The 2020s File Feature
Is It A Crime
Is It A Crime — Mariah the Scientist and Kali Uchis in Orbit TogetherTwo Artists Who Rewrote the RulebookSomewhere in the summer of 2025, between the algorit…
01 The Story
Is It A Crime — Mariah the Scientist and Kali Uchis in Orbit Together
Two Artists Who Rewrote the Rulebook
Somewhere in the summer of 2025, between the algorithmic chaos of streaming platforms and the increasingly compressed attention spans of the global audience, two of contemporary R&B's most distinctively individual voices found each other on a track. Mariah the Scientist had built her reputation over several years on a raw emotional directness that borrowed from classic soul while refusing to sound nostalgic; Kali Uchis had arrived from a completely different angle, mixing Colombian heritage with downtown Los Angeles aesthetics and a voice that could float above a production or cut straight through it. Is It A Crime brought those two sensibilities into the same room and asked what might happen.
Mariah the Scientist's Ascent
The Atlanta-based artist had developed a devoted following through a series of projects that engaged unflinchingly with romantic obsession, vulnerability, and the specific pain of modern emotional entanglement. Her approach resisted the polished corporate R&B that dominated playlists in the mid-2010s; she had a rawness that felt calibrated to a generation of listeners who found emotional armor aesthetically exhausting. By 2025 she had accumulated chart experience, critical credibility, and the kind of cult following that tends to translate into sustained streaming numbers rather than short-term pop spikes.
Kali Uchis as the Perfect Collaborator
Uchis had been one of the most consistently interesting artists in the space between R&B, Latin pop, and indie soul for nearly a decade by the time this track appeared. Her ability to shift registers, from ethereal and detached to intensely present, made her an ideal foil for a song built around emotional interrogation. The title Is It A Crime asks a question that suits both artists perfectly: it's the kind of lyric that requires a voice capable of making uncertainty sound like a complete emotional state, and both singers do exactly that.
A Four-Week Chart Run
The track debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on August 16, 2025, entering at position 62. After briefly dipping, it climbed to a peak of number 59 on September 6, spending a total of four weeks on the chart before fading at position 84. Four weeks of Hot 100 presence for a collaboration between two artists who operate primarily in the R&B and alternative-pop space is a meaningful result, reflecting both the genuine enthusiasm of their combined fanbases and the kind of word-of-mouth velocity that the streaming era can generate around a well-constructed track.
What the Collaboration Signals
Collaborations that cross genre and demographic lines are increasingly common in contemporary music, but Is It A Crime stands apart from purely calculated pairings because both artists bring genuine artistic weight to the track. Neither is coasting on reputation; both are performing at the intersection of their actual creative preoccupations. That quality gives the song a staying power beyond its chart run. Press play and let the question hang in the air where it belongs.
“Is It A Crime” — Mariah the Scientist & Kali Uchis's singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
Is It A Crime — The Emotional Logic of Impossible Questions
A Question as a Declaration
The most efficient lyrical move a songwriter can make is to pose a question that is really a declaration in disguise. Is It A Crime operates on this principle; the interrogative frame signals uncertainty but the emotional content underneath is urgent and fully formed. The question being asked isn't genuinely open: the narrator knows exactly what they feel and suspects that feeling it this intensely might be a transgression. That structure gives the song its tension.
Obsession as the Central Emotion
Both Mariah the Scientist and Kali Uchis have built significant portions of their artistic identities around exploring the less comfortable dimensions of romantic attachment: the moments when desire becomes consuming, when caring about someone threatens to overwhelm the self-possession that modern culture insists we maintain. Is It A Crime exists in that emotional territory. It examines the experience of feeling too much, of loving in a way that leaves you exposed, and asks whether that exposure is something to be ashamed of or simply the price of being fully alive to someone else.
The Cultural Context of Radical Vulnerability
In a pop cultural landscape that had spent several years alternating between emotional armor and performative openness, a track that engages directly with genuine vulnerability hit a particular nerve. The early-to-mid 2020s saw a growing audience appetite for music that acknowledged emotional complexity without resolving it neatly; listeners were increasingly suspicious of songs that tied romantic suffering into redemptive bows. Is It A Crime refuses that resolution, and that refusal is a large part of what made it resonate with its audience across four weeks on the Billboard Hot 100.
Two Voices, One Emotional Position
The collaboration structure mirrors the content in an interesting way. When two voices ask the same question from their distinct registers, the effect is to suggest that this particular emotional experience transcends individual personality; it's not one person's idiosyncratic obsession but something more widely shared. Mariah the Scientist's rawer edges and Uchis's more controlled, floating quality create a composite portrait that covers more emotional ground than either could manage alone.
The Resonance of Moral Framing
Casting emotional intensity in moral terms, asking whether loving someone deeply can be considered a crime, is a move that connects the song to a long tradition of romantic music that reaches back through soul and blues to the earliest popular forms. The moral framing elevates the feeling; it suggests that what the narrator experiences has weight and consequence, that the heart's demands are serious business deserving serious examination. That seriousness, delivered through the particular vocal chemistry of two genuinely gifted performers, is what keeps the song working.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging