The 2020s File Feature
Talking
Talking — ¥$: Kanye West Ty Dolla $ign Featuring North WestThe Unusual Album and Its Unusual MomentEarly 2024 brought one of the stranger commercial events i…
01 The Story
Talking — ¥$: Kanye West & Ty Dolla $ign Featuring North West
The Unusual Album and Its Unusual Moment
Early 2024 brought one of the stranger commercial events in recent pop history: the release of Vultures 1, the collaborative album by Kanye West (performing as Ye) and Ty Dolla $ign under the joint billing ¥$. The album's journey to release had been prolonged and complicated, shaped by Ye's public controversies and the difficulty of securing distribution. That it arrived at all, and that it moved significant numbers when it did, speaks to the enduring commercial gravity of one of the most polarizing figures in modern music. Talking was among the tracks that made it onto the charts from that release.
Kanye West in 2024: Gravity Despite Everything
By early 2024, the question surrounding Ye was no longer whether he remained culturally significant but how that significance could coexist with the controversies that had followed him since 2022. For a substantial portion of his audience, the music existed in a separate compartment from the public persona; for others, that separation had become impossible. Vultures 1 landed into that divided audience and still performed, which tells you something about the depth of the loyalty his catalog had built over two decades. Ty Dolla $ign's role in the project went well beyond featured artist; he was a genuine co-equal, and his presence gave the album a melodic and harmonic richness that balanced Ye's more abrasive instincts.
North West's Appearance
Among the most talked-about elements of the Vultures 1 project was the participation of North West, Ye's eldest daughter. At the time of the album's release, she was ten years old, and her voice appears on several tracks including Talking. Her inclusion generated significant discussion: some saw it as a touching family collaboration, others raised questions about involving a child in material aimed at an adult audience. What is undeniable is that the moment carried an unusual emotional charge, placing a child's voice inside an album that was being received in a context of considerable adult controversy.
Chart Performance
The track debuted at number 30 on the Hot 100 on February 24, 2024, representing a strong debut-week performance that reflected the album's concentrated streaming activity in its opening days. The song spent two weeks on the chart, dropping significantly in its second week to number 96. That trajectory is characteristic of a title that generates massive opening-weekend streaming on the strength of an artist's fanbase and then settles into a smaller dedicated audience. The 6.7 million YouTube view count reflects continued engagement from that dedicated group.
A Document of a Complicated Moment
Whatever judgment history renders on the Vultures project or its creator, Talking exists as a document of a very particular moment in 2024 pop culture: the collision of outsized artistic ambition, family dynamics played out publicly, and the strange mathematics of celebrity in an era when controversy and commercial success are no longer mutually exclusive. Press play with your own complicated feelings intact; that complexity is part of what the track is.
“Talking” — ¥$'s singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning Behind "Talking" by ¥$: Kanye West & Ty Dolla $ign Featuring North West
Communication and Its Failures
The title points directly at the song's preoccupation: talking, and specifically the gap between the words people say and what they actually mean or feel. This theme runs throughout Kanye West's artistic catalog, the sense that conventional communication is inadequate to the depth of experience he wants to express. On Talking, that preoccupation takes a form shaped by the collaborative dynamic: Ty Dolla $ign's melodic sensibility softens and opens the emotional register, while the track explores what it means to talk past each other, or to finally say something true.
The Voice of a Child
The presence of North West on the track introduces a layer of meaning that operates independently of the lyrical content. A child's voice, by its nature, carries connotations of innocence, of unfiltered perception, of a kind of truth-telling that adult sophistication has not yet complicated. Whether intentional or not, placing that voice inside a record by artists navigating enormous adult controversy creates a tonal contrast that listeners cannot ignore. The child speaks or sings, and the surrounding adult world with all its weight is briefly suspended.
¥$ as Collaborative Concept
The joint billing of Ye and Ty Dolla $ign as ¥$ represents something beyond a standard feature arrangement. The project was conceived as a genuine artistic partnership, with both artists credited as equal authors. That framing matters for understanding individual tracks: Talking is the product of two distinct sensibilities in genuine dialogue, which is, appropriately, a form of talking. Ty Dolla $ign's contributions give the track an emotional accessibility that Ye working alone might not have produced in this period.
The 2024 Context of Being Heard
Early 2024 was a moment when public discourse was intensely focused on who gets to speak, who gets heard, and what the consequences of saying certain things are. Vultures 1 arrived explicitly in that context: the album existed because of controversies triggered by speech, and much of its reception was filtered through that history. A song called Talking on that album invites the listener to consider those layers even while engaging with the music on its own terms. The title is almost too on-the-nose, which may be the point.
Why Listeners Engaged
The track drew listeners who were willing to separate the pleasure of the sound from the complexity of the context, and who found in the music something that the public controversy couldn't erase: real craft, real melody, real production intelligence. Whether that separation is possible or appropriate is a question each listener answers individually. The chart performance and YouTube numbers suggest a substantial audience decided it was, at least for the duration of a play.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging