The 2020s File Feature
Bad Reviews
Bad Reviews: Sabrina Carpenter Turns Criticism Into a Calling CardThere's a particular kind of courage required to address your critics directly in a song, t…
01 The Story
Bad Reviews: Sabrina Carpenter Turns Criticism Into a Calling Card
There's a particular kind of courage required to address your critics directly in a song, to take the thing that was meant to diminish you and set it to music. By early 2025, Sabrina Carpenter had accumulated enough critical scrutiny to write an entire album about it. She had crossed from Disney Channel actress to genuine pop force over several years of careful career development, and Short n' Sweet, her breakout 2024 album, had produced genuine radio hits and launched one of the most talked-about tours of the year. Bad Reviews arrived in 2025 as a dispatch from an artist who had read everything written about her and decided to make the reading material part of the work.
The Transition That Actually Worked
The former child-actor-to-pop-star pipeline has claimed a lot of careers over the years. The transition requires timing, artistic reinvention, and the ability to build a new audience while retaining the old one, a set of demands that few manage gracefully. Carpenter navigated it with unusual success, finding a vocal style that draws on classic pop and comedy-adjacent theatrical delivery, a combination that proved surprisingly durable. By 2025, she had become one of the most discussed pop artists of her generation, her lyrics analyzed in think pieces, her fashion documented obsessively, and her interviews widely shared. The attention had consequences, including the kind of critical overreaction that strong fame inevitably generates.
The Song's Premise and Sound
A song called Bad Reviews could go several directions: it could be defensive, it could be self-deprecating, it could be aggressively dismissive. Carpenter's version appears to land somewhere more interesting, using the premise as a vehicle for self-assurance rather than self-defense. The production style of her Short n' Sweet era leans into a warm, slightly vintage pop sound with wit built into the arrangements, and a track addressing critics would presumably maintain that light, knowing tone. It's a different approach from the earnest wounded-artist response, and for Carpenter's specific register, it's probably the right one.
Chart Performance
Bad Reviews debuted and peaked at number 87 on the Billboard Hot 100 on March 1, 2025, spending one week on the chart. The modest chart run is consistent with a follow-up single arriving in the long tail of a successful album cycle: the audience has largely settled into its streaming habits, and new material lands on the chart based on devoted-fan activity rather than broad radio programming. A number 87 peak still represents genuine chart presence for an era-closing single rather than a lead campaign track.
Carpenter's Growing Confidence
What the song's very existence demonstrates is a level of creative confidence that Carpenter had been building toward for years. The artists who can afford to address their critics directly in their material are the ones whose position is secure enough to absorb the meta-commentary without it becoming the only thing the song is about. By 2025, Carpenter was firmly in that category: established enough to be playful about her own public image, skilled enough to make the playfulness musically interesting rather than merely defensive.
Press Play and Let the Point Land
Carpenter's best moments on record share a quality of seeming effortless while being clearly deliberate, the kind of effect that takes considerable craft to produce. Bad Reviews offers that quality: a song that sounds casual but knows exactly what it's doing. Turn it on and let Carpenter make her case. The critics can wait.
“Bad Reviews” — Sabrina Carpenter's singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
What Bad Reviews Mean: Sabrina Carpenter on Criticism, Identity, and the Art of Not Caring
Every artist who achieves significant public attention eventually faces the question of what to do with the criticism that attention generates. Some ignore it, some internalize it, some address it directly. Sabrina Carpenter, whose public persona has always involved a knowing awareness of how she's being perceived, chose the third option and built a song around it.
The Public Gaze and the Artist's Response
Fame in the social media era is particularly saturating. Every performance is documented, every interview is clipped and analyzed, every sartorial choice becomes a think piece. For an artist who came of age entirely within this environment, the critical gaze is not a new experience but a chronic condition. Bad Reviews treats that condition with something between humor and defiance, using the language of consumer criticism (reviews, ratings, assessments) to reframe a more personal kind of scrutiny.
Confidence as a Mode of Being
The thematic core of the song seems to be a particular kind of self-possession: the capacity to receive negative judgment without letting it reorganize your sense of self. This is not naivety about criticism or rejection of accountability; it's the recognition that a significant portion of public criticism says more about the critic's expectations and anxieties than about the work being assessed. Carpenter's lyrical persona, across much of her catalog, is someone who has thought carefully about this distinction and chosen where to direct her energy accordingly.
Pop Music as Autobiography and Performance
One of the interesting complications of celebrity pop is that the audience can never be entirely sure where the persona ends and the person begins. When Carpenter sings about bad reviews, she's simultaneously describing a real experience, performing a response to that experience, and constructing a public version of herself that incorporates the criticism into her myth. The song is all three things at once, which gives it a layered quality that rewards repeated listening.
The Era Context
The early 2020s produced an unusual volume of songs by female pop artists explicitly about how they are perceived, critiqued, and categorized. From genre-straddling concept albums to direct singles addressing media narratives, the theme of the scrutinized woman responding to her scrutinizers has been one of the decade's defining artistic preoccupations. Bad Reviews joins that conversation with Carpenter's characteristic lightness of touch, choosing wit over grievance and arriving at something that feels empowering without requiring anyone to be the villain.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging