The 1980s File Feature
What Have I Done To Deserve This?
"What Have I Done To Deserve This?" -- Pet Shop Boys and Dusty Springfield's Glorious ReunionTwo Eras CollideAt first glance, the pairing seems almost too ca…
01 The Story
"What Have I Done To Deserve This?" -- Pet Shop Boys and Dusty Springfield's Glorious Reunion
Two Eras Collide
At first glance, the pairing seems almost too calculated to work. Neil Tennant and Chris Lowe had spent 1987 conquering charts on both sides of the Atlantic with a brand of arch, irony-saturated synth-pop that felt distinctly of its moment. Dusty Springfield was a performer whose peak commercial period had occurred two decades earlier in a completely different sonic universe. The combination should have produced something awkward, a novelty collaboration that satisfied neither party's core audience. Instead, What Have I Done To Deserve This? works not despite the incongruity but because of it. The collision of voices and sensibilities produces something richer than either party could have achieved alone.
Springfield's Second Chapter
By 1987, Dusty Springfield's commercial fortunes had followed the complicated arc that often claims artists whose peak is associated with a specific era and a specific sound. The extraordinary recordings of the late 1960s had given way to decades of intermittent activity and varying commercial success. The collaboration with Pet Shop Boys returned her to mainstream visibility in a way that honored her original qualities without requiring her to pretend that no time had passed. Tennant understood what Springfield's voice could do that his could not, and the record they made together is in significant part a showcase for that understanding. Her entrance in the song is one of the moments in 1980s pop that rewards repeated attention.
The Chart Ascent
The single debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on December 12, 1987, entering at number 60. What followed was a confident and sustained climb through the winter months: from 60 to 48, then 39, then 39 again, then 31, and continuing steadily upward into early 1988. By February 20, 1988, the song had peaked at number two on the Hot 100, spending eighteen weeks on the chart. That peak represented one of the Pet Shop Boys' strongest American chart showings and introduced Springfield to a new generation of listeners who might otherwise never have encountered her work in a contemporary context.
The Actually Album and Its Ambitions
The track appeared on Pet Shop Boys' second studio album, Actually, released in September 1987. The album was a carefully constructed statement: wry, emotionally precise, unwilling to choose between genuine feeling and knowing detachment. Tennant's lyrics consistently operated on several levels simultaneously, and What Have I Done To Deserve This? exemplified this quality at its most effective. Springfield's contribution was not simply a vocal cameo added to strengthen a single's commercial appeal; her presence changed the song's emotional register, moving it from the intellectual toward something warmer and more immediately human. The record works because both elements are genuinely present, in tension, neither fully winning.
The Legacy of the Collaboration
With over 72 million YouTube views, the track continues to attract new listeners through Pet Shop Boys retrospectives and Dusty Springfield documentaries alike. The 1988 collaboration is now widely recognized as one of the more inspired pairings of the decade. It also played a significant role in Springfield's artistic rehabilitation: the association with one of the era's most critically admired acts introduced her to an audience that might otherwise never have discovered her work, and the goodwill generated by the collaboration contributed to subsequent projects that extended her late-career recognition in ways she had not been able to achieve on her own during the decade's earlier years.
Put on your headphones and pay attention to the moment Springfield's voice enters the track. You will understand immediately why this record mattered and why it still does.
"What Have I Done To Deserve This?" -- Pet Shop Boys & Dusty Springfield's singular moment on the 1980s charts.
02 Song Meaning
Loss and Bewilderment in "What Have I Done To Deserve This?"
A Question Without a Comfortable Answer
The title is not rhetorical in the way that many song titles pretend to be. It is a genuine question, and the song declines to answer it definitively. The narrator has been left, or is in the process of being left, and cannot locate a satisfying explanation for what is happening. This specific variety of bewilderment, not anger at a clear transgression, not the grief of a mutual ending, but pure baffled incomprehension at an abandonment that seems to arrive without adequate explanation or warning, is what the song sustains across its runtime. It is a feeling that most people know from their own experience, and few pop songs have rendered it with this combination of precision and generosity toward the listener.
Two Voices, Two Registers
The structural decision to split the song between Tennant and Springfield is also a thematic one, and understanding it helps account for why the song works as well as it does. Their voices embody different relationships to the situation being described: Tennant's characteristic dry precision, his ability to state painful things without overselling their painfulness, set against Springfield's warmer and more openly vulnerable delivery. Together they create a composite portrait of someone processing loss from more than one internal angle simultaneously. The counterpoint between intellectual distance and emotional exposure is the song's most sophisticated achievement, and it required both voices to make it work. Neither alone would have produced the same result.
Pet Shop Boys' Emotional Intelligence
Neil Tennant has consistently been one of pop music's more emotionally intelligent lyricists, capable of writing about genuine feeling without sentiment, of addressing serious subjects without losing the formal discipline that made Pet Shop Boys distinctive and sometimes misunderstood. In this song, the lyrics describe the disorientation of relational loss in language precise enough to feel accurate without being clinical, specific enough to be immediately recognizable without being merely anecdotal. The question of what one has done to deserve a particular outcome is one of the more difficult questions loss raises, because it implies a system of moral causation that very often turns out not to exist at all.
The Era's Synth-Pop and Its Emotional Range
In 1987, synth-pop was sometimes charged with emotional coldness, with producing music that prioritized sound design and clever distance over anything as vulnerable as genuine feeling. Pet Shop Boys were consistently cited as evidence against this charge, and this song is one of their strongest counter-arguments. The synthesizer textures do not create distance from the song's emotional content; they provide a clean, clear space in which that content can be heard without the distraction of conventional rock arrangement. The production is sophisticated, but the feeling it frames is simple and universal. The sophistication is in service of the simplicity, not in competition with it.
Springfield's Voice as Embodiment
There is a particular reason this collaboration contributed meaningfully to the reassessment of Dusty Springfield's place in British pop history. Her vocal performance on the track carries a lifetime of musical intelligence in every phrase: the phrasing, the breath control, the ability to make lyrics feel lived-in rather than performed from a careful distance. More than 72 million YouTube views have introduced her voice to generations that grew up long after her original commercial peak, and many of those listeners have followed the thread backward into her extraordinary catalog to discover the recordings that established her reputation in the first place. The song functions, among its other achievements, as one of the most effective introductions to a great singer that the 1980s produced.
→ More from the 1980s File
View all 1980s hits →
Keep digging