The 1970s File Feature
What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'
What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin': Stephanie Mills on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1979 Stephanie Mills arrived at a commercial breakthrough in the summer and fal…
01 The Story
What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin': Stephanie Mills on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1979
Stephanie Mills arrived at a commercial breakthrough in the summer and fall of 1979 with "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'," a disco-influenced R&B single that demonstrated her transition from Broadway performer to major recording artist. The song entered the Billboard Hot 100 on July 21, 1979, debuting at number 96, and climbed steadily through the summer months to reach its peak position of number 22 on September 29, 1979. The single spent fourteen weeks on the Hot 100, reflecting sustained radio support and sales performance throughout the late summer and early fall of that year.
Stephanie Mills: Background and Broadway Career
Stephanie Mills was born in Brooklyn, New York on March 22, 1957. Her path to recording success was unusual in that it ran through one of Broadway's most celebrated productions of the 1970s. She originated the role of Dorothy in the Broadway production of The Wiz, which opened in 1975 and ran for 1,672 performances. Her performance was critically acclaimed, earning her a Tony Award nomination and establishing her as a vocal talent of considerable power and range at an early age.
The transition from Broadway to recording was a natural one given her vocal gifts, but not all theatrical performers successfully make that crossing. Mills's gospel-rooted voice, capable of communicating both vulnerability and strength, translated effectively to the production styles that dominated late-1970s R&B and disco. She signed with 20th Century Records, a label that was actively working to build its R&B roster during this period.
For the First Time and the Recording of the Single
"What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" was the lead single from Mills's album For the First Time, released on 20th Century Records in 1979. The album was produced by James Mtume and Reggie Lucas, a production partnership that had recently achieved considerable success working with Roberta Flack and Donny Hathaway and would subsequently produce some of Mills's strongest commercial work as well as records for Phyllis Hyman and others. Mtume and Lucas were among the most sophisticated R&B producers working at the end of the 1970s, and their work with Mills on this album reflected a clear understanding of both her vocal strengths and the commercial landscape of the moment.
The production incorporated the rhythmic elements of late-disco while maintaining a soul-oriented vocal focus that suited Mills's voice and her gospel background. The track's arrangement featured prominent synthesizer lines, a pulsing bass, and enough rhythmic propulsion to secure disco-era radio airplay while the vocal performance elevated the material beyond pure dance-floor functionality. This balance between commercial accessibility and artistic substance would characterize Mills's best work throughout her career.
Chart Performance and R&B Success
While the Hot 100 peak of 22 was the single's most visible commercial benchmark, "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" performed even more strongly on the R&B charts, where it reached number two on the Billboard R&B Singles chart. This performance reflected Mills's core audience and the track's particular resonance in Black radio markets. The fourteen-week Hot 100 run was sustained by consistent R&B airplay and crossover support that placed it in the lower-to-middle range of the pop chart throughout late summer 1979.
The chart context of late summer and fall 1979 included the final months of disco's mainstream dominance and the early signs of the backlash that would reshape pop radio in 1980. Mills's record benefited from the last season of widespread disco-format radio support before that format began its rapid commercial contraction. The timing proved fortunate, as subsequent Stephanie Mills singles would have to navigate a significantly changed radio landscape.
Career Impact and Subsequent Success
For the First Time and its lead single launched what would become a highly successful recording career spanning multiple decades. Mills continued working with Mtume and Lucas and subsequently achieved further chart success, including hits in the 1980s that confirmed her commercial standing. Her combination of theatrical vocal power and pop sensibility gave her a distinctive identity in the R&B marketplace, and "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" was the record that first demonstrated that combination to a national pop audience.
02 Song Meaning
Themes and Legacy of "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" by Stephanie Mills
"What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" operates within the long tradition of R&B records that address the dynamics of romantic partnership through the lens of emotional challenge and vulnerability. The title's direct address to a partner, its insistent question about the disposition of offered love, places it in a lineage that runs through the classic soul era and into the late-1970s R&B context in which Mills was working.
Vocal Identity and Theatrical Training
One of the most significant aspects of Mills's contribution to late-1970s R&B was the way her theatrical background shaped her approach to recorded performance. Singers who have trained for Broadway develop a particular relationship to narrative and emotional arc within a song, conditioned by the demands of storytelling in a theatrical context where emotional communication must reach the back row of a theater without the aid of amplification. This training gave Mills's recordings a quality of dramatic commitment that distinguished them from the more production-driven work of many of her contemporaries.
On "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'," this theatrical instinct is audible in the way she navigates the song's emotional arc, moving between challenge and vulnerability, assertion and appeal, with a naturalness that suggests both technical command and genuine emotional engagement. The Mtume-Lucas production gave her a sophisticated sonic environment within which these qualities could register clearly, and the result was a record that functioned simultaneously as radio product and as a showcase for an exceptional vocal instrument.
Gospel Roots and R&B Crossover
Mills's gospel background, like that of many of the great R&B vocalists of her generation, provided the foundational emotional vocabulary for her secular recordings. The conversion of sacred vocal intensity to secular romantic subject matter has been one of soul music's defining operations since at least the early work of Ray Charles in the late 1950s. Mills's participation in this tradition through the late-1970s lens of disco-era R&B connected her work to a much longer history of African American vocal expression.
This connection enriched the apparent simplicity of the track's subject matter. A question about what a partner intends to do with offered love becomes, in the hands of a vocalist with this kind of training, a vehicle for something more complex: an assertion of the singer's own worth, a demand for reciprocity, and a demonstration that emotional vulnerability is compatible with vocal power.
Legacy in the Stephanie Mills Catalog
The success of "What Cha Gonna Do With My Lovin'" established Mills as a viable recording artist independent of her theatrical identity, clearing the path for a recording career that continued productively through the 1980s and beyond. Her subsequent hits, including "Never Knew Love Like This Before" (which reached number six on the Hot 100 in 1980), built on the foundation that this record helped create. The song thus occupies a foundational position in her discography, representing the moment when her Broadway-forged vocal identity fully engaged with and succeeded within the commercial R&B landscape of its era. For listeners and researchers exploring the transition from 1970s soul and disco to the R&B of the 1980s, her work provides important evidence of the continuities that underlie the apparent stylistic shifts between decades.
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging