The 1960s File Feature
That's How Heartaches Are Made
The Marvelettes: "That's How Heartaches Are Made" (1969) By the time The Marvelettes released "That's How Heartaches Are Made" in the autumn of 1969, the gro…
01 The Story
The Marvelettes: "That's How Heartaches Are Made" (1969)
By the time The Marvelettes released "That's How Heartaches Are Made" in the autumn of 1969, the group had already navigated nearly a decade of personnel shifts, stylistic reinventions, and the relentless commercial pressures of Motown Records. The single arrived at a peculiar crossroads for both the group and for Motown as a whole, as the label began pivoting away from its classic Detroit assembly-line sound toward more psychedelic, socially conscious material. That tension is palpable in the recording itself.
"That's How Heartaches Are Made" was produced under the Motown in-house system, where writers and producers from the Motown creative stable crafted material intended to sustain the group's commercial viability. The Marvelettes had first broken through in 1961 with "Please Mr. Postman," a number-one hit that became the label's first chart-topper on the Billboard Hot 100. The song had been recorded in a single session with a raw, spontaneous energy that captured something essential about the group's early identity. Over the subsequent years, the original five-member lineup contracted through departures and personal circumstances, and by 1969 the group was effectively a trio anchored by Wanda Young, whose warm alto had become the primary identifying voice on Marvelettes recordings throughout their commercial peak years.
The song exemplifies the lush orchestral soul that Motown was deploying across much of its 1969 catalog. String arrangements cushion a mid-tempo groove, and the call-and-response vocal architecture that had served the Marvelettes so well throughout the decade remained intact. Yet the recording also carries a certain melancholy undertow, fitting for a lyric that meditates on romantic loss and the almost pedagogical quality of heartbreak. The production choices reflect Motown's awareness that the group's audience had matured alongside them, expecting something more emotionally nuanced than the exuberant teen pop of the early releases.
On the Billboard Hot 100, "That's How Heartaches Are Made" debuted and peaked at number 97 during the chart dated November 8, 1969, spending a single week on the survey. That modest commercial performance reflected the intensely competitive Motown roster of the era, where the label was simultaneously promoting releases from Marvin Gaye, Stevie Wonder, Diana Ross and the Supremes, and the Temptations, each commanding enormous promotional resources and radio promotion budgets. Smaller catalog releases from groups like the Marvelettes could easily be swamped in that environment, receiving limited promotional support as the label concentrated its attention on acts with greater current momentum.
The 1969 period also coincided with broader industry disruption as album-oriented rock began consolidating its hold on radio formats, compressing the promotional windows available to classic soul singles. Motown had built its empire on the seven-inch 45 rpm single, and the declining dominance of that format created real headwinds for any act that wasn't already a superstar draw capable of commanding dedicated playlist slots from increasingly rock-oriented program directors.
Historically, the Marvelettes occupied an important but sometimes undervalued position in the Motown narrative. The group had introduced a rough, ebullient R&B energy to the label's early releases that predated the more polished Holland-Dozier-Holland productions that would come to define Motown's commercial peak in the middle years of the decade. Music historians and Smithsonian researchers have noted that "Please Mr. Postman" essentially validated the label's commercial model at a critical early moment, proving that Berry Gordy's vision of Black pop music crossing over to mainstream audiences was commercially viable and not merely aspirational.
"That's How Heartaches Are Made," arriving eight years later, belongs to a different chapter: a period of graceful persistence rather than explosive breakthrough. The group would officially disband in 1969, making this single among their final Motown releases. Wanda Young's continued work in the studio through this period demonstrated both personal commitment to the Marvelettes legacy and Motown's interest in extracting catalogue value from the brand. The recording thus functions as a closing document of one of the label's foundational acts, capturing a mature, orchestrated soul sound that stood at some remove from the rawer exuberance of the group's earliest work while preserving the vocal warmth that had always been central to their appeal.
Collectors and soul enthusiasts have returned to the late-period Marvelettes catalog with renewed interest in subsequent decades, finding in recordings like "That's How Heartaches Are Made" a sophisticated emotionalism that was perhaps underappreciated on initial release. The song remains a document of Motown's transitional late-1960s moment, when the label's signature sound was evolving under the pressure of changing cultural and musical forces, and when veteran acts like the Marvelettes were navigating the difficult terrain between their established identities and the demands of a rapidly shifting popular music landscape.
02 Song Meaning
Meaning and Emotional Register of "That's How Heartaches Are Made"
"That's How Heartaches Are Made" operates within a well-established Motown lyrical tradition: the anatomy of romantic loss delivered with precise, almost clinical observation. Rather than wallowing in grief, the song frames heartbreak as a process that follows identifiable steps, lending the emotional content a quality of hard-won wisdom rather than raw anguish. This instructional undertone distinguishes the track from simpler laments that merely express pain without attempting to comprehend its structure or origins.
The central conceit of the lyric positions the narrator as someone who has accumulated enough romantic experience to understand the mechanics of how affection curdles into pain. Heartache is not presented as an arbitrary catastrophe but as the predictable result of specific choices and emotional dynamics. There is a pedagogical gravity to this framing, one that both validates the narrator's suffering and grants it a kind of dignity. Suffering, in this reading, is educational rather than merely afflictive, and the singer's willingness to articulate its mechanics suggests that understanding has at least partially replaced the initial devastation.
This interpretive angle connects the song to a broader tradition in African American popular music of finding philosophical grounding in personal hardship. The blues tradition had long articulated loss through narrative frames that emphasized resilience and self-knowledge rather than pure victimhood. Motown soul refined this impulse through polished production and melodic sweetness, softening the blues' rawer edges without abandoning its fundamental insistence on survival through understanding. The narrator knows something now that she didn't know before, and that knowing is itself a form of forward movement.
The orchestral arrangement reinforces the song's emotional tone without overwhelming it. Strings add a layer of pathos that invites empathy from the listener, while the rhythmic pulse underneath prevents the track from becoming purely elegiac. The balance between orchestral weight and rhythmic momentum mirrors the lyrical balance between grief and the steadying force of understanding one's own emotional history. The production choices are, in this sense, interpretive: they tell the listener how to feel about what is being described.
Wanda Young's vocal delivery carries the text with a controlled expressiveness that avoids melodrama. Her tone suggests someone who is not merely recounting a recent wound but synthesizing a pattern she has observed across time. The phrasing is deliberate, each line landing with the measured quality of a statement rather than a cry. This restraint amplifies the emotional impact precisely because it signals that the emotion has been processed rather than suppressed, transformed into something that can be communicated calmly because it has been genuinely understood.
Listened to in the context of 1969, the song also carries a subtle resonance with the social turbulence of the era. While it does not address political events directly, its meditation on disappointment, betrayal of trust, and the slow accumulation of damage resonates with a broader cultural mood of disillusionment. The personal and the collective frequently bleed into each other in soul music of this period, and even a seemingly private lyric about romantic heartache absorbs some of the era's ambient anxiety, becoming a more general statement about the costs of hope and the education that follows its collapse.
Ultimately, the song's meaning rests in its insistence that heartache is not inexplicable but comprehensible, not purely destructive but potentially clarifying. The narrator's willingness to identify the mechanism of her own pain transforms a story of loss into a story of knowledge, and knowledge, in the Motown tradition, is always at least partly a form of power and of protection against the same wound being inflicted again.
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging