The 2010s File Feature
Impossible
History of "Impossible" by Shontelle Shontelle, the Barbadian recording artist born Shontelle Layne, released "Impossible" as the lead single from her second…
01 The Story
History of "Impossible" by Shontelle
Shontelle, the Barbadian recording artist born Shontelle Layne, released "Impossible" as the lead single from her second studio album No Gravity in 2010. The song was written by Iyiola Babarinde Shonibare, known professionally as Iyanya, and was produced by Brian Kennedy. Shontelle had first come to international attention in 2008 with her debut single "T-Shirt," which established her as a capable R&B vocalist with a knack for emotionally resonant pop crossover material. "Impossible" represented a significant stylistic step forward, moving from the lighter tone of her debut work into a more orchestral, emotionally intense ballad format that showcased the full range of her vocal capabilities.
The recording was made in the context of Shontelle's development as an artist signed to SRP Records and distributed through Universal Motown. The production of "Impossible" featured a sweeping orchestral arrangement that placed Shontelle's voice at the center of a lush sonic landscape built from strings, piano, and layered vocal harmonies. This production approach connected the song to a tradition of grand pop ballads that had been commercially successful across multiple decades, while the contemporary production techniques applied to the arrangement kept it firmly grounded in the sound of its era. The combination proved highly effective commercially and artistically.
On the Billboard Hot 100, "Impossible" debuted on May 8, 2010, at number 88, and climbed steadily over the following weeks and months. The song reached its peak position of number 13 on July 31, 2010, after 20 weeks on the chart. This extended chart run reflected sustained radio support, particularly from Adult Contemporary and rhythmic pop formats, as well as strong digital download sales that continued to accumulate throughout the summer of 2010. The song's performance during the summer months was particularly strong, as its emotional intensity and melodic richness made it a suitable companion for the introspective and nostalgic listening habits commonly associated with that season.
The song's international commercial performance exceeded its American chart results. "Impossible" topped singles charts in multiple European markets, including Germany, Switzerland, and Austria, and performed strongly across Scandinavia and other markets with well-developed markets for adult pop and R&B material. The song's international reach established Shontelle as a genuinely global artist rather than simply an American or Caribbean regional act, and the European success in particular opened new promotional opportunities that extended her touring and media presence considerably beyond what her American chart position alone would have warranted.
One of the most commercially significant developments in the song's lifecycle was the cover version recorded by James Arthur, the British singer-songwriter who won the ninth series of The X Factor UK in December 2012. Arthur's winning performance on the show was a version of "Impossible," and his recording of the song, released immediately following his competition win, became one of the fastest-selling singles in UK chart history at that time, selling hundreds of thousands of copies in its first week. Arthur's version reached number one in the United Kingdom and was released in dozens of international markets, dramatically amplifying the song's global profile and introducing it to audiences who had not encountered Shontelle's original recording.
The relationship between the original recording and the X Factor cover was commercially complex. Shontelle's original remained available for streaming and purchase alongside Arthur's version, and the attention generated by Arthur's success demonstrably increased interest in the original. Streaming figures for Shontelle's version increased substantially in the weeks following Arthur's win, and chart activities in several markets reflected renewed listener interest in the original. This dynamic, in which a cover version's success generates renewed commercial activity for the original, was not unusual in the streaming era but was particularly pronounced in the case of "Impossible" given the scale of Arthur's X Factor victory.
Shontelle's original recording of "Impossible" has accumulated over 258 million YouTube views, a figure that reflects both the song's original commercial impact and the sustained interest generated by the multiple cover versions and cultural touchpoints it has produced over the years since its release. The song has appeared in numerous film and television soundtracks, which has continued to expose it to new audiences and contribute to its streaming accumulation. The track is widely regarded as the defining commercial recording of Shontelle's career and as one of the significant pop ballads of the early 2010s international music market.
Critically, "Impossible" was praised for the quality of Shontelle's vocal performance, which was considered one of the most technically accomplished and emotionally controlled of her career at that point. Reviewers noted the way she navigated the song's demanding melodic range without sacrificing emotional authenticity for technical display, a balance that was identified as the key element distinguishing the song from more clinical vocal showcase ballads of its era.
02 Song Meaning
Meaning of "Impossible" by Shontelle
"Impossible" is a breakup ballad that describes the aftermath of a deeply significant romantic relationship from the perspective of a narrator who finds that separating from a former partner is emotionally far more difficult than she had anticipated. The central tension of the song is between the knowledge that a relationship must end and the psychological reality that ending it requires overcoming attachments that do not dissolve simply because a rational decision has been made. The word "impossible" in the title refers not to the relationship itself but to the act of living without the person who occupied the center of the narrator's emotional life.
The song's lyrical structure follows a pattern common to the most effective ballads of its type: an acknowledgment of the relationship's end, followed by a detailed examination of the emotional consequences of that ending. The narrator describes the particular forms that loss takes in daily life, the small moments and habitual associations that reveal how thoroughly another person has become integrated into one's sense of normalcy. These observations are rendered without sentimentality but with precise emotional honesty, which gives the song its distinctive quality of authenticity. The narrator is not wallowing in grief but reporting it with a kind of careful clarity that makes the emotional content more rather than less affecting.
The concept of impossibility as applied to emotional recovery is philosophically interesting. The song does not claim that the narrator will never recover, but rather that in the present moment, the idea of recovery feels entirely out of reach. This temporal specificity, the focus on the immediate experience of loss rather than on abstract pronouncements about the permanence of grief, grounds the song's emotional claims in the recognizable reality of how people actually experience the end of significant relationships. Listeners responded to this specificity because it matched their own experiences in ways that more generalized expressions of heartbreak often do not.
The song also addresses the physical dimensions of emotional loss. The narrator describes symptoms of grief that are not purely psychological but are felt in the body, a sleeplessness and physical restlessness that reflects the body's inability to adjust to an absence that the mind has not yet fully processed. This attention to physical experience alongside emotional and cognitive experience gave the song a completeness of description that distinguished it from more abstract love ballads and contributed significantly to its emotional power and listener identification.
The cultural reception of "Impossible" was shaped by its placement within a specific tradition of emotionally direct pop ballads that had been commercially successful across several decades. Listeners and critics both recognized the song as belonging to this tradition while also identifying qualities that felt fresh and contemporary. The orchestral production, which might in other contexts have felt dated or overwrought, was instead received as appropriate to the emotional scale of the content, a sign that the songwriting and production were sufficiently strong to carry an ambitious musical setting without collapsing under its own weight.
The song's enduring cultural presence, reinforced by multiple successful cover versions including James Arthur's high-profile recording, reflects the depth and universality of its central emotional content. Songs about the impossibility of getting over someone touch on experiences that transcend specific cultural contexts and generational experiences. The particular version of this experience that "Impossible" articulates, focused on the gap between knowing something must end and being able to emotionally accept that ending, is one that resonates across demographic boundaries, which helps explain why multiple artists across different national music markets have found commercial success with the material.
→ More from the 2010s File
View all 2010s hits →
Keep digging