The 2020s File Feature
Montero (Call Me By Your Name)
Montero (Call Me By Your Name): Lil Nas X and the Chart-Topping Cultural Reckoning "Montero (Call Me By Your Name)" is a hip-hop and pop hybrid single by Ame…
01 The Story
Montero (Call Me By Your Name): Lil Nas X and the Chart-Topping Cultural Reckoning
"Montero (Call Me By Your Name)" is a hip-hop and pop hybrid single by American artist Lil Nas X, released on March 26, 2021, through Columbia Records. The song debuted at number one on the Billboard Hot 100, making Lil Nas X the first openly gay Black artist to debut at the top of the chart. The achievement was commercial and historic simultaneously, arriving at a moment when the cultural conversation around LGBTQ+ representation in mainstream hip-hop was particularly active. The song takes its title from the artist's birth name, Montero Lamar Hill, and its subtitle is a reference to the 2017 Italian-American romantic film Call Me by Your Name, which depicted a same-sex relationship with sensitivity and emotional depth.
Written by Lil Nas X, Denzel Baptiste, David Biral, Omer Fedi, and Roy Lenzo, and produced by Take a Daytrip and Omer Fedi, the track operates across genre lines with characteristic fluidity. The production incorporates elements of Spanish guitar, trap percussion, and pop melody, creating a layered sound that resists easy categorization. This genre-crossing was not incidental: Lil Nas X had established himself through "Old Town Road," one of the best-selling singles of all time, as an artist who treated genre classification as an obstacle to be circumvented rather than a parameter to work within. "Montero" continued that approach while expanding the emotional stakes considerably beyond what "Old Town Road" had addressed.
The music video, directed by Tanu Muino and Lil Nas X himself, was released simultaneously with the audio and became one of the most discussed music videos of 2021. The visual concepts were elaborate and deliberately provocative, drawing on imagery from classical mythology, Renaissance religious iconography, and contemporary club culture. The video depicted a Garden of Eden sequence, a gladiatorial arena, a descent through layers toward a hellish realm, and concluded with an image of Lil Nas X giving a lap dance to a horned devil figure before snapping the devil's neck and taking his crown. The visual sequence was clearly constructed as a series of deliberate provocations, engaging with religious imagery in ways that generated immediate controversy.
The response to the video and its surrounding context was intense and multifaceted. Conservative commentators and religious figures condemned the video's imagery as blasphemous, and their objections were amplified enormously by social media. Lil Nas X responded to the criticism through social media with characteristic directness and wit, using Twitter and other platforms to address his detractors with a combination of humor, emotional honesty, and pointed observation. His responses became news stories in themselves, extending the cultural conversation well beyond the music industry into general public discourse.
The controversy was intensified by the simultaneous release of a limited-edition "Satan Shoes" collaboration with art collective MSCHF, which were modified Nike Air Max 97 sneakers containing, according to the creators, a drop of human blood in the sole alongside other occult imagery. Nike filed a lawsuit against MSCHF over the unauthorized use of its trademark, and the legal dispute added a commercial and legal dimension to the controversy that had begun as a cultural and religious argument. A court order required the recall and destruction of the limited-edition shoes, and the episode generated coverage in mainstream news outlets far removed from music journalism.
Amid the controversy, the song's actual musical and commercial performance was exceptional. "Montero" debuted at number one and spent multiple weeks in the top ten of the Hot 100. It was certified multi-platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America and performed strongly on streaming platforms globally. The controversy, rather than diminishing commercial interest, appeared to amplify it, as listeners who might not have discovered the song through music channels alone encountered it through news coverage of the cultural debate surrounding its release.
At the Grammy Awards, "Montero (Call Me By Your Name)" received nominations in major categories including Song of the Year, Record of the Year, and Best Melodic Rap Performance, reflecting the Recording Academy's assessment of the song as a significant artistic achievement regardless of the controversy that surrounded it. The nominations placed Lil Nas X in competition with the most commercially and critically recognized music of the year, a positioning that would have seemed improbable for an openly gay Black hip-hop artist just a few years earlier.
Lil Nas X delivered the song in a live television performance at the BET Awards in June 2021 that became one of the most discussed live performance moments of the year. The choreography and staging incorporated elements of the music video's visual language and reinforced the song's central themes in a live context that reached an enormous television audience. The performance was widely praised for its ambition and its willingness to bring the song's full conceptual vision to a mainstream broadcast platform without dilution.
In the broader cultural narrative, "Montero" represented a significant moment in the ongoing expansion of mainstream American pop and hip-hop's willingness to fully embrace and celebrate LGBTQ+ identity rather than merely tolerating it. The song did not merely exist in the commercial mainstream: it debuted at its summit, which represented a form of cultural legitimacy that previous generations of LGBTQ+ artists in hip-hop had been denied. Lil Nas X's insistence on making his identity central rather than incidental to his public artistic persona, and the commercial reward that followed, changed what seemed possible for openly queer artists in American hip-hop.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning of "Montero (Call Me By Your Name)": Identity, Defiance, and the Reclaiming of Shame
"Montero (Call Me By Your Name)" is a song about sexual and romantic desire between men, written and performed by an openly gay Black artist at a time when that combination remained genuinely rare at the top of the American mainstream music charts. The title uses Lil Nas X's birth name, Montero Lamar Hill, which transforms the song into a direct autobiographical statement. The narrator is not a fictional character. The emotions being described are not abstract or generalized. This specificity is deliberate and significant: it refuses the coded ambiguity that LGBTQ+ artists have historically sometimes used to navigate mainstream acceptance, insisting instead on complete visibility.
The reference in the subtitle to the film Call Me by Your Name is also meaningful. That film, directed by Luca Guadagnino from André Aciman's novel, depicted a same-sex relationship with a level of tenderness and cultural legitimacy that represented a new kind of mainstream recognition for queer romantic experience. By invoking it in his title, Lil Nas X placed his song within a tradition of thoughtful, serious engagement with queer desire rather than framing it as transgression or novelty. The cultural register of the reference says: this is a real feeling, with a legitimate artistic lineage, and it deserves the same serious treatment that the film received.
The music video extended the song's meaning into elaborate visual territory. Its imagery of Eden, temptation, and descent into a place of judgment engaged directly with the religious frameworks that have historically been used to condemn same-sex desire. The imagery of hell, devils, and punishment was not presented with horror or shame but with glamour and confidence, transforming the symbols of condemnation into symbols of power. When Lil Nas X gives the devil a lap dance before taking his crown, the visual language is clear: the narrative in which same-sex desire leads to damnation is being claimed, inhabited, and overturned. The threat of hell becomes an invitation, and the response to that threat is not fear but creative exuberance.
Lil Nas X made the meaning of this gesture explicit in his public communications around the release. In social media posts, he addressed critics directly, and in a widely circulated open letter to his younger self, he described the emotional journey of growing up gay and Black, feeling shame about his identity, and ultimately choosing full visibility over comfortable concealment. The personal dimension of "Montero" was not incidental: the song was a direct product of processing that history, and the courage of the artistic choices in the video reflected the courage of the personal ones that preceded them.
The song's title and subtitle together perform a specific function: they insist on naming. Calling himself by his real name, invoking a film that also turns on the act of naming, the artist refuses the anonymity and indirection that social pressure often encourages in LGBTQ+ artists navigating mainstream spaces. To name oneself fully, in the context of a song about desires that have been historically subject to shame and punishment, is itself a political and personal act. The meaning of "Montero" is, at one level, simply that this is who the artist is, named and visible, without apology.
The controversy that surrounded the release, while not anticipated to quite the scale it reached, was part of what made the song culturally significant. The intensity of the reaction to the video's imagery demonstrated that the territory it was engaging with was genuinely contested in American culture, that the images of queerness and religious symbol systems were still charged with real social tension. Lil Nas X's response to that controversy, which was consistently witty, warm, and unapologetic, modeled a way of existing in public visibility that was new in mainstream hip-hop: comfortable in one's identity, unintimidated by hostility, willing to engage critics directly without surrendering any ground.
For listeners who shared the artist's experience of navigating LGBTQ+ identity within communities where that identity is subject to strong social pressure, "Montero" carried a meaning that extended well beyond its musical content. It was evidence that full visibility and commercial success were not incompatible, that it was possible to debut at number one on the Billboard Hot 100 while being exactly who you are. That evidence mattered, and the song's cultural significance rests at least as much on what its success demonstrated as on what its music and imagery expressed.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging