The 1990s File Feature
Like The Way I Do/If I Wanted To
"Like The Way I Do/If I Wanted To": Melissa Etheridge's Double-Barreled 1995 Surge The Voice That Wouldn't Compromise Picture the American rock landscape in …
01 The Story
"Like The Way I Do/If I Wanted To": Melissa Etheridge's Double-Barreled 1995 Surge
The Voice That Wouldn't Compromise
Picture the American rock landscape in early 1995, and you find Melissa Etheridge in an unusual position: she was simultaneously at the absolute peak of her commercial success and at one of the most personally public moments of her life. Her January 1993 announcement that she was gay, made at a Clinton inaugural celebration, had transformed her public profile and intensified her cultural significance in ways that extended well beyond her music. She had become a symbol for a community and a conversation about visibility and authenticity in popular culture that was just beginning to reach mainstream American consciousness.
The album Yes I Am, released in September 1993, was the commercial vehicle for all of this energy. The title itself was a pointed declaration, and the music inside fulfilled its promise: Etheridge turned up the volume on her already intense guitar rock sound, delivering performances that were physically and emotionally demanding in ways that few other artists of her era were attempting. The album eventually sold over six million copies in the United States alone, generating multiple chart singles over a release cycle that stretched across more than a year and a half.
The Double-Single Format
Like the Way I Do / If I Wanted To was released as a double A-side, a format that pairs two tracks from the same artist on a single promotional release. The pairing strategy allowed radio programmers to choose the track that fit their format while the chart impact of either track would benefit both songs' visibility. Like the Way I Do had originally appeared on Etheridge's 1988 debut album, while If I Wanted To came from Yes I Am. Pairing an established fan-favorite live track with a current album cut gave the release a richness that a single song alone might not have carried.
Like the Way I Do had long been a concert highlight, a song whose intensity built through performance in ways that studio versions couldn't fully capture. Its emotional core was raw and demanding: the narrator challenging a rival to prove that their love for the shared object of affection matches the narrator's own fierce devotion. The live version's extended guitar workout had made it a signature of Etheridge's concert experience, and including it on this release acknowledged the song's special status in her catalog.
The Chart Run
The release debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on February 18, 1995, entering at position 25, which reflected the strong established audience that Yes I Am had built over its previous chart cycle. Over the following weeks the single climbed steadily, moving through the 20s with gathering radio support. By March 11, 1995, the release had reached its peak position of number 16 on the Hot 100, spending 20 weeks total on the chart. Twenty weeks at that level represented exceptional staying power for a rock act in a pop chart environment.
The mainstream rock charts, where Etheridge's audience was most concentrated, showed even stronger performance. She was one of the few female rock artists of this period who competed directly with male-fronted acts for rock radio airtime and won it on equal terms.
The Grammy Moment
The period of Yes I Am's chart dominance coincided with what became one of the most discussed Grammy moments of the mid-1990s. At the 1995 Grammy Awards, Etheridge performed a tribute to Janis Joplin that was received as a genuine revelation, demonstrating live the kind of full-throated commitment to rock and blues tradition that her records had always claimed but that live performance could prove in ways that recordings sometimes couldn't. The performance brought her music to viewers who might not have been following her chart career closely and reinforced her standing as a genuine force in rock rather than a crossover curiosity.
Why the Records Held Up
Both songs on this double release have survived their moment of chart relevance. Like the Way I Do in particular has become a standard in Etheridge's live repertoire precisely because its emotional intensity scales upward with extended performance. The kind of passionate rock that she built her career on has not become dated in the ways that more production-dependent sounds of the same era have. Rawness, when it's genuine, doesn't expire. Crank either of these tracks and hear exactly what uncompromising rock conviction sounds like when it's entirely real.
"Like The Way I Do/If I Wanted To" — Melissa Etheridge's singular moment on the 1990s charts.
02 Song Meaning
"Like The Way I Do/If I Wanted To": Passion as Challenge
The Fire Inside "Like The Way I Do"
The emotional argument of Like the Way I Do is one of the bolder constructions in 1980s and 1990s rock songwriting. The narrator addresses a rival for her lover's affections directly, issuing a challenge that functions simultaneously as an assertion of superiority and an admission of vulnerability: prove that you feel this person the way the narrator does, and if you can't, step aside. The intensity is staggering. Melissa Etheridge's vocal delivery on the live versions that circulated widely matched the lyric's ferocity with physical commitment, turning a competition into something that felt more like a testimony.
What makes the song's emotional architecture interesting is its combination of aggression and openness. The narrator isn't hiding the depth of her attachment but throwing it forward as a weapon and a proof. To love someone this much, the song suggests, is to have a claim that goes beyond conventional romantic logic. The passion itself is the argument.
Authenticity and the Etheridge Persona
Etheridge's public coming out in 1993 recontextualized her earlier music in ways she hadn't necessarily anticipated when writing it. Songs about intense, demanding, boundary-testing love acquired additional dimensions when heard as the work of an artist who had spent years singing about her real emotional experience in a coded form that mainstream audiences could receive while her core audience understood its full weight. The honesty that always characterized her music became even more charged when the biographical context became fully public.
This retroactive depth is one of the things that makes both songs on this release interesting beyond their immediate chart moment. Like the Way I Do in particular reads as a song about the particular intensity with which queer people can love, given how much of that love had to be felt privately before it could be expressed publicly. The emotional surplus in the vocal performance has biographical roots whether or not the listener knows them.
The Meaning Inside "If I Wanted To"
The companion track, If I Wanted To, works a different but related emotional territory. Where Like the Way I Do is all forward momentum and challenge, If I Wanted To is more reflective: a song about agency, about choosing to stay in a situation rather than being trapped in it. The narrator asserts that she could leave, could change, could abandon the relationship, but chooses not to. The lyric restores choice to a situation that might otherwise feel coercive, reframing commitment as an ongoing decision rather than a fait accompli.
This is a psychologically sophisticated position for a pop-rock song to occupy. The emotional content of the two tracks complements each other usefully on the double release: one declares the intensity of the feeling, the other asserts the autonomy behind choosing to act on it.
Rock as a Vehicle for Emotional Truth
What Etheridge understood, and what these two songs demonstrate particularly well, is that rock music's traditional formal elements (loud guitar, powerful drumming, a vocalist pushed to their limits) create the conditions for a kind of emotional honesty that more polished pop formats resist. The physical force of the music gives the emotional force of the lyrics somewhere to live. When she sang about wanting someone with every fiber of her being, the music made it credible in ways that a softer arrangement simply couldn't have achieved. Rock was the right vehicle because the emotion demanded nothing less.
→ More from the 1990s File
View all 1990s hits →
Keep digging