The 2020s File Feature
Last Christmas
Last Christmas: Lauren Spencer-Smith and the Cover Song as Emotional ReinventionA Song That Refuses to Stay in One DecadeGeorge Michael and Andrew Ridgeley w…
01 The Story
Last Christmas: Lauren Spencer-Smith and the Cover Song as Emotional Reinvention
A Song That Refuses to Stay in One Decade
George Michael and Andrew Ridgeley wrote and recorded Last Christmas in 1984 for their group Wham!, and in the four decades since its release it has become one of the most durable and beloved seasonal songs in the popular canon. The original recording was confoundingly modern for its time, built on synthesizers and drum machines but suffused with a genuine emotional ache that gave it staying power long after the production style dated. Every Christmas season, without fail, it reenters the cultural bloodstream, replayed on radio, reused in films, and re-recorded by a new generation of artists who find in its melody something that still has things to say. Lauren Spencer-Smith's version arrived in December 2022 as part of exactly that tradition.
The Canadian Singer Finding Her Moment
Lauren Spencer-Smith had come to wider attention in 2022 following her appearance on American Idol, where her powerful voice and emotional directness made her one of the season's most memorable performers. Her original material, particularly the breakout track Fingers Crossed, demonstrated that she could take romantic disillusionment and channel it into something accessible and moving. When she turned to Last Christmas, she brought that same quality: a voice substantial enough to carry the song's emotional weight without the ironic distance that some contemporary covers apply to older material as a protective layer.
Climbing the Chart Through the Holiday Season
The cover debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on December 10, 2022 and spent five weeks on the chart, climbing steadily to its peak of number 72 on January 7, 2023. The trajectory is notable: rather than debuting high on first-week buzz and then fading, Spencer-Smith's version built consistently through December and into the New Year, suggesting that listeners were actively seeking it out over the holiday period rather than simply encountering it passively. A peak in the first week of January, when the holiday chart bump has typically faded, indicates genuine sustained interest from her audience.
What a Great Cover Does
A cover recording earns its existence by doing something the original didn't, whether by opening the song to a new audience, by finding an emotional angle that the original left unexplored, or simply by providing a contemporary listener with a performance that feels immediate rather than archival. Spencer-Smith's version emphasized the raw vulnerability in the lyric: the narrator's combination of grief and continued susceptibility to the person who hurt them is content that a young woman's voice inflects differently than it did filtered through the sleek production of the Wham! original. The song's core emotion, the specific pain of associating a season with someone who is no longer present, translated without loss.
A Twenty-Two-Year-Old and a Forty-Year-Old Song
One of the pleasures of watching a relatively new artist take on a song with deep cultural history is seeing what they bring to it from their own experience and artistic sensibility. Last Christmas is a song that most people over thirty have significant personal associations with, and Spencer-Smith's version creates a fresh point of entry for a younger audience that might know the song primarily as background music in shopping centers. Press play and you'll hear someone treating a classic with the seriousness it deserves while making it genuinely her own.
“Last Christmas” — Lauren Spencer-Smith's singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
Last Christmas: The Seasonal Wound That Won't Close
The Geography of Holiday Heartbreak
Christmas is a particularly brutal backdrop for romantic loss. The forced festivity, the insistence on communal warmth and togetherness, throws into sharp relief anything that deviates from the seasonal ideal. A person who is grieving a relationship during the holiday season is simultaneously surrounded by the symbols of what they're missing and expected to participate in celebrations they don't feel. Last Christmas understood this dynamic with unusual precision when George Michael wrote it in 1984, and the song has retained that precision through every subsequent re-recording. Lauren Spencer-Smith's 2022 version is, in this respect, as emotionally accurate as the original.
The Gift Given Carelessly
The central lyrical image, the heart given as a gift and discarded by someone who didn't value it, is a compact metaphor for one of the more specific varieties of romantic pain: the experience of having been vulnerable and open with a person who treated that openness as ordinary or even inconvenient. What makes the song cut deeply is not the grand gesture of the heartbreak but its casualness: the object of affection didn't maliciously destroy the narrator's heart, they simply gave it away to someone else. Carelessness is sometimes harder to recover from than cruelty because it admits of no satisfying narrative of villains and victims.
The Decision to Try Again
What's underappreciated about the song's lyrical arc is its forward momentum. The narrator isn't simply lamenting the past; they're making a decision. The promise that this year the heart will be given to someone special is an act of will, a refusal to close off after one bad experience. For a song that reads, on the surface, as melancholic holiday fare, that resilience gives it a quietly optimistic undertone. The wound is real, but so is the capacity to heal and risk again.
Why Young Voices Find It
Each generation of young singers who covers Last Christmas is, in part, processing the song's emotional content through their own experience of first heartbreaks and first attempts to move on. Spencer-Smith's version in particular, coming from a twenty-one-year-old with a voice that conveys both power and exposure, channels the song's combination of pain and resolve through a sensibility that connects it to the emotional reality of a new audience. The best covers don't simply replicate; they reactivate.
A Perennial in the Best Sense
A song that continues to attract serious new interpretations forty years after its original release isn't merely popular; it's structurally true. Last Christmas describes something that recurs reliably in human experience, and that reliability is exactly why it keeps being sung. Spencer-Smith found what the song had to say to her, and in saying it clearly, ensured it had something to say to a new generation of listeners as well.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging