The 1960s File Feature
To Each His Own
To Each His Own: The Tymes Carry Philadelphia Elegance onto the National ChartsPhiladelphia Soul Before Soul Had a NameThere is a moment in the early spring …
01 The Story
To Each His Own: The Tymes Carry Philadelphia Elegance onto the National Charts
Philadelphia Soul Before Soul Had a Name
There is a moment in the early spring of 1964 when American pop music is caught between worlds. The British Invasion has just declared itself with tremendous force, and the old structures of domestic pop are shifting fast. Into this turbulent moment steps a Philadelphia vocal group, immaculately turned out and singing with a poise that few of their contemporaries could match. The Tymes were not trying to compete with the noise. They were offering something different: refinement, warmth, and a mature sense of harmonic craft that owed as much to doo-wop tradition as to the new soul currents moving through Black American music.
The group had already announced themselves with some force the previous year, scoring a major hit with the ballad "So Much in Love," which reached the top of the pop chart in the summer of 1963. That success introduced mainstream radio audiences to their sound: lush male harmonies, a light orchestral touch, and lead vocals that combined tenderness with genuine technique. "To Each His Own" was their bid to sustain that momentum.
The Song's Long History
"To Each His Own" was not a new composition when The Tymes recorded it. The song had been a major popular standard since the late 1940s, recorded by dozens of artists over the intervening years. Reviving a well-known standard carried risk as well as opportunity: audiences already had their preferred versions, and a new interpretation needed to offer something distinct to justify its existence.
The Tymes justified it through elegance. Their arrangement surrounded the familiar melody with the kind of polished orchestration that was becoming the hallmark of their label work, and the vocal performance treated the song's message of romantic preference with real conviction. The result felt fresh precisely because it was sung with such specific feeling rather than generic sentiment.
Four Weeks and a Steady Climb
The Tymes entered the Billboard Hot 100 with "To Each His Own" on March 14, 1964, debuting at number 98. The ascent was measured and consistent, moving through 89, then 83, before peaking at number 78 during the song's fourth and final week on the chart on April 4. Four weeks, modest placement, but a clean arc from entry to peak that suggests an audience finding the record and responding to it sincerely rather than reacting to a promotional blitz.
The timing was complicated by the sheer volume of British product flooding American radio that spring. The week the record peaked, the chart was thick with Beatles tracks and their British contemporaries. That The Tymes could land at all under those conditions was a demonstration of the loyalty their previous success had built.
The Tymes in the Larger Picture
What the group represented in 1964 was a kind of Philadelphia grace that would, within a few years, develop into one of American popular music's most distinctive and influential sounds. The smooth harmonic architecture, the sophisticated orchestration, the emphasis on emotional maturity over teenage excitement: these qualities would be refined and amplified by subsequent generations of Philadelphia artists and producers. The Tymes were early carriers of an aesthetic that would eventually transform the genre.
Their chart presence in early 1964 also demonstrated that audiences had not abandoned domestic pop entirely in the face of the British wave. Taste remained plural. A beautifully sung standard could still find its people.
Lasting Resonance of a Gentleman's Song
Listening to The Tymes now, what strikes you most is the confidence of understatement. There is no desperation in the performance, no reaching for an effect that isn't there. The group trusted the song and trusted their own craft, and that trust communicates itself across sixty years without any effort at all.
The song's title works as both personal statement and musical philosophy: in a market crowded with styles and influences, The Tymes simply did what they did best and let the music find its own audience.
Put this one on and let that Philadelphia poise remind you what it sounded like when pop music dressed for the occasion.
"To Each His Own" — The Tymes' singular moment on the 1960s charts.
02 Song Meaning
To Each His Own: Love on Its Own Terms
The Philosophy of Personal Preference
The title phrase itself carries a quiet declaration of independence. "To each his own" is an old saying rooted in the notion that personal taste is sovereign: what matters to one person may mean nothing to another, and both responses are equally valid. Applied to romantic love, the phrase becomes an assertion that the narrator's feelings are specific, chosen, and not subject to outside approval or comparison.
In the context of The Tymes' recording, this philosophical underpinning gives the love song an unusual kind of groundedness. The narrator is not swept away, not overwhelmed; this is a person who has considered their preferences and arrived at a deliberate conclusion. That maturity of tone was part of what distinguished the group's emotional register from much of the teen-oriented pop that surrounded them on the chart.
Romantic Devotion and Exclusivity
The song's emotional core is the assertion that one particular person fulfills everything the narrator needs or wants. Other relationships, other possibilities, other standards of beauty or companionship: all of these exist in the world, but none of them matter because this one person is simply everything. The feeling described is total romantic preoccupation, rendered not as obsession but as a kind of serene certainty.
That certainty is what makes the song resonate across the decades. It describes a feeling most people recognize: the moment when abstract romantic possibility collapses into one specific, irreplaceable person. The song gives that feeling a dignified and beautiful form.
The Standard as Emotional Template
Because this song existed as a standard before The Tymes performed it, it carried a built-in layer of emotional history. Listeners in 1964 who had grown up hearing earlier versions would bring that accumulated meaning to the new recording, layering their own associations over the fresh arrangement. Standards work this way; they accumulate weight over time, becoming vessels that each generation fills with its own experience.
The Tymes' interpretation does not fight that history. It inhabits it comfortably, allowing the familiar melody to carry its decades of romantic association while the vocal performance adds something new: a specifically 1960s Black American sweetness, shaped by gospel harmony and doo-wop tradition.
Why It Spoke to 1964 Listeners
Early 1964 was a period of considerable cultural unsettlement in the United States. The previous November's assassination had left a wound that had not healed; the civil rights movement was pressing its claims with urgency; new sounds from Britain were reshaping the pop landscape. In that climate, a beautifully sung song about romantic certainty and personal devotion offered something valuable: stability, warmth, the idea that some feelings remained steady beneath the turbulence.
Twelve weeks on the Hot 100 confirmed that there was a real audience for what The Tymes were offering. Listeners did not need to choose between the new and the emotionally sustaining.
The Song's Enduring Appeal
The feelings described in "To Each His Own" require no historical context to understand. Romantic preference, the sense that one person is uniquely right for you, is as universal an experience as music addresses. What the song adds to that universal is a vocabulary of grace: the ability to hold that feeling with dignity and tenderness rather than raw intensity. That quality is what makes older listeners return to it and younger ones discover it with a sense of recognition that crosses generations.
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging