production while respecting the retro-influenced direction that the trio and McAnally had established. The resulting track sounds genuinely like a lost classic from the late 1970s or early 1980s while also meeting the sonic standards of contemporary country production, a balance that is significantly harder to achieve than it might appear.
The song reached number one on Billboard's Country Airplay chart in October 2017, a remarkable achievement for a debut single, and spent multiple weeks at or near the top of that chart. It also appeared on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, where it performed strongly for an extended period. The song's chart success marked Midland as the most commercially significant new traditional-leaning country act in years, and the conversation around their debut extended well beyond country music circles into broader discussions about authenticity, commercial music, and the cyclical nature of genre trends.
The Grammy Award for Best Country Song was presented to the songwriters of "Drinkin' Problem" at the 60th Grammy Awards in January 2018, an honor that validated the critical consensus around the track and elevated its profile further. The nomination and award also represented a statement by the Recording Academy about the direction country music was heading, a validation of the traditional sound that many in the industry had feared was being permanently displaced by the pop-influenced production that dominated Nashville output in the early and mid-2010s.
The album On the Rocks, released in September 2017 on Big Machine Records, served as the full-length context for "Drinkin' Problem" and demonstrated that the sound of the debut single was not a one-off but a genuine artistic commitment. The album's title referenced both the ice delivery method for whiskey and the metaphor of a relationship in difficulty, a layered pun that reflected the band's comfort with the lyrical traditions of classic country. The production throughout maintained the consistency of approach that "Drinkin' Problem" had established.
Mark Wystrach's visual presence and the group's carefully curated aesthetic, which referenced classic country imagery including western wear, vintage vehicles, and the visual vernacular of 1970s country album artwork, contributed to their commercial appeal in ways that extended beyond the music alone. In an era when the visual dimension of an artist's identity is as commercially important as their sound, Midland's coherent visual world was a significant asset that distinguished them from competitors whose music might have occupied similar sonic territory without the same level of visual and thematic consistency.
The success of "Drinkin' Problem" opened doors for subsequent singles and helped establish Big Machine Records as a home for artists pursuing traditional-leaning country sounds. The track also influenced the broader conversation within Nashville about commercial viability of traditional country approaches, demonstrating to labels and radio programmers that an audience existed for music that departed from the dominant contemporary country sound without abandoning the genre's commercial infrastructure entirely.
Midland's debut arrived at a moment when acts like Chris Stapleton, Sturgill Simpson, and Kacey Musgraves had already demonstrated that country music's tent was wider than mainstream Nashville output suggested. "Drinkin' Problem" occupied a more explicitly commercial space within that broader trend, aiming for and achieving mainstream country radio success while maintaining the traditional aesthetic that those artists had also celebrated. The combination proved remarkably durable, and the song remains the defining moment in Midland's discography.
02 Song Meaning
The Real Problem in "Drinkin' Problem": Heartache Wearing Honky-Tonk Clothes
"Drinkin' Problem" executes one of country music's oldest and most effective structural moves: it presents what appears to be a song about drinking and reveals, through a rhetorical turn, that the real subject is a person. The speaker has been accused of having a drinking problem and acknowledges the accusation while identifying its actual referent: the problem is not the drinking itself but the fact that the person who drove the speaker to drink is still in their thoughts. This pivot is the song's core emotional mechanism, and it works as well as it does because country music's audience has been primed by decades of precedent to receive exactly this kind of rhetorical twist with recognition and satisfaction.
The honky-tonk tradition that "Drinkin' Problem" draws on has always understood that drinking songs and heartache songs are essentially the same song told from different angles. The bar is not a place of escape but a place of reckoning, where the absence of the person one loves becomes more vivid rather than less because there is nothing to do but sit with it. Midland locates themselves within this tradition not as nostalgic tourists but as genuine inheritors of it, and the conviction of the performance is what separates their song from mere period pastiche.
Mark Wystrach's vocal performance captures the specific tone of someone who knows they are being self-destructive and has decided to own that knowledge rather than fight it. This is a particular kind of emotional honesty that country music has historically done better than any other popular genre: the acknowledgment that grief does not always produce dignified behavior, that the process of surviving heartbreak is frequently messy and somewhat ridiculous, and that the most useful artistic response to this reality is clear-eyed recognition rather than romanticization. The song is funny in the way that country music at its best is funny, not because it trivializes the pain but because it finds the dark comedy in human behavior under emotional pressure.
The lyrical construction also rewards attention at the level of wordplay. The phrase "drinkin' problem" shifts registers throughout the song, moving between accusation, self-identification, and redefinition, and each shift changes what the words mean. This kind of linguistic playfulness is characteristic of Shane McAnally's songwriting, which consistently finds ways to make conventional subject matter feel fresh through the precision and surprise of word choice. Country music has a long tradition of honoring exactly this craft, and the Grammy recognition that the song received was in part a recognition of the writing's technical quality.
For listeners who encountered "Drinkin' Problem" as a potential corrective to the dominant country sounds of the mid-2010s, the song carried additional meaning as a statement about what country music could be. The Bakersfield influences, the steel guitar tones, the phrasing borrowed from the classic honky-tonk tradition all function as a kind of genre argument as well as a song, making the case through example that the emotional territory and formal elegance of traditional country had not been exhausted by decades of previous exploitation. This argument resonated strongly with a segment of country music's audience that had felt underserved by the more pop-oriented direction mainstream Nashville had pursued.
The song's continued resonance in the years since its release speaks to the durability of its emotional and formal combination. It has been adopted as a karaoke standard, a bar band staple, and a reference point in conversations about what authentic country sounds like in the contemporary moment. These are not simply marks of commercial success but signs that the song has entered the living repertoire of country music in a way that only the most genuinely realized work manages to achieve. The drinkin' problem, it turns out, was the same problem that has always been worth singing about in this tradition: the problem of loving someone so much that their absence rearranges the furniture of ordinary life.
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging