The 2020s File Feature
In The Stars
In The Stars — Benson Boone's Grief-Drenched Debut That Grew Into a Global PhenomenonThere are songs that arrive quietly and then refuse to leave. Benson Boo…
01 The Story
In The Stars — Benson Boone's Grief-Drenched Debut That Grew Into a Global Phenomenon
There are songs that arrive quietly and then refuse to leave. Benson Boone was barely known to the wider public when In The Stars first surfaced: a teenager from Monroe, Washington, who had placed third on American Idol's 2021 season before deciding to walk away and pursue his own artistic path rather than accept the record deal that came with the show. The song he eventually built around loss and longing became something far larger than any competition show could have manufactured, and the path it took to get there was as unconventional as the artist himself.
A Young Voice and a Very Old Grief
Boone wrote In The Stars about the death of his girlfriend's father, channeling grief from the outside in. That specific perspective angle matters enormously to what the song is doing. The narrator is not the bereaved; he is the witness, the person standing beside the bereaved, feeling the particular helplessness of presence that cannot repair what has been broken. The dead father is present in the song as an absence, described through longing rather than memory, wished back with the desperate sincerity of someone watching a person they love carry an unbearable weight.
Few songwriters his age attempted subject matter this emotionally complex and heavy, and fewer still delivered it with the kind of unselfconscious directness that makes a listener feel seen rather than performed at. Boone was young enough not to have developed the protective irony that often hardens around serious subject matter as artists age. He asked the questions directly, and that directness became the song's primary strength.
The Sound of Raw Emotion
The production builds with deliberate patience. Opening stripped back, Boone's voice carries the full weight of the melody before the arrangement gradually swells into something genuinely anthemic. His vocal range across the song is extraordinary, moving from vulnerable lower registers through a falsetto passage that lands somewhere between a scream and a prayer. The song does not sound like the polished pop coming out of major studios in 2022. It sounds like someone processing grief in real time and accidentally making it beautiful.
That quality of accidental beauty, of emotion so immediate it has not been processed into something more controlled, is what TikTok users responded to when they began attaching the track to tribute videos for their own lost loved ones. The song became a container for collective grief that Boone had not imagined when writing it. His specific loss became everyone's loss, which is the alchemy that separates truly resonant grief songs from ones that merely describe sadness.
A Single Week That Changed Everything
In The Stars made its Billboard Hot 100 debut on May 14, 2022, arriving at number 82 for a single charted week. On paper, a one-week appearance at number 82 sounds modest. In practice, the song's life was only beginning. TikTok amplified it relentlessly through 2022 and into 2023, with users attaching the track to tributes for deceased family members and friends, creating a chain of shared mourning that the algorithm continued feeding. The YouTube view count climbed to over 78 million views, a number that dwarfs what its Hot 100 placement would suggest. The Billboard moment was a snapshot of one week; the cultural moment was something else entirely, measured in years rather than chart cycles.
The Slow Burn Becomes a Signature
Boone went on to release more music and develop a reputation as one of the more compelling young performers of the early 2020s. His live shows demonstrated a physical expressiveness, a willingness to throw himself around a stage in ways that made even ballads feel explosive and urgent, that expanded the emotional range his studio recordings could only hint at. He wore his influences openly and without apology, drawing on classic rock vocal traditions and contemporary pop structures simultaneously.
In The Stars remained the anchor of his catalog, the song that introduced him to most of the world and established the emotional register he would keep returning to across subsequent releases: grief processed through melody, vulnerability offered without apology, the sincere question asked without guarantee of an answer. That foundation proved more durable than any calculated hit could have been.
Find a quiet moment, put on headphones, and let Boone's voice do what it was built to do. The ending, in particular, has a way of staying with you long after the song stops.
“In The Stars” — Benson Boone's singular moment on the 2020s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Heart of In The Stars: Grief, Distance, and a Desperate Wish
Some songs are about romantic longing; In The Stars is about something quieter and more final. Benson Boone wrote it while watching his girlfriend mourn her father, and that outside perspective shapes every element of the song. The narrator is not the bereaved: he is the witness beside the bereaved, feeling the limits of what love and presence can actually offer when the wound is one that no living person can close.
Love as Witness
The emotional core of the song sits in the narrator's helplessness. He loves someone who is hurting from a loss he did not share, and he cannot repair what has been broken. He can only remain present, which is both the minimum and the maximum of what is available to him. The song honors that position rather than dismissing it. Being the person who witnesses grief rather than carries it is its own particular emotional labor, and In The Stars gives that experience a form that most grief music does not bother to address.
The dead father is present in the song as a longed-for absence. Boone describes the wish to reach through death and offer reassurance, to close a distance that nothing in the living world can close. That longing attaches to any loss the listener has experienced, not only a parent, and that emotional portability is a large part of why the song traveled so far beyond its original specific context.
Cosmic Imagery and the Search for Connection
The title gesture, looking for a person among the stars, belongs to a long tradition of mapping grief onto the sky. The metaphor works because it acknowledges an unbridgeable distance while refusing to surrender the impulse toward connection. The stars are unreachable; the act of looking is human and persistent anyway. Boone leans into this tension without resolving it, which gives the song its emotional weight and its staying power.
The lyrics imagine a conversation that cannot happen, a reunion that exists only in the longing. That structure of impossible wish is fundamental to how human beings process loss, and Boone articulates it with the kind of directness that arrives when a young person has not yet learned to manage their emotional expression into something more palatable.
The Soundtrack to Shared Mourning
When TikTok users began attaching In The Stars to tribute videos, they were performing a specific and meaningful act: borrowing Boone's language to name their own losses. The song became a shared container for grief in a way that occurs only when a piece of writing is genuinely open rather than narrowly autobiographical. The production's gradual, swelling quality helped the song function ceremonially, like a slow gathering of everyone who has ever stood helplessly beside someone they love who is carrying unbearable loss.
Why Young Listeners Claimed It
The early 2020s were years of layered, complicated mourning for millions of people: pandemic deaths, funerals attended by almost no one, delayed rituals, grief that had no proper container and no social permission to be expressed. In The Stars offered a form that had been missing. Boone's youth was not a liability in this context; it gave him permission to express grief without the protective distance that more seasoned artists might have imposed. He simply asked the questions that grief generates, and found an audience that had been waiting for someone to ask them aloud.
→ More from the 2020s File
View all 2020s hits →
Keep digging