The 2020s File Feature
I Should Probably Go To Bed
I Should Probably Go To Bed: Dan + Shay's Pandemic-Era Country Hit Dan + Shay had established themselves as one of the dominant forces in contemporary countr…
01 The Story
I Should Probably Go To Bed: Dan + Shay's Pandemic-Era Country Hit
Dan + Shay had established themselves as one of the dominant forces in contemporary country music by the time "I Should Probably Go To Bed" arrived in October 2020, released through Warner Music Nashville. The duo, consisting of Dan Smyers and Shay Mooney, had already accumulated multiple number-one hits and Grammy Awards, building an audience drawn to their signature blend of polished production, strong vocal harmonies, and emotionally accessible songwriting.
The song was written by Dan Smyers, Shay Mooney, and Jordan Reynolds, a prolific Nashville songwriter whose credits span multiple genres. Jordan Reynolds has contributed to some of the most commercially successful country songs of the past decade, and his involvement on this track reflects the professional apparatus that surrounds Dan + Shay's songwriting process. The production was handled by Smyers himself, who functions as the duo's primary producer in addition to his role as a performer, giving the track a cohesive internal vision.
The song's release coincided with an unusual moment in American cultural life. The COVID-19 pandemic had dramatically altered social behavior, keeping many people physically separated from partners and romantic interests. The song's scenario of being on the phone late at night with someone you are developing feelings for carried particular resonance in 2020, when phone and video calls had become the primary medium for romantic connection for millions of people who could not meet in person. That coincidence of timing amplified the song's emotional relevance and contributed to its strong streaming performance.
The track reached number one on the Billboard Country Airplay chart, continuing Dan + Shay's remarkable run of chart success in a format where sustaining top-tier commercial performance across multiple releases is genuinely difficult. Country radio programmers responded warmly to the song's clean production and the duo's vocal performance, which showcased their tight harmonies in a setting that felt appropriately intimate for the lyrical content.
The music video was well-suited to pandemic-era production constraints, featuring minimal cast and an intimate visual treatment that matched the song's late-night telephone call scenario. The visual component reinforced the lyrical narrative without requiring the kind of large-scale production that had become difficult to execute in the early months of the pandemic, demonstrating the duo's ability to adapt creative execution to the practical realities of 2020.
Critically, the song received positive attention for its precision and economy. Reviewers noted that Dan + Shay had refined their songwriting to a point where a relatively simple scenario, a man reluctant to hang up the phone with someone he cares about, could sustain a full track without feeling thin or stretched. The craft evident in the song's structure was recognized as evidence of genuine professional development rather than reliance on a proven formula.
The song was nominated for Best Country Song at the Grammy Awards, reflecting the Recording Academy's recognition of its songwriting quality and its impact on the country music landscape. Grammy consideration at this level acknowledges not just commercial performance but the quality of the underlying song as a piece of craft, a distinction that the songwriting team's professional reputation made particularly appropriate.
Streaming performance for the track was strong and sustained, reflecting the dual appeal of a song that works both as a radio-friendly country hit and as a late-night, mood-appropriate streaming choice. Its placement on romantic, late-night, and country playlists across major streaming platforms extended its reach to listeners who might not primarily engage with country radio, broadening the audience for the track beyond the duo's existing fanbase.
Dan + Shay's live performances of the song reinforced its standing as one of their more emotionally effective tracks. The intimate lyrical content translated well to live settings, where the duo's vocal chemistry gave the performance a warmth that resonated with audiences who had encountered the song during the isolating circumstances of the pandemic year. The song became a consistent highlight of their touring set as the duo returned to live performance in 2021 and beyond.
The broader arc of Dan + Shay's career makes "I Should Probably Go To Bed" particularly significant. Rather than representing a stylistic departure, it consolidates and refines the elements that have defined their commercial and artistic identity: strong hooks, clear emotional narratives, accomplished vocal harmonies, and production that prioritizes clarity and emotional impact over novelty. The song is, in that sense, a mature and confident example of an artist doing what they do best at the highest level of craft.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning Behind I Should Probably Go To Bed
"I Should Probably Go To Bed" captures a very specific and widely recognizable romantic experience: the late-night phone call with someone you are falling for, prolonged beyond all practical justification because neither party is willing to be the one to end it. The song's central scene is one of those minor-key romantic dramas that ordinary life generates constantly but that popular music rarely examines with the precision this track brings to bear on it.
The title and central lyric function as both a confession and an explanation. The narrator is fully aware of the rational case for ending the call, acknowledging the hour and the practical demands of the following day. But the emotional pull of the connection overcomes that rational awareness repeatedly, producing a loop of goodbye attempts that neither party allows to complete. That loop, that repeated failure to do the sensible thing in the face of genuine feeling, is the emotional heart of the song.
The song belongs to a long tradition in country music of finding emotional significance in the specific and mundane details of romantic experience. Rather than addressing love through grand gestures or dramatic circumstances, Dan + Shay and their co-writers locate the feeling in the texture of an ordinary late-night conversation. The specificity of this scene, its recognizability to anyone who has experienced early-stage romantic connection, is what gives the song its broad appeal.
The choice of the telephone call as the song's central setting was particularly resonant in the context of 2020, when physical separation from romantic partners or potential partners had become a near-universal experience. The song did not deliberately court this reading, but the timing of its release meant that listeners encountered it against the backdrop of their own pandemic-induced separation from people they cared about, which gave the late-night-call scenario an additional emotional weight it might not otherwise have carried.
Dan + Shay's vocal performance is itself part of the song's meaning. Their tight harmonies, which have become one of the most recognizable sonic signatures in contemporary country music, add a dimension of romantic warmth that reinforces the lyrical content. The blend of their voices suggests the kind of easy closeness that the song's narrator is working to build with his subject, a performance choice that makes the formal elements of the track work in direct service of its emotional argument.
The song also speaks to a particular phase of romantic development that is rarely addressed directly in mainstream pop or country: the period after initial attraction but before explicit commitment, when every interaction carries the potential for both deepening connection and misunderstanding. The narrator's reluctance to hang up is not merely about enjoyment but about holding onto the contact before the relationship is secure enough to survive moments of distance. That subtle emotional layer beneath the song's breezy surface is what separates it from a purely formulaic treatment of the late-night-call scenario and gives it genuine emotional intelligence. The song's enduring appeal rests on that precision, the sense that its writers understood not just the surface of the experience but its psychological and emotional subtext.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging