The 1970s File Feature
That's The Way A Woman Is
That's the Way a Woman Is: The Messengers and Early 1970s Soul The Messengers were a soul and R&B group who recorded for Detroit-based labels during the late…
01 The Story
That's the Way a Woman Is: The Messengers and Early 1970s Soul
The Messengers were a soul and R&B group who recorded for Detroit-based labels during the late 1960s and early 1970s, working within the fertile ecosystem of producers, arrangers, and musicians that the Motown era had created in that city. "That's the Way a Woman Is" was released in 1971 and debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on September 11, 1971, spending 9 weeks on the chart and peaking at number 62 on October 23, 1971. The single represented a modest but genuine commercial achievement for a group operating in the intensely competitive soul and R&B market of the early 1970s.
The group recorded during a period when Detroit's musical infrastructure was undergoing significant changes. Motown Records had relocated its primary operations to Los Angeles by 1972, but the city retained a deep pool of musical talent, production expertise, and recording facilities that continued to produce commercially viable soul and R&B. Independent labels and production companies operated in the space created by Motown's partial departure, and groups like the Messengers found opportunities within this evolving landscape.
The track was released on Soulpower Records, a small independent label operating in Detroit during this period. Small independent labels in this era functioned as important incubators for talent that the major labels and large independents might overlook, and Soulpower's roster reflected the depth of Detroit's ongoing musical productivity even as the city's most famous musical export had moved west. The production on "That's the Way a Woman Is" drew on the established vocabulary of Detroit soul, with a rhythm section rooted in the Motown session musician tradition and orchestral sweetening appropriate to the period's commercial expectations.
The chart trajectory of the single was distinctive: the track entered at number 93, held that position for a second consecutive week, then climbed through September and October before reaching its peak of number 62 in late October. The initial stagnation at number 93 was unusual but not unprecedented for records that found their initial audience slowly before gaining broader radio play and retail traction. The subsequent climb demonstrated that the track had genuine commercial appeal once it achieved adequate airplay exposure.
The vocal performance on the track drew on the male soul tradition that had been developed through the Motown era and was being sustained by groups across the Detroit-influenced R&B landscape. The lead vocalist brought to the performance the kind of emotional directness and technical polish that soul audiences expected, and the production supported the vocal with arrangement choices appropriate to both the lyric's content and the commercial requirements of the period's radio market.
The Messengers operated in a competitive environment that included not only Motown's own acts but a wide range of independent soul groups, Philadelphia-influenced acts, and the emerging funk-oriented sound that was gaining commercial momentum in the early 1970s. Maintaining chart presence in this environment required consistent releases and effective radio promotion, challenges that independent labels often struggled to meet with the resources available to them. The 9-week chart run of "That's the Way a Woman Is" reflected both the track's genuine commercial appeal and the limitations of the promotional infrastructure supporting it.
The broader Detroit soul legacy within which the Messengers operated has been extensively documented by music historians and collectors, and interest in the independent label recordings from this period has grown substantially in the decades since their original release. Tracks that achieved moderate chart success in the early 1970s have been rediscovered through reissue projects and streaming platforms, introducing them to audiences who were not part of the original listening community. The Messengers' work from this period stands as a representative example of the kind of quality independent label soul production that sustained Detroit's musical identity through the transitional years of the early 1970s.
02 Song Meaning
Observation, Acceptance, and the Complexity of Romantic Understanding
"That's the Way a Woman Is" belongs to a tradition of soul music that approaches romantic relationships through the lens of patient observation and earned understanding. The declarative title sets the tone for the entire lyric: the narrator is not discovering or debating; he is stating something he has come to know through experience. The Messengers deploy this posture of confident understanding to create a song that feels mature and grounded rather than naive or idealistic about the nature of romantic partnership.
The phrase "that's the way" carries within it a history of observation and reflection. It implies that the narrator has watched, paid attention, made mistakes, revised his understanding, and arrived at a position of genuine knowledge. This kind of earned perspective was highly valued in the soul tradition, where authenticity of feeling and directness of communication were aesthetic and moral virtues. The narrator who claims to understand how a woman is must demonstrate through the specificity and accuracy of his observations that his claim is credible rather than presumptuous.
The lyric navigates the territory between genuine appreciation and potential condescension with the care that the best soul songwriting typically brought to this kind of material. The observations the narrator makes are presented as sympathetic rather than critical, as the understanding of someone who has learned to see clearly rather than someone who judges from a position of superiority. This sympathetic observation is what transforms what might otherwise be a reductive formulation into something that functions as a genuine expression of romantic knowledge and acceptance.
The soul tradition from which the track emerges had developed sophisticated conventions for navigating gender dynamics in romantic song. The best male soul vocalists of the Motown era and its aftermath had learned to communicate about women and relationships in ways that acknowledged complexity and paid respect to the full humanity of both parties in the relationship. The Messengers' track draws on these conventions, using the musical and vocal vocabulary of Detroit soul to frame its lyrical content in ways that feel emotionally genuine rather than reductive.
The production context, rooted in the Detroit soul tradition even as that tradition was evolving in the early 1970s, reinforces the lyric's emotional register through arrangement choices that signal seriousness and sincerity. The orchestral elements suggest that what is being communicated is substantive, worthy of the full resources of the production. The rhythm section grounds the emotion in physical reality, preventing the lyric's reflective quality from becoming too abstract or detached from the bodily experience of romantic relationship.
In the competitive early-1970s soul market, tracks that offered this combination of emotional specificity and broad accessibility occupied a valuable commercial position. Soul audiences were sophisticated listeners who brought high expectations for both vocal performance and lyrical substance to their engagement with new recordings. A track that could deliver genuine emotional content in the context of a well-crafted production could find a loyal audience even without the promotional resources of a major label. "That's the Way a Woman Is" achieved its modest chart success through precisely this combination of craft, performance, and authentic emotional engagement with its subject matter. The earned understanding at the song's core connected with listeners who recognized in it a reflection of their own experience of learning to see the people they loved with greater clarity and acceptance over time.
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging