The 2020s File Feature
Criminals
The Final Entry: Criminals by Meghan Trainor Meghan Trainor had established herself as one of pop music's most reliable craftspeople since her 2014 breakthro…
01 The Story
The Final Entry: Criminals by Meghan Trainor
Meghan Trainor had established herself as one of pop music's most reliable craftspeople since her 2014 breakthrough, an artist with an acute sense of melody and a gift for writing songs that connected with mainstream audiences across multiple album cycles. By late 2024, she was promoting new music that pushed her into slightly different emotional territory: the full-throated, slightly rebellious celebration of the holiday season that the title Criminals suggested, arriving on the Billboard Hot 100 at the very end of November when the year's Christmas music was beginning to compete aggressively for radio attention and streaming share.
Meghan Trainor and the Long Game of Pop Craftsmanship
Trainor's career trajectory after All About That Bass had been one of sustained professional development rather than continued chart domination. She worked consistently, releasing albums and singles, producing and writing for other artists, building a catalog that demonstrated range: doo-wop-inflected pop, country-adjacent ballads, upbeat feel-good anthems, holiday material. By 2024, she was an artist whose commercial profile sat in the reliable adult contemporary and family-friendly pop space, where longevity matters more than breakthrough moments and where her particular skill set, honed over a decade of professional songwriting before she ever had a recording contract, translated naturally and consistently.
The December Pop Landscape
The Billboard Hot 100 in late November and December operates under particular pressures. The holiday music season drives significant chart activity as decades-old classics by Mariah Carey, Brenda Lee, and others return with massive streaming numbers, compressing the space available for new chart entries. A debut at number 100 in this environment represents genuine achievement; it means the record found enough immediate streaming traction to register against the heaviest seasonal competition the chart faces all year. Criminals landed in this environment on the week of November 23, 2024, competing not only against new releases but against perennial holiday records that have been accumulating streaming numbers for years.
Number 100 for One Week
The chart data for Criminals is brief: the track debuted and peaked at number 100 on the Billboard Hot 100 the week of November 23, 2024, spending 1 week on the chart. That position, at the precise bottom of the chart, is not a minor achievement; the Hot 100 represents the full landscape of commercial music activity in the United States, and placing at all requires genuine audience engagement. For a seasonal track competing against established holiday perennials and the full weight of late-year album releases, breaking onto the chart at all reflects the loyalty of Trainor's existing fanbase and the effectiveness of whatever promotional push accompanied the release.
Meghan Trainor's Relationship with the Holiday Music Tradition
Trainor had previously engaged with holiday music in ways that connected with her audience, and the release of Criminals in late 2024 fits a pattern of end-of-year activity that many pop artists have found commercially and artistically useful. The holiday season offers a specific emotional register, a combination of warmth, nostalgia, and celebratory energy, that suits Trainor's strengths as a writer and performer. Her ability to work within familiar pop frameworks while adding her own personality to them has always been one of her primary commercial assets, and the holiday format is one of the few remaining spaces in contemporary pop where that kind of craft-centered, personality-forward approach consistently finds an audience willing to engage on purely emotional terms.
The one-week chart life of Criminals reflects the competitive realities of the November pop landscape rather than anything about the quality of the record. In that particular corner of the year, even well-resourced releases by established artists can find the chart door slammed shut by a combination of holiday perennials and competing new projects. For fans of Trainor's brand of warm, craft-conscious pop, the track delivers exactly what her catalog has always promised. Press play and let the end of 2024 find its soundtrack.
“Criminals” — Meghan Trainor's singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Playful Rebellion of Criminals by Meghan Trainor
Meghan Trainor has always worked in a register of warmth and accessibility, writing songs that find their audience through directness rather than obscurity. Criminals applies that approach to a specific kind of playful transgression: the light-hearted claim to criminal status that functions not as genuine menace but as a celebration of whatever small pleasures and indulgences the holiday season makes available. The emotional register is fun, self-aware, and designed to make the listener feel like a cheerful co-conspirator.
The Tradition of Seasonal Misbehavior
Holiday pop has a long-running affection for the idea of breaking rules in benign ways: sneaking treats, staying up too late, spending too freely, being the kind of slightly reckless version of yourself that the celebration of the season seems to license. Criminals draws on this tradition, using the language of transgression to describe holiday excess in a way that is entirely unthreatening. The framing is knowing; Trainor understands that her audience is in on the joke, that calling yourself a criminal for eating too many cookies or indulging in seasonal sentimentality is funny precisely because it is so far from the literal meaning of the word.
Meghan Trainor's Gift for Communal Feeling
One of Trainor's most consistent strengths as a songwriter is her ability to construct lyrics that create a sense of shared experience and collective permission. Her most successful work invites listeners into a "we," a feeling of being part of a group that validates the specific pleasure or comfort the song is describing. Criminals employs that technique in the holiday context: the listener is included in the transgression, made to feel that their own seasonal indulgences are part of a community rather than a private weakness. This inclusivity is central to how Trainor's music functions emotionally and to why her audience maintains its loyalty across multiple album cycles.
The Seasonal Pop Context
Arriving in the final weeks of November 2024, Criminals entered a pop landscape crowded with holiday classics and new seasonal contenders. The emotional work that holiday pop performs is specific: it provides permission to feel warmth, nostalgia, and communal joy in a cultural moment that endorses those feelings explicitly. Trainor's track participates in that work while adding a slightly more irreverent angle, the suggestion that genuine seasonal celebration involves a certain cheerful willingness to abandon normal restraint. That angle suits her artistic personality, which has always mixed sincerity with self-awareness in proportions that feel genuinely earned rather than calculated.
Pop Craft and the Value of Direct Emotion
The broader argument that Criminals makes, implicitly and without any pretension to depth it does not possess, is that direct, unironic emotional engagement with seasonal pleasure is worthwhile. In a pop landscape that sometimes prizes complexity and ambiguity above clarity, there is genuine value in a song that simply wants to make its audience feel good about feeling good. Trainor has built her career on that proposition, and the holiday format is perhaps its natural home: a moment when the culture explicitly endorses the kind of warm, uncomplicated pleasure that her music has always been designed to deliver.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging