The 1980s File Feature
That Ain't Love
REO Speedwagon and "That Ain't Love": Arena Rock's Power Ballad in the Late 1980s REO Speedwagon was one of the defining acts of American arena rock, a band …
01 The Story
REO Speedwagon and "That Ain't Love": Arena Rock's Power Ballad in the Late 1980s
REO Speedwagon was one of the defining acts of American arena rock, a band that had navigated successfully from hard rock origins in the late 1960s through the corporate rock of the 1970s and into the power ballad era of the early 1980s. Their 1980 album "Hi Infidelity" had become one of the best-selling albums in American music history, spending 15 weeks at number one on the Billboard 200, and singles like "Keep On Loving You" and "Take It on the Run" had established lead vocalist Kevin Cronin and guitarist Gary Richrath as among the most commercially effective partnerships in rock music.
By 1987, the band was operating in a different commercial landscape. The mid-1980s had seen arena rock's commercial dominance begin to erode slightly under pressure from hair metal on one side and the developing alternative rock movement on the other, though the genre retained a substantial and loyal audience that sustained acts like REO Speedwagon, Foreigner, and Journey in their continued commercial activity. The album "Life As We Know It," released on Epic Records in 1987, was REO Speedwagon's attempt to maintain relevance within the changing rock landscape while honoring the conventions their audience had established loyalty to over the preceding decade.
"That Ain't Love" was written by Kevin Cronin, maintaining the songwriting tradition of earlier REO Speedwagon hits like "Keep On Loving You" in which the vocalist was also the primary composer of the material most closely associated with the band. The song was produced with the kind of polished, radio-ready sonic clarity that Epic Records' production infrastructure could support and that album-oriented rock (AOR) radio programmers expected from established acts at this level of the market.
The single debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on January 31, 1987, entering at number 73, and climbed steadily to reach its peak position of number 16 on April 4, 1987, after 14 weeks on the chart. That peak placed the song firmly within the mainstream pop landscape rather than confining it to the AOR specialty chart, reflecting the genuine crossover appeal that the power ballad format had demonstrated for REO Speedwagon since "Keep On Loving You" had reached number one in 1981.
The 14-week chart run demonstrated the sustained radio appeal of the track across both AOR and adult contemporary formats, two constituencies that overlapped substantially for REO Speedwagon's core demographic. Adult contemporary stations in particular maintained long rotations for ballads that resonated with listeners in their thirties, and "That Ain't Love" fit neatly into that format's conventions while carrying enough rock production energy to retain credibility on AOR stations that might have found a purer adult contemporary production too soft for their programming identity.
The music video received strong rotation on both MTV and VH1, the two cable networks that served, respectively, the younger rock audience and the older adult contemporary demographic that REO Speedwagon needed to maintain. VH1's emergence as a viable promotional vehicle had been particularly significant for established acts whose target demographics skewed older than MTV's primary audience, and "That Ain't Love" benefited from the dual-network exposure strategy that the band's label team deployed.
Kevin Cronin's vocal performance on the track drew on his established strengths, particularly the emotional intensity that had made "Keep On Loving You" so commercially effective earlier in the decade. His voice had aged into a register that carried both authority and vulnerability, a combination that the power ballad format required and that younger vocalists attempting the form could not always credibly produce.
REO Speedwagon continued recording and touring through the remainder of the 1980s and into the 1990s and beyond, becoming one of the archetypal classic rock acts that maintained commercial viability through touring revenue and nostalgia markets even as new recordings generated diminishing returns relative to their early catalog. "That Ain't Love" stands as one of the later career chart successes that demonstrated the band's ability to produce commercially viable new material rather than existing purely on the strength of earlier hits.
02 Song Meaning
Authentic Feeling Versus Performance in REO Speedwagon's "That Ain't Love"
"That Ain't Love" builds its argument on a negative definition, using the title's rejection of false or insufficient love as the framework through which genuine feeling is defined. The song does not primarily describe what love is but rather catalogs what it is not, a rhetorical strategy that positions the narrator as someone whose standard for authentic connection is high enough to recognize and reject its counterfeits. That positioning was consistent with the emotional sophistication that Kevin Cronin's songwriting had demonstrated throughout REO Speedwagon's most commercially significant work.
The tradition of love-song negative definition has roots in both folk and classical lyric poetry, where the articulation of what love is not has long served as a way of approaching the ineffable through exclusion. In the context of arena rock balladry, the convention was deployed somewhat differently: the catalog of false love's characteristics served primarily to set up the narrator's own emotional authenticity as the contrasting positive case, positioning them as someone whose feeling was genuine precisely because they understood what genuine feeling required.
Cronin's vocal approach to the theme carried the conviction that the argument required. A performance that had seemed self-righteous or smug, imposing the narrator's standard of genuine love on the listener without acknowledging the difficulty of that standard, would have undermined the song's emotional credibility. Instead, Cronin's delivery communicated a sense of hard-won understanding, the authority of someone who had learned the distinction through experience rather than simply asserting it theoretically.
Within REO Speedwagon's thematic catalog, "That Ain't Love" represents a maturation of the relationship perspective that "Keep On Loving You" had established in 1981. Where the earlier song was about commitment in the face of difficulty, the 1987 track was about discernment, about the capacity to distinguish between genuine connection and its impersonators. That evolution from commitment to discernment tracked a plausible emotional development in a songwriter who had been writing about relationships for more than a decade.
The production choices reinforced the thematic content in specific ways. The balance between the rock production energy, carried primarily by the guitar work and rhythm section, and the ballad's emotional vulnerability, communicated through the vocal performance and harmonic structure, created a sonic environment that embodied the song's interest in combining strength and emotional openness. REO Speedwagon's commercial success had always depended on their ability to make that combination credible, and "That Ain't Love" represented a mature execution of the formula.
The song's commercial success in early 1987, reaching number 16 on the Hot 100 during a competitive period on the chart, suggested that the audience the band had cultivated through the early and mid-1980s remained receptive to new material that worked within the established emotional and sonic framework. That receptiveness was not simply nostalgia but reflected a genuine engagement with the kind of emotionally sophisticated power ballad that REO Speedwagon had been among the most commercially effective practitioners of throughout the decade.
Retrospective assessments of the song have tended to read it within the context of arena rock's late-1980s struggle to maintain commercial and critical relevance, which is a legitimate framework but one that can obscure the song's intrinsic qualities as a piece of emotionally intelligent songwriting. On those intrinsic terms, "That Ain't Love" represents Kevin Cronin's craft at a high level, a well-constructed argument delivered through a well-suited vocal performance in a production that supported both without overwhelming either.
→ More from the 1980s File
View all 1980s hits →
Keep digging