The 2020s File Feature
Thats What I Want
That's What I Want: Lil Nas X's Longest-Running Billboard Entry Lil Nas X, born Montero Lamar Hill on April 9, 1999, in Lithia Springs, Georgia, first demons…
01 The Story
That's What I Want: Lil Nas X's Longest-Running Billboard Entry
Lil Nas X, born Montero Lamar Hill on April 9, 1999, in Lithia Springs, Georgia, first demonstrated his capacity for extraordinary chart performance with "Old Town Road," which set the all-time Billboard Hot 100 record for consecutive weeks at number one when it occupied the top position for 19 weeks in 2019. The success of that track established him as one of the most commercially significant artists of his generation and raised expectations for his subsequent releases to a degree that few artists could realistically meet. "That's What I Want," released in late 2021, demonstrated that his commercial longevity was not a one-song phenomenon, charting for 45 weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 and reaching a peak position of number 8.
"That's What I Want" was released on September 17, 2021, as the third single from his debut album Montero, which arrived on the same date. The album also featured the singles "Montero (Call Me by Your Name)" and "Industry Baby," the latter a collaboration with Jack Harlow that reached number one on the Hot 100. The simultaneous commercial success of multiple singles from the album confirmed that Lil Nas X had constructed a full album that could sustain chart activity across multiple tracks rather than relying on a single focal point.
Production and Sound
The production of "That's What I Want" was handled primarily by Take a Daytrip, the production duo of David Biral and Denzel Baptiste who had previously worked with Lil Nas X on "Panini" and other early releases. The track occupies a sonic space between pop-punk, country pop, and melodic hip-hop, reflecting Lil Nas X's consistent interest in genre hybridization and his refusal to settle into a single commercial lane. The guitar tones reference pop-punk's emotional directness while the vocal performance draws on R&B and hip-hop traditions, and the result is a song that sounds simultaneously familiar and formally unusual.
Lil Nas X has described the song as expressing a genuine longing for romantic partnership and emotional support, a desire for a relationship that is consistently present rather than intermittent or conditional. This thematic content, relatively straightforward compared to some of his more conceptually elaborate releases, gave the song a broad emotional accessibility that contributed to its extended chart presence. The directness of the song's emotional premise made it easy to share as a statement of feeling, which drove significant streaming activity on platforms like TikTok and Spotify.
Chart Performance in Detail
"That's What I Want" debuted at number 10 on October 2, 2021, and then demonstrated a chart pattern more typical of slow-burning pop hits than of songs that peak immediately on debut. After an initial dip to positions 24 and 26 in its second and third weeks, the song gradually reasserted itself and climbed back toward its ultimate peak. It reached its best position of number 8 during the week of April 2, 2022, more than six months after its initial release, a trajectory that reflected organic, sustained streaming activity rather than a promotional burst followed by rapid decline.
The 45-week chart run placed it among the longest-charting songs of Lil Nas X's career, a remarkable achievement given that "Old Town Road" had itself charted for an extended period and that his subsequent work "Montero (Call Me by Your Name)" had also demonstrated significant longevity. The pattern across his catalog suggested a consistent ability to generate music that remained in cultural circulation well beyond its initial promotional window.
Music Video and Visual Strategy
The music video for "That's What I Want" was directed by Gibson Hazard and depicted Lil Nas X in a college sports context, playing for a football team, navigating the social world of campus life, and pursuing a same-sex romantic relationship with a teammate. The video's exploration of gay romance within the specific social environment of college athletics, an institution with historically complex relationships to LGBTQ+ identity, generated significant media attention and discussion about representation in sports contexts. The video accumulated hundreds of millions of views across platforms and became one of the more discussed visual pieces of his broader campaign for the Montero album.
The choice to situate the romantic narrative within college football specifically, rather than in a more obviously queer-friendly social context, was understood as a deliberate artistic and political statement. Lil Nas X has consistently used his music videos to advance conversations about queer visibility in spaces where it has historically been absent or suppressed, and the college athletics setting served this purpose particularly effectively given the ongoing debates within organized sports about LGBTQ+ inclusion and representation.
Grammy Recognition
At the 64th Grammy Awards in 2022, "That's What I Want" received a nomination for Best Pop Solo Performance. While it did not win in that category, the nomination confirmed the Recording Academy's recognition of the song's commercial and artistic significance. Lil Nas X's broader Grammy relationship had been complicated by the exclusion of "Old Town Road" from country categories in 2020, making the subsequent nominations for his pop work an interesting reflection of how the industry had accommodated his genre-resistant approach.
The song's YouTube view count of approximately 172 million reflects the sustained global interest it generated across its extended chart life and beyond, confirming its status as a significant commercial release within his catalog rather than a transitional or secondary work.
02 Song Meaning
Longing, Queer Desire, and the Politics of Visibility in "That's What I Want"
"That's What I Want" occupies an unusual position within Lil Nas X's catalog in that it is, at its core, a relatively straightforward love song. Where tracks like "Montero (Call Me by Your Name)" and "Industry Baby" deployed elaborate conceptual frameworks and provocative visual strategies to engage with questions of queer identity, sexuality, and social constraint, "That's What I Want" addresses the desire for reciprocal romantic love in language that is direct without being abstract or conceptually elaborate. This directness is not a diminishment of its thematic ambitions but a different mode of pursuing them.
The song describes a specific emotional need: the desire for a partner who is consistently, reliably present, who provides the kind of emotional sustenance that is not contingent on external circumstances or variable moods. This longing for stable romantic reciprocity is one of the oldest and most universal subjects in popular song, and Lil Nas X's decision to express it as a queer desire, without qualification or apology, is itself a political act even when the musical surface remains emotionally accessible.
Queer Visibility in Mainstream Pop
The significance of "That's What I Want" in terms of queer representation operates on several levels simultaneously. At the most basic level, a song expressing same-sex romantic desire that achieves peak chart positions in the top ten of the Billboard Hot 100 and spends 45 weeks on the chart represents a form of mainstream inclusion that was not available to queer artists in most of the Hot 100's history. The commercial success of the song is itself evidence of cultural change.
At a deeper level, the song's emotional accessibility demonstrates that the specific character of queer desire, the particular experience of longing for a same-sex partner within a social world that has historically not acknowledged or validated that longing, can be communicated through popular music to a broad audience without requiring that audience to have prior familiarity with queer experience. The emotional content of the song resonates across sexual identities because the underlying emotional state, the desire for love that is reciprocated and sustained, is not exclusive to any particular orientation.
Genre Hybridity and Emotional Communication
The sonic environment of "That's What I Want" brings together genre elements that carry different emotional associations, and this hybridity is itself meaningful in the context of Lil Nas X's artistic identity. The pop-punk textures invoke a tradition of emotional directness and adolescent longing that has been central to the genre since its emergence in the 1990s. The melodic hip-hop elements connect the song to contemporary Black musical traditions. The country undertones reference the genre crossover that first brought Lil Nas X to widespread public attention.
By operating across these genre boundaries simultaneously, the song implicitly argues that the emotional need it describes belongs to no single community or musical tradition. The desire for love, expressed across genres, becomes a universal emotional claim rather than a culturally specific one, and this universalism is both a rhetorical strategy and a genuine musical achievement.
The Music Video's Social Commentary
The music video's college football setting added a specific layer of social commentary to the song's broader thematic concerns. College athletics, and particularly football as the most financially and culturally prominent college sport in the United States, represents a social environment in which normative masculinity has historically been enforced through both formal and informal mechanisms. The depiction of a same-sex romance within this environment functions as an argument about the right to belong, to inhabit spaces that have historically excluded queer people through social pressure if not explicit policy.
The video's treatment of this romance is notably non-sensationalistic. It depicts the emotional arc of attraction, connection, and ultimately disappointment with a realism that avoids both the eroticization and the tragedy that have frequently characterized mainstream media representations of gay relationships. The protagonist's experience of rejection is handled with emotional honesty rather than dramatic excess, and this restraint gives the narrative a mundane authenticity that is itself a form of normalization. Queer relationships, the video suggests, include the same emotional range of joy, hope, and ordinary disappointment that characterizes all human romantic experience.
The extended chart life of "That's What I Want," reaching its peak of number 8 more than six months after its initial release, suggests that listeners returned to the song repeatedly over an extended period, which is the most reliable indicator that a piece of music is doing genuine emotional work for its audience rather than simply satisfying an initial curiosity. The song became part of the emotional vocabulary of its listeners in ways that sustained commercial engagement well beyond what promotional activity alone could account for.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging