The 2020s File Feature
Fallin'
Fallin': Why Don't We and the Pandemic-Era Pivot to Emotional Pop Why Don't We released "Fallin'" in October 2020, a moment when the music industry was still…
01 The Story
Fallin': Why Don't We and the Pandemic-Era Pivot to Emotional Pop
Why Don't We released "Fallin'" in October 2020, a moment when the music industry was still navigating the profound disruptions caused by the global pandemic and when pop acts that had built their audiences through touring and live events were being forced to rethink their strategies for reaching fans. The song appeared as a standalone single during what the group described publicly as a period of creative reorientation, an acknowledgment that the boyband formula that had launched their careers needed to evolve if they were going to retain relevance as they aged into adulthood. "Fallin'" represented one significant step in that evolution.
Why Don't We formed in September 2016 when five solo social media and YouTube personalities, Jonah Marais, Corbyn Besson, Daniel Seavey, Jack Avery, and Zach Herron, were brought together with the assistance of management connected to Atlantic Records. All five members had been building independent digital followings before the group was formed, and their combination within a single act was designed to aggregate those audiences while also presenting something with the visual and musical appeal of traditional pop groups. The band signed with Atlantic Records and released its debut EP, Only the Beginning, in December 2016.
The group's early commercial trajectory was built largely on the kind of intense fan dedication typical of social media-native pop acts, with a base that followed every move across Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and YouTube. Their debut studio album, 8 Letters, released in August 2018, reached number six on the Billboard 200, a strong commercial showing that confirmed their ability to translate digital following into physical sales and streaming numbers. The album's title track reached the top twenty of the Billboard Adult Top 40 chart and established the group as a significant commercial presence in the pop landscape.
By 2020, however, the group was in a transitional period. Their second studio album, The Good Times and the Bad Ones, was in development and would ultimately be released in January 2021. "Fallin'" appeared in the months before that album as a preview of the direction they were taking, and it signaled a more mature sonic approach than their earlier material. The production was cleaner and more restrained than the maximalist pop of their debut era, and the vocal performances leaned into the kind of smooth, controlled harmonies that highlighted the group's genuine musical abilities rather than simply the charm and energy that had driven their early appeal.
The song debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 at number 37 during the chart week dated October 17, 2020, the highest single-week position of the track's chart life. The number 37 debut was a meaningful achievement for the group, representing their highest Hot 100 peak at that point and demonstrating that their fanbase was capable of driving strong opening-week streaming and download numbers even in the absence of the live touring and promotional infrastructure that had been central to their earlier promotional campaigns. The track spent one week on the Hot 100, which was typical for fan-driven pop acts whose audiences tend to concentrate their listening activity immediately around a release before moving on to the next piece of content.
The timing of "Fallin'" in the broader context of the pandemic pop landscape is significant. With concerts, touring, and traditional promotional appearances off the table, pop acts in 2020 were forced to rely almost entirely on social media, streaming platforms, and creative music video content to maintain connections with their audiences. Why Don't We adapted to this reality with facility, leveraging their social media expertise and the inherent intimacy of fan communities that had followed them since their YouTube and Vine days. The song's release was supported by substantial fan mobilization on TikTok, where the group's members were active participants in the platform culture that was, by mid-2020, beginning to exert enormous influence on music chart performance.
Why Don't We had been working with a range of songwriters and producers throughout their career, collaborating with professionals including Ed Sheeran, who co-wrote their 2019 single "I Don't Belong in This Club." The songwriting processes that produced "Fallin'" reflected the group's desire to take on more creative ownership of their material, a desire that would be articulated more fully in interviews around the The Good Times and the Bad Ones album campaign. The members spoke openly about wanting to move away from the purely collaborative model of their early career toward something that felt more authentically expressive of who they were becoming as artists and as individuals.
The group's YouTube channel had accumulated over four million subscribers by the time "Fallin'" was released, and the music video for the track generated meaningful view counts that contributed to the song's streaming performance. The visual treatment was relatively intimate compared to the more elaborate productions that characterized some of their earlier releases, a choice that fit the stripped-back emotional tone of the song and the constrained production environment of 2020. By the time "Fallin'" had accumulated approximately 52 million YouTube views, it had become one of the more enduring pieces of content in the group's catalog, a track that continued to attract new listeners through algorithmic recommendation even as it faded from active chart competition.
The Group's Continued Development
Why Don't We's trajectory after "Fallin'" was complicated by the very public tensions that emerged within the group during 2021, when several members spoke to media about difficult experiences with their management and broader industry pressures. These revelations were unusual in their candor and attracted significant media attention, leading to a protracted period of renegotiation, legal activity, and public discourse about the conditions faced by young artists within the music industry's machinery. The group eventually parted ways with Atlantic Records and their original management infrastructure, a separation that was painful but that ultimately allowed them to pursue the more autonomous creative direction that "Fallin'" had foreshadowed.
The song thus occupies an interesting position in the group's history, a creative achievement from just before a period of significant institutional turbulence, when the energy being invested in musical development was about to be redirected toward advocacy and self-determination. That context adds retrospective weight to a track that might otherwise be heard simply as a pleasant, commercially successful pop single.
02 Song Meaning
The Emotional Architecture of Fallin': Vulnerability and the Pop Boyband
"Fallin'" by Why Don't We operates within a well-established tradition of pop music centered on the experience of falling in love as something that happens to a person rather than something they choose, a sensation of involuntary descent that combines exhilaration and vulnerability in roughly equal measure. The specific emotional territory the song occupies is one that has fascinated songwriters across generations, the moment when attachment deepens beyond easy rationalization, when what began as a manageable interest or affection reveals itself as something far more consuming and significant. Why Don't We bring this familiar emotional landscape into the sonic vocabulary of 2020 pop with care and genuine feeling.
The central tension in the song is between the desire to maintain emotional control and the recognition that such control has already been lost. This is a fundamentally human experience, the dawning awareness that one's emotional state has outpaced one's capacity to manage it, and it is precisely the kind of experience that pop music is uniquely equipped to capture. The production choices support this thematic tension, with a sound that is simultaneously smooth and assured on the surface while containing undertones of urgency and emotional intensity that suggest something more complicated beneath.
The group's harmonic approach is central to the song's emotional effectiveness. Why Don't We had always distinguished themselves from other boyband acts partly through their genuine musical abilities, the capacity to construct and execute complex vocal harmonies rather than simply distributing individual lines among members. In "Fallin'," those harmonies create a sense of shared experience, as though the emotional journey being described is something the group has undergone collectively rather than individually. This is a clever formal choice that aligns with the group's identity as a collective while also speaking to a universal experience of emotional openness.
The imagery deployed around the concept of falling is worth unpacking carefully. Falling is inherently uncontrolled motion, movement without agency, the body subject to forces beyond its own direction. To describe falling in love using this language is to emphasize the degree to which romantic attachment can overwhelm the ordinary mechanisms of self-determination. For a young pop act whose audience consisted largely of teenagers and young adults navigating their own first experiences of serious emotional attachment, this framing would have resonated with immediate personal relevance. The song gave language and melody to something many listeners were experiencing without the words to articulate it.
The pandemic context of the song's release is not irrelevant to its emotional register. October 2020 was a moment of widespread social isolation, when many people's most significant emotional relationships were being conducted at a distance, mediated through screens, and therefore more intensely felt for being less easily consummated. A song about the overwhelming quality of romantic feeling arrived at a cultural moment when such feelings were perhaps more vivid for being harder to act upon. The longing implicit in "Fallin'" found an audience primed by circumstance to understand longing in unusually acute terms.
Why Don't We's position within the broader cultural category of the boyband is also relevant to the song's meaning. The boyband format has historically been criticized for packaging emotional expression in ways that feel manufactured or inauthentic, and part of what Why Don't We were attempting with their 2020 material was to push back against that perception by bringing more genuine personal investment to their recordings. "Fallin'" participates in that project by privileging emotional directness over performance, allowing the voices to carry the weight of the song rather than surrounding them with production elements that might serve as a kind of buffer between the listener and the raw emotional content.
The song also engages with the specific emotional experience of the early stages of love rather than the more settled, secure feelings of an established relationship. This developmental moment, when attachment is still new enough to feel unstable and uncertain, when the emotional stakes feel high precisely because so little has yet been confirmed or settled, is fertile territory for pop songwriting because it is a moment most listeners can relate to from their own experience. Why Don't We capture the particular quality of this early-stage vulnerability with notable precision, the combination of excitement and anxiety, desire and fear, that characterizes the threshold experience of falling for someone.
The production aesthetic of "Fallin'" also communicates meaning. The relative restraint of the arrangement, its preference for clean sonics and space over maximalist layering, suggests a kind of emotional honesty, a willingness to let the material breathe rather than drowning it in sonic ornamentation. This approach was consistent with broader trends in 2020 pop toward more stripped-back productions, but it also aligned with the group's stated desire to be taken more seriously as musicians and songwriters rather than simply as personalities. The sonic restraint is itself an argument for the authenticity of the emotion being expressed.
Ultimately, "Fallin'" asks its listeners to recognize and accept the reality of emotional vulnerability, to understand that losing control of one's feelings in the face of genuine connection is not a weakness but simply a dimension of human experience. That message, delivered with smooth harmonies and clean production, represents the song's most significant contribution, its invitation to the listener to acknowledge something that popular culture often pressures people to conceal or overcome rather than embrace.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging