The 2010s File Feature
What Now
What Now: Creation, Recording, and Chart History What Now is a pop and RB ballad recorded by Rihanna, released in 2013 from her seventh studio album Unapolog…
01 The Story
What Now: Creation, Recording, and Chart History
What Now is a pop and R&B ballad recorded by Rihanna, released in 2013 from her seventh studio album Unapologetic. The song was written by Rihanna, Lukasz Gottwald (known professionally as Dr. Luke), Henry Walter (known as Cirkut), and Makeba Riddick-Joelle. The production team responsible for the track brought together a set of collaborators who had collectively been central to the construction of commercial pop music throughout the preceding decade, each contributing expertise in a specific dimension of the recording process.
Unapologetic was Rihanna's seventh studio album in as many years, a release pace that had become one of the defining characteristics of her commercial operation. The album was the first of her career to debut at number one on the Billboard 200, and it was released at a time when Rihanna had established herself as one of the most commercially dominant recording artists in the world. The album contained a range of sonic styles, from club-oriented electronic productions to more introspective ballads, and What Now sat firmly within the latter category, providing emotional depth and tonal contrast to the more uptempo material that surrounded it.
The song was constructed around a production palette of synthesizer textures and a prominent guitar element that gave it a rock-influenced edge within an otherwise pop and R&B sonic context. Dr. Luke and Cirkut's production choices created a sound that was simultaneously arena-scaled and emotionally intimate, a combination that suited Rihanna's vocal delivery and the lyrical content's focus on confusion and emotional searching. The inclusion of the guitar element was a deliberate choice that gave the track a textural distinctiveness within the album's broader sonic environment, marking it as a song that drew on a wider range of musical influences than a conventional R&B ballad would suggest.
Rihanna's vocal performance on the track was noted for its emotional directness, with her delivery conveying a sense of genuine searching rather than polished emotional performance. The song builds through its structure, moving from a relatively restrained opening to a climactic vocal expression that utilized the full range and power she had demonstrated consistently throughout her career. This structural arc gave the song its character as a slow-building emotional release rather than an immediately accessible pop hook, distinguishing it from the majority of her commercial single releases.
What Now was released as a single in November 2013, entering the Billboard Hot 100 on November 9 at position 96. Its climb was methodical, reaching its peak of number 25 during the week of December 7, 2013, after spending eight weeks on the chart in total. The song's relatively modest Hot 100 peak relative to some of Rihanna's more dance-oriented material reflected the format preferences of Hot 100 methodology at the time, which weighted airplay formats that favored uptempo pop over slower, more atmospherically complex ballads.
The track performed more strongly on format-specific charts where ballads had traditionally found a more receptive audience. It also earned significant international chart attention, reflecting the global nature of Rihanna's audience, which had developed across more than a decade of consistent international commercial activity. In the United Kingdom and other European markets, the song's atmospheric production and emotional directness resonated with audiences who responded to the album's more introspective qualities.
The music video for the song was a visually ambitious production featuring Rihanna in a series of transformative environments that reflected the song's themes of disorientation and searching. The video's production values were consistent with the large-scale visual presentations that had become standard for Rihanna's single releases, and it received substantial digital viewership on YouTube and other platforms, accumulating hundreds of millions of views over the years following its initial release.
In the context of Unapologetic's commercial and critical reception, What Now was identified as one of the album's most emotionally substantial moments. Critics who noted the album's tonal range frequently cited the song as evidence that Rihanna's artistry extended beyond the dance-floor-oriented material that generated the majority of her chart activity, demonstrating a capacity for reflective emotional expression that rounded out her artistic profile and confirmed the breadth of her creative range. The song's enduring streaming performance in subsequent years affirmed its place within a catalog of recordings that continued to attract new listeners long after the original commercial moment had passed.
02 Song Meaning
What Now: Themes and Meaning
What Now explores the psychological experience of disorientation following an emotional crisis. The song's narrator has reached a point where previously reliable sources of meaning, direction, or comfort have been exhausted or stripped away, leaving a condition of genuine uncertainty about how to proceed. The question posed in the title is not rhetorical but a sincere expression of lostness, a recognition that the strategies the narrator has previously employed to navigate difficulty are no longer available or adequate.
The song is notable for the absence of resolution in its emotional arc. Rather than moving from crisis toward recovery or clarity, it sits within the crisis itself, documenting the experience of emotional suspension without offering a path out of it. This structural choice distinguishes the track from more conventional pop treatments of difficulty, which typically frame challenges as temporary obstacles on the way to a more positive state. The song insists on the validity of not knowing what comes next, treating that uncertainty as a genuine psychological condition rather than a dramatic device that will be resolved in the final chorus.
The references within the lyric to tried and failed coping mechanisms, to places of escape that no longer work and to the depletion of emotional reserves, construct a picture of someone who has not simply encountered a new difficulty but has reached the end of their resources for addressing difficulty. This specificity gives the song a psychological depth that allows it to function as more than a general expression of sadness. It describes a particular stage in emotional experience: the moment when even grief or anger is exhausted and what remains is a blank uncertainty that resists any easy characterization or conventional remedy.
Rihanna's delivery of the lyrical content carries credibility partly because of the publicly documented nature of her own personal experiences during the years preceding the song's release. Without reducing the song to autobiography, it is possible to observe that her vocal performance conveys a quality of authenticity that audiences engaged with as genuine rather than performed. This sense of lived experience behind the performance contributed to the song's reception as one of the more emotionally substantial entries in her catalog, distinguishing it from recordings in which the emotional content felt more calculated or detached from personal reality.
The rock-influenced production elements, particularly the guitar texture within the arrangement, give the song a sonic environment that suits its themes. The expansive, slightly dissonant quality of the production creates an atmosphere of unsettledness that mirrors the narrator's psychological state. The song does not sound comfortable or resolved, which is a production choice that reinforces rather than contradicts its lyrical content.
The song also reflects a broader cultural conversation about the relationship between public expectation and private emotional reality for artists who operate at the highest levels of commercial visibility. The narrator's exhaustion and disorientation take on additional dimensions when considered in the context of an artist whose public life has been subject to extraordinary levels of scrutiny and whose emotional responses to that scrutiny have been publicly evaluated and interpreted. The universality of the song's emotional content coexists with a specificity of circumstance that gives it a documentary quality within the broader arc of Rihanna's career, making it both a standalone emotional statement and a contextually situated artistic document.
Keep digging