The 1970s File Feature
Breaking Up Is Hard To Do
Breaking Up Is Hard To Do — The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy The summer of 1972 presented an interesting commercial parado…
01 The Story
Breaking Up Is Hard To Do — The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy
The summer of 1972 presented an interesting commercial paradox. Serious rock criticism had, by then, established a fairly clear hierarchy of what counted as significant and what counted as disposable, and the Partridge Family occupied the bottom of that hierarchy with remarkable stability. The show was a hit, the merchandising was a phenomenon, and David Cassidy's poster was on the bedroom wall of a substantial portion of the American teenage female population. None of this impressed the critics. The audience, characteristically, did not consult the critics, and over ten weeks beginning July 1, 1972, they carried the Partridge Family's version of "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" to number 28 on the Billboard Hot 100.
The Partridge Family Phenomenon
The Partridge Family had premiered on ABC in September 1970 and almost immediately created a commercial juggernaut that went well beyond what anyone involved had anticipated. I Think I Love You, the show's debut single, reached number one in November 1970 and became one of the year's biggest records. What followed was a sustained run of chart activity that made the Partridge Family one of the most commercially successful recording acts of the early 1970s by pure chart metric, regardless of what the critical establishment thought of the material. David Cassidy was, by any honest measure, one of the biggest pop stars in America in 1971 and 1972, his face and music reaching into demographics that conventional rock acts could not access.
The Song Choice
Covering "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" in 1972 meant engaging with Neil Sedaka's 1962 pop hit, a song so thoroughly identified with its original recording that it had the quality of a standard despite its relative youth. Sedaka's version had reached number one a decade earlier, and the song's melodic clarity and lyrical accessibility had made it a natural target for subsequent interpretations. The Partridge Family's version suited both the song's inherent pop craft and the commercial context the show provided: a clean, accessible interpretation that would resonate with the broad audience the television exposure delivered.
The Chart Run
The record debuted at number 95 on July 1, 1972, and climbed with consistent momentum through July and August: to 82, then 55, 41, 36, and continuing upward through its ten-week run, reaching its peak position of number 28 during the week of August 19, 1972. Ten weeks on the Hot 100, a climb from the bottom of the chart to near the top 25. That kind of sustained climb over ten weeks is the signature of a record with genuine and growing commercial traction, building its audience week by week through television exposure, radio airplay, and the purchasing activity of a loyal fanbase.
Teen Pop as a Commercial Force
The early 1970s teen pop market, which included not just the Partridge Family but also the Osmonds, David Cassidy's solo career, and various other television-adjacent acts, operated on commercial scales that the critical establishment's focus on album-oriented rock entirely missed. The singles these acts released sold in large quantities to an audience that was genuinely engaged, not passive consumers but active participants in a fan culture with its own internal hierarchies and rituals. The Partridge Family's chart success was the commercial expression of this engagement, millions of individual purchase decisions made by people who found the music and the performers genuinely appealing.
Shirley Jones and the Show's Credibility
The full billing on the record, The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy, reflected the show's own understanding of its legitimacy structure. Jones was an Academy Award winner with a serious acting credential, and her presence in the cast gave the show a degree of adult respectability that it might not have achieved with an entirely youthful lineup. This was not an accident of casting but a deliberate choice to anchor the family scenario in recognizable adult credibility, which in turn gave the family's recordings a thin layer of legitimacy that pure teen acts could not claim.
A Career Moment in Cultural Context
The Partridge Family's chart history, viewed without the distortion of critical condescension, is genuinely impressive. Multiple top-ten records, consistent Hot 100 presence across three years, and the kind of fan engagement that translates into sold-out concerts and substantial merchandise revenue: these are the markers of real commercial success in the music industry by any objective measure. The summer 1972 cover of "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" is a solid entry in that catalog, a record that earned its ten weeks and its peak at 28 through the same combination of commercial execution and genuine audience connection that drove all of the act's best-performing releases.
Put it on and let the chorus bring back whatever summer it belonged to for you.
"Breaking Up Is Hard To Do" — The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy's singular moment on the 1970s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Pop Ritual of Romantic Difficulty: What "Breaking Up Is Hard To Do" Means
Some lyrical titles operate as complete emotional statements in themselves, requiring no further explanation because they describe an experience so universally recognized that simply naming it accurately is sufficient. "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" is one of these titles. The statement is obvious, the experience is universal, and the song's commercial durability across multiple decades and multiple recording interpretations confirms that obvious accuracy is its own form of artistic achievement.
The Truth in Simplicity
Neil Sedaka's original lyric made no attempt at poetic complexity or unexpected emotional angles. It stated a familiar truth in the most direct terms available and trusted the melody to give that truth its emotional weight. This decision to stay simple rather than reach for sophistication was the right creative choice, because the experience the song describes is not a complex one: endings are painful, and the desire to defer or avoid them is natural. A song that says this simply and melodically will always find an audience because the audience will always have people in the middle of exactly this experience.
The Partridge Family Audience and Romantic Experience
The primary audience for the Partridge Family's recordings in 1972 was adolescent, which meant that many of them were encountering romantic breakups, or the anticipation of them, for the first time. The intensity of early romantic experience, before the accumulation of breakups has built the emotional calluses that make subsequent ones more manageable, is in some ways more acute than the adult experience of the same situation. A song that confirms "this is hard" serves a real function for young listeners who might otherwise wonder whether the pain they feel is proportionate to the situation.
Permission to Mourn
Pop music has always served as a vehicle for emotional permission, a space where feelings that social convention requires you to manage in public can be fully experienced in private. Breakup songs give their listeners license to feel sad without time limit, to replay the feeling rather than moving quickly past it. The Partridge Family's commercial context, associated with television and teen culture, made this permission available to exactly the audience most likely to need it: young people navigating their first experiences of romantic loss.
The Cover Version as Validation
When an act as commercially prominent as the 1972 Partridge Family chose to record a particular song, the choice itself was a form of validation for the original material. Sedaka's composition, already a decade old by 1972, was confirmed as having sufficient cultural staying power to merit a new commercial life in a new format and for a new audience. That intergenerational transmission of a song's relevance is one of the more interesting processes in popular music, and the Partridge Family's hit represents one successful instance of it.
Endings as Cultural Constant
The universality of breakup songs across all genres, all decades, and all commercial contexts reflects a permanent feature of human experience: relationships end, and the ending hurts, and the hurt is real regardless of how many other people have felt the same thing before. A song that remains commercially viable across multiple generations of performers and listeners is a song that has accurately located a permanent feature of human emotional life rather than a historically specific one. "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" in the Partridge Family's 1972 version is one more confirmation that this particular emotional territory never runs out of visitors.
→ More from The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy
View all The Partridge Family Starring Shirley Jones Featuring David Cassidy hits →
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging