The 1970s File Feature
Cindy Incidentally
Faces and "Cindy Incidentally": A Snapshot of the Rod Stewart Era By 1973, Faces were one of the most energetically compelling live bands in British rock, a …
01 The Story
Faces and "Cindy Incidentally": A Snapshot of the Rod Stewart Era
By 1973, Faces were one of the most energetically compelling live bands in British rock, a reputation built on performances that prioritized communal exuberance over technical precision and that made their concerts events more akin to extended parties than to formal musical presentations. The group had coalesced from the remnants of the Small Faces following Steve Marriott's departure in 1969 to form Humble Pie, with Rod Stewart and Ron Wood joining Ronnie Lane, Kenney Jones, and Ian McLagan to create a lineup that brought together two distinct creative personalities in a productive if often combustible combination.
The tension at the heart of Faces was the dual stardom of Stewart and Lane. Stewart, who simultaneously maintained a solo career through Mercury Records while remaining a member of the group, had achieved enormous commercial success with his solo albums Every Picture Tells a Story (1971) and Never a Dull Moment (1972). His solo profile often overshadowed the group identity, a source of ongoing friction within the band and a complicating factor in how the public perceived the relationship between his individual work and the collective output of Faces.
Ronnie Lane, who served as the group's principal songwriter alongside McLagan and Stewart, brought a different sensibility to the band: rooted in English folk and music hall traditions, warmer and more eccentric than the rock ambitions of Stewart's solo work. The interplay between those two creative orientations, Stewart's rock star charisma and Lane's more whimsical, folk-influenced songwriting, gave Faces records a distinctive quality that was harder to replicate than either element alone would have been.
"Cindy Incidentally" was released as a single in early 1973, drawn from the band's creative activity during a particularly active period for the group. Written by Stewart, Lane, McLagan, and Wood, the track captured the loose, good-humored energy that characterized the best Faces recordings: an arrangement that sounded simultaneously spontaneous and crafted, with a groove that invited physical engagement without demanding technical attention. The title itself reflected a quality of offhand wit that ran through much of the Lane-influenced material in the band's catalog.
The single was released in the United Kingdom, where it performed well, reaching the top five. Its US release followed, and the single debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on March 10, 1973, entering at number 83. The ascent was gradual, consistent with the pattern of album-rock-oriented acts finding their way onto the Hot 100 through a combination of album sales momentum and AOR radio play rather than the more aggressive promotional push that Top 40 singles received. The track climbed through the seventies and sixties before reaching its peak of number 48 during the week of April 21, 1973. The 9-week chart run documented a real but modest US commercial footprint for the band during this period.
American audiences had been slower than British ones to fully embrace Faces, and the chart performance of their US releases consistently reflected that pattern. Their albums found substantial audiences through AOR radio and college markets, but translating that into strong Hot 100 performances proved difficult in the way that it did for many British acts whose energy was more naturally suited to album tracks and live performance than to the three-minute single format that dominated pop radio. "Cindy Incidentally" nonetheless represented one of their more successful US Hot 100 showings.
Ron Wood contributed guitar work that was central to the record's character, his style providing the rhythmic and harmonic backbone that allowed the rest of the arrangement to breathe loosely without losing coherence. Wood had developed a guitar approach that was simultaneously distinctive and selfless, capable of generating momentum and texture without asserting a virtuosic personality that would have changed the band's collective dynamic. That quality made him a valued collaborator not only within Faces but subsequently in the Rolling Stones, whom he joined in 1975.
The period around "Cindy Incidentally" was, in retrospect, one of the final productive phases of the classic Faces lineup. Ronnie Lane left the band later in 1973, citing dissatisfaction with the balance between the group's collective identity and Stewart's increasingly dominant solo profile. Lane's departure fundamentally altered the band's creative character, removing the songwriter most responsible for its more idiosyncratic and folk-influenced material. The group continued for a period without him but never fully recovered the specific chemistry that his presence had generated.
Stewart himself departed in 1975 to pursue his solo career full-time following the massive success of "Maggie May" and his subsequent solo albums. The remaining members restructured, with various configurations using the Faces name in subsequent years. But the core period of the band, from their formation in 1969 through Lane's departure in 1973, produced a body of work that has been consistently recognized as among the most enjoyably unpretentious and musically generous in British rock history.
Looking back, "Cindy Incidentally" captures the band near the end of that core period, still operating with the full complement of their most characteristic elements: Lane's songwriting sensibility, Stewart's charismatic vocal delivery, Wood's fluid guitar work, and the rhythm section of Jones and McLagan providing the propulsive foundation that made their records sound as good in clubs and pubs as they did on album. The Hot 100 placement at number 48 was modest by the standards of the era's biggest acts, but it documented a genuine audience response to a song that embodied everything the band at its best represented.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning of "Cindy Incidentally" by Faces
"Cindy Incidentally" is a song whose meaning is partially embedded in its manner of meaning rather than in any single, easily extracted message. The track is characteristic of a strand of Faces songwriting, shaped significantly by Ronnie Lane's eccentric and warmly humanistic sensibility, in which the mood and texture of the song carry as much significance as the literal content of the lyric. The title itself, with its slightly odd pairing of a conventional first name and an adverb that does not obviously follow from it, signals that the song is interested in slantwise approaches to its subject rather than direct statement.
The song's lyric traces a relationship in which the figure named Cindy is encountered not as the center of a grand romantic drama but in passing, incidentally, as the adverb of the title suggests. This framing distinguishes it from the more conventionally earnest love songs that dominated the pop charts of the period. The Faces were not generally a band interested in performing sincerity in the straightforward way that many of their contemporaries were, and "Cindy Incidentally" reflects that orientation: the emotional content is real but delivered with a wryness and a lightness of touch that kept it from tipping into sentimentality.
There is also an element of self-deprecation in the song's emotional architecture that was characteristic of the band's approach to its own image. Faces cultivated a persona that was laddish and fun rather than self-important, and their best songs captured that quality: emotionally engaged but not emotionally overwrought, capable of taking genuine feelings seriously without insisting that the audience regard those feelings as cosmically significant. "Cindy Incidentally" exemplifies this balance, addressing whatever the narrator feels about Cindy with warmth but without grandiosity.
The musical setting contributed substantially to this emotional register. The arrangement's easy, rolling groove gave the song a quality of good humor and physical pleasure that made the lyric's more personal dimensions feel casual rather than confessional. Listening to the track, one gets the sense that whatever is happening between the narrator and Cindy is being reported in the spirit of a good story shared among friends rather than a wound being examined in isolation. This communal quality, the sense that the music itself is a social act, was central to what Faces represented at their best.
Rod Stewart's vocal delivery on the track reinforced this reading. Stewart was capable of both grand romantic sincerity, as he demonstrated on ballads throughout his career, and the kind of knowingly casual delivery that suited lighter material. On "Cindy Incidentally," he occupied the latter register comfortably, his voice communicating the narrator's attachment to Cindy without overdramatizing it. The result was a vocal performance that matched the song's emotional temperature precisely.
The song's modest US chart performance at number 48, reached during a period when Faces were more acclaimed as a live act than as a singles band in the American market, meant that "Cindy Incidentally" reached a smaller American audience than its quality perhaps deserved. In the United Kingdom, where it performed significantly better, it was recognized as a characteristic expression of what made the band distinctive: a combination of musical warmth, lyrical wit, and unpretentious emotional honesty that set them apart from both the earnest rock acts and the more calculated pop acts that surrounded them in the early 1970s.
Decades later, the song remains one of the more enjoyable entries in the Faces catalog, a small, well-made piece of British rock that says what it means without belaboring it and moves on, which is exactly what a song with "incidentally" in its title should do.
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging