The 2000s File Feature
Don't Rain On My Parade
"Don't Rain On My Parade" — The Glee Cast and a Broadway Classic Reimagined A Song with Decades of History Some songs arrive on Broadway and immediately anno…
01 The Story
"Don't Rain On My Parade" — The Glee Cast and a Broadway Classic Reimagined
A Song with Decades of History
Some songs arrive on Broadway and immediately announce themselves as standards, pieces that will outlast their original production and continue to accumulate meaning through each new generation of performers who take them on. "Don't Rain On My Parade" from the 1964 musical Funny Girl was that kind of song from the moment Barbra Streisand performed it on stage as Fanny Brice. The number had everything that makes a Broadway showstopper: an irresistible melodic drive, lyrics that crystallized an entire personality in a few minutes of music, and a build that demanded more from its performer with every successive phrase. By the time Glee covered it in 2009, the song carried 45 years of theatrical history, most of it associated with the specific legend of Streisand's definitive early performance.
The Glee Context
The television series Glee had launched in May 2009 with a pilot episode and then returned for its full first season in the autumn of the same year. The show's producers understood immediately that Broadway material was central to their mission, and covering the great show tunes was as important to the program's identity as covering contemporary pop hits. The Streisand catalog in particular represented both artistic ambition and a claim to a specific legacy of theatrical performance, the idea that the show was engaged with the full history of the American musical tradition, not just its most recent developments. Placing this song in the hands of one of the show's lead characters was a statement about ambition, personality, and the capacity of high school musical theater to contain the biggest emotional registers.
The Billboard Entry
The Glee Cast's recording entered the Billboard Hot 100 on December 26, 2009, the week of Christmas. It debuted and peaked at number 53, spending one week on the chart. That single-week chart appearance was typical of how Glee recordings performed on the Hot 100, generating immediate purchase activity from fans who had just seen the episode and wanted to own the performance, then fading from chart eligibility as the immediate enthusiasm resolved. The holiday timing of the chart entry gave the single an additional boost from the accelerated purchasing patterns of the December holiday week, when digital sales across all categories tended to spike.
The Interpretation Problem
Covering a song so closely identified with a specific legendary performance is an exercise in navigating precedent. Every note of the original carries Barbra Streisand's specific vocal interpretation, and any subsequent version is immediately measured against that standard. The Glee approach to this challenge was generally to honor the spirit of the original while adapting the arrangement to the demands of its new narrative context, using the song's emotional content to serve the character's story rather than trying to reproduce or directly compete with the definitive version. The result was a kind of theatrical cover that existed in a different register from a standard pop cover, aware of its sources and its debts while serving a new purpose.
Broadway's Presence in the Glee Universe
The success of Glee's Broadway covers, measured both in chart performance and in fan response, revealed something about the audience that producers had perhaps not fully anticipated: there was a large, enthusiastic viewership that had not grown up with the Broadway canon but was ready to encounter it through the mediation of television and character identification. Songs like this one, which had been primarily known to theater-goers and Streisand devotees, suddenly reached a generation of teenage viewers who experienced them as fresh material rather than as historical artifacts. That cross-generational transmission was one of the more valuable cultural functions the show performed, and it was something neither traditional Broadway nor traditional pop radio could have accomplished independently.
The song still demands everything from whoever performs it. Press play and hear what Glee's version did with one of Broadway's most demanding showstoppers.
"Don't Rain On My Parade" — Glee Cast's singular moment on the 2000s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning and Legacy of "Don't Rain On My Parade" by Glee Cast
The Declaration at the Song's Core
Originally written by Jule Styne with lyrics by Bob Merrill for the 1964 Broadway production of Funny Girl, the song functioned as a character manifesto, a declaration of unstoppable forward motion in the face of everything that might try to slow it down. The narrator refused to be diminished, patronized, or cautioned. The imagery was romantic and theatrical, all steamboats and ticker tape, reaching for the grandest available metaphors to express the sheer force of personal ambition and self-belief. The song was essentially a theatrical aria of determination, and its placement at a climactic moment in the original musical gave it the function of a character fully claiming her identity and her right to pursue it without apology.
The Adolescent Resonance
Part of the reason the song worked so powerfully in a Glee context was the ease with which its core emotional content translated to the experience of ambitious teenagers. The feeling of having one's dreams underestimated, of being told to be realistic or to moderate one's expectations, is one of the defining experiences of adolescence, particularly for young people with artistic ambitions. The song's defiance of those limiting voices resonated with a teenage audience that recognized the emotional situation even if they had never seen Funny Girl and had no particular connection to Barbra Streisand or mid-century Broadway. The emotional universality of the song's core argument made the translation across generations and contexts nearly frictionless.
Streisand's Shadow and Its Meaning
It is impossible to engage seriously with this song in any context without acknowledging the specific weight of Barbra Streisand's original performance, both in the 1964 stage production and in the 1968 film adaptation. Streisand's interpretation became so definitive that the song functioned, for subsequent generations, as a kind of test: could any performer bring sufficient conviction to material so thoroughly identified with one artist's particular genius? The history of the song's subsequent performances is partly a history of that test and how different singers have approached it. The Glee version, by embedding the performance in a television narrative about a character's specific journey, found a way to serve the song's emotional content while acknowledging rather than competing with its legendary past.
Cross-Generational Transmission of the Musical Canon
The deeper cultural significance of the Glee cover lay in its function as a bridge across generations of theatrical and musical history. Young viewers who might never have sought out a Streisand album or a Broadway cast recording encountered this song as an urgent, emotionally immediate piece of contemporary television storytelling. For many of them, the Glee version was the primary version, the one they knew first and the one through which they later discovered the original. That sequence of discovery, from contemporary cover to historical original, is an unusual but not unprecedented path through musical history, and the songs that lend themselves to it are almost always the ones with the strongest underlying emotional architecture. "Don't Rain On My Parade" has that architecture in abundance, and its Glee incarnation confirmed that it could travel across very different cultural territories without losing its essential force.
→ More from Glee Cast
View all Glee Cast hits →
→ More from the 2000s File
View all 2000s hits →
Keep digging