The 1970s File Feature
My Mistake (Was To Love You)
My Mistake (Was To Love You): Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye's Bittersweet CollaborationIn the spring of 1974, Motown released a duet album that arrived in the m…
01 The Story
My Mistake (Was To Love You): Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye's Bittersweet Collaboration
In the spring of 1974, Motown released a duet album that arrived in the middle of a complicated moment in the careers of both artists involved. Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye had each, by 1974, reached positions of enormous commercial and artistic consequence; both were in the process of redefining what those positions meant in relation to Motown's evolving corporate identity. Together, they recorded Diana & Marvin, and from it came "My Mistake (Was To Love You)," a track that gave both singers a vehicle perfectly calibrated to what each of them did best.
Two Stars at Complicated Moments
Diana Ross had left the Supremes in 1969 to launch a solo career that had been enormously successful, both commercially and in terms of her expanding ambitions as an actress and a performer. By 1974 she was Motown's most celebrated face. Marvin Gaye, meanwhile, had by 1971 redirected his own career entirely with What's Going On, one of the most influential albums in the history of American popular music. His position within the label was consequently complicated: he had demonstrated that Motown's model of artist control could produce extraordinary results, which created tension with the label's traditional approach. Bringing these two artists into the studio together was a calculated move on Berry Gordy's part, one that produced a record with genuine commercial appeal alongside genuine artistic interest.
The Sound of the Duet
What makes "My Mistake (Was To Love You)" work as a piece of music is the way the two voices relate to each other. Ross's voice is precise and controlled, operating in a range that gave it clarity and a certain cool elegance. Gaye's voice was a different instrument entirely: warmer, more fluid, with a falsetto capable of extraordinary intimacy. The contrast between their vocal textures creates a kind of dramatic tension within the duet, each voice carrying its own emotional character while still serving the shared narrative. The production, characteristic of Motown's work in this period, is immaculate: lush without being oppressive, rhythmically assured, built to carry the vocal performances at the center.
The Chart Journey
"My Mistake (Was To Love You)" debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on February 23, 1974, at number 84. Over the following weeks it climbed steadily through the chart, moving through the fifties and forties and thirties as spring arrived. The song reached its peak position of number 19 on May 4, 1974, spending a total of 16 weeks on the chart. On the R&B chart the song performed even more strongly, which was characteristic of Gaye's releases in this period. Sixteen weeks on the Hot 100 with a top-twenty peak was a genuine commercial success, particularly for a duet album that might have been dismissed as a corporate product but instead demonstrated real artistic chemistry.
The Legacy of the Collaboration
The Diana & Marvin album was and remains a somewhat underappreciated document in both artists' catalogs. It does not occupy the same canonical position as Gaye's solo work from this period, and it represents a different mode of Ross's output than her highest-profile projects. But "My Mistake (Was To Love You)" demonstrates that the collaboration produced something genuinely worthwhile rather than merely commercially convenient. The song's 8.1 million YouTube views suggest that listeners continue to find it, often through the backdoor of one artist's catalog or the other, and are rewarded by the discovery of a record that sounds as good now as it did in 1974.
Press Play
The song holds up as a piece of craft and as a piece of performance. Put it on now and listen to the exchange between the two voices: the way they play off each other, the places where they pull the melody in slightly different directions, the underlying warmth that makes the whole thing feel less like a studio exercise and more like two people who genuinely hear each other.
"My Mistake (Was To Love You)" — Diana Ross & Marvin Gaye's singular moment on the 1970s charts.
02 Song Meaning
My Mistake (Was To Love You): When Regret Is Also Gratitude
The title positions the song's central emotional logic immediately: love is named as a mistake. But the treatment of that premise in the lyric is more nuanced than the bluntness of the title suggests. The narrator's regret is genuine, but the acknowledgment of the love as a mistake is delivered without bitterness, without the anger that usually accompanies the realization that one has made an error of this magnitude. What emerges is a song about a particular emotional state that is harder to write than most: the place where regret and gratitude coexist.
The Anatomy of the Romantic Mistake
When the lyric calls love a mistake, it is invoking a specific emotional logic: the recognition, after the fact, that the cost of a relationship exceeded what it returned. This is a common enough experience, but it is usually accompanied by a negative emotional charge that the song carefully avoids. The narrator is not angry at the person they loved. They are not angry at themselves. They are simply acknowledging a miscalculation, with the kind of acceptance that only arrives when the pain has had time to transform into something more neutral. That temporal quality, the retrospective nature of the assessment, gives the song its particular emotional temperature.
Two Voices, Two Perspectives
Part of what gives "My Mistake (Was To Love You)" its emotional complexity is the duet format itself. Two voices sharing the same lyric, ostensibly describing the same experience from the same narrative vantage point, but bringing distinct emotional textures to the delivery. The effect is to suggest that the experience of loving and being let down by love is not singular but shared; that two people can have the same basic story and render it differently through the particular quality of who they are. Diana Ross and Marvin Gaye's vocal contrast makes that implicit argument audible rather than theoretical.
Motown's Emotional Grammar
The song operates within a tradition of Motown songwriting that understood romantic disappointment as a subject requiring precision and dignity rather than dramatic excess. The label's most durable catalog items tend to treat heartbreak and complication with a kind of emotional intelligence that refuses to wallow. The production lifts the lyric; the arrangement supports rather than overwhelms; the singers are given space to find the human scale of the emotion rather than performing it at a scale that exceeds the listener's ability to identify with it. "My Mistake (Was To Love You)" honors that tradition. It is a sad song that does not make you feel worse for having listened to it, which is a harder achievement than it sounds.
What Remains
The song continues to reach listeners who find in it a particular kind of emotional accuracy: the recognition of love as something that can be simultaneously real, worth having had, and ultimately wrong for the particular people involved. That combination of qualities is not easily rendered in popular song, and when it is rendered well it creates a record that carries meaning far beyond the specifics of its original moment. "My Mistake (Was To Love You)" has earned its place in both artists' legacies by doing exactly that.
→ More from the 1970s File
View all 1970s hits →
Keep digging