The 2020s File Feature
Carnival
Carnival — ¥$: Kanye West Ty Dolla $ign Featuring Rich The Kid Playboi CartiChaos Dressed as MaximalismEarly 2024 found Kanye West and Ty Dolla $ign unveilin…
01 The Story
Carnival — ¥$: Kanye West & Ty Dolla $ign Featuring Rich The Kid & Playboi Carti
Chaos Dressed as Maximalism
Early 2024 found Kanye West and Ty Dolla $ign unveiling Vultures 1, a collaborative album that had been the subject of months of anticipation, controversy, and industry uncertainty before it finally materialized. Carnival was its centerpiece in commercial terms: absurdist, dense, built around a sample that felt simultaneously archaic and completely suited to the moment, with four distinct artist personalities colliding in its four-minute runtime. The track captured something essential about where rap's sonic ambitions had arrived by 2024.
The Sample at the Core
The production on Carnival draws heavily on a sample that gives the track its Big Top feeling, all clanking percussion and unsettled energy underneath the verses. This was the kind of production instinct that had defined Kanye's career since his earliest work: finding unlikely sources and bending them into something that felt both familiar and genuinely strange. The result was a track that felt maximalist in intent but actually achieved its effects through tension rather than sheer volume.
Four Voices, One Atmosphere
The combination of Kanye's characteristic rapping, Ty Dolla $ign's melodic contributions, Rich The Kid's verse, and Playboi Carti's distinctive delivery created a collective performance where contrast was the point. These are artists who operate in adjacent but distinct sonic worlds, and the track's genius, such as it is, lies in how it refuses to smooth those differences out. The friction between the performers is the energy source.
A Number 1 That Climbed Slowly
Carnival debuted at number 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 on February 24, 2024, and it spent the following weeks climbing rather than falling, which is unusual behavior for any song at that chart level. It reached number 1 on March 16, 2024, after spending four weeks on the chart. That ascent reflected growing streaming consumption as more listeners caught up with the album and the track spread through social media. The song also logged over 41 million YouTube views, demonstrating its reach beyond the core fanbase.
Kanye in 2024: The Album in Context
The release of Vultures 1 was complicated by the controversy surrounding Kanye West's public behavior and statements in the preceding years, which had made major label and major platform relationships difficult to sustain. The album was released independently, and its commercial success, including Carnival's number 1, demonstrated that the audience for his music had not disappeared even as the institutional infrastructure around it had shifted. Whether that success represented genuine artistic rehabilitation or simply the resilience of a large fanbase was a question the culture spent considerable energy debating through 2024.
Put it on in a setting where the speakers can carry the low end; the track was made to fill a room.
“Carnival” — ¥$'s singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning Behind Carnival
The Carnival as Metaphor
The title is doing real work. A carnival is a place of controlled chaos, of entertainment that exists at the edge of comfort, where the rules of ordinary life are suspended and spectacle is the currency. Carnival as a track operates within that metaphor deliberately: the production creates a space that feels unstable, carnivalesque in the literal sense, and the performances lean into the disorientation rather than trying to resolve it. This is music designed to feel like being somewhere slightly overwhelming.
Bravado and Its Discontents
The lyrical content across the track's verses is largely concerned with status, wealth, and the performance of dominance that has always been central to rap's rhetorical tradition. Each of the four featured voices approaches this material differently, from Carti's near-abstract vocal styling to Kanye's more narrative ambitions, but the underlying subject is consistent: the assertion of an elevated position and the social display that accompanies it. The carnival setting gives all of this a slight edge of unreality, as though the heights being claimed are also being gently mocked.
Ty Dolla $ign's Melodic Function
Ty Dolla $ign's contribution to the track is partly about tonal balance: he brings a melodic fluency that softens the harder edges of the production and the more abrasive verses around him. His presence on Vultures 1 more broadly was about this function; his versatility as a vocalist gave the album range that a single-artist project might not have achieved. On Carnival specifically, his sections provide something like relief from the surrounding intensity.
Cultural Reception: The Complicated Artist Question
The track arrived at a moment when listeners were actively negotiating what it meant to enjoy music from artists whose public conduct had been controversial. Carnival forced that conversation because it was genuinely compelling on its own merits: catchy, strange, well-constructed, and undeniably attention-getting. For many listeners, the song existed in a separate space from its creator's biography; for others, separating those things was not possible. Both responses were reasonable and the culture held them simultaneously.
Replay Value and the Absurd
Part of what has kept the track in rotation beyond its chart run is its genuine weirdness. In an era of sleek, algorithmic pop production, Carnival sounds genuinely handmade and odd. The sample creates a mood that nothing else in 2024 radio was generating, and that distinctiveness has real staying power. Songs that sound unlike anything else tend to age better than those that simply execute a formula with precision.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging