The 1960s File Feature
Knock On Wood
Knock On Wood: How Otis Redding and Carla Thomas Transformed a Soul Classic By the summer of 1967, the Stax Records roster had accumulated one of the most po…
01 The Story
Knock On Wood: How Otis Redding and Carla Thomas Transformed a Soul Classic
By the summer of 1967, the Stax Records roster had accumulated one of the most potent collections of soul talent in American popular music. Among those artists, Otis Redding stood as arguably the label's greatest star, a man whose raw, gospel-rooted delivery had already produced monuments like "Try a Little Tenderness" and "I've Been Loving You Too Long." Carla Thomas, meanwhile, had grown up inside the Stax family; her father Rufus Thomas was among the label's founding figures, and she herself had scored with "Gee Whiz (Look at His Eyes)" back in 1961. The pairing of these two artists on a duet album seemed not merely logical but inevitable, and the single that emerged from those sessions, a cover of Eddie Floyd's "Knock On Wood," became one of the defining moments of the soul era.
Eddie Floyd had written "Knock On Wood" with Steve Cropper, the Stax house guitarist, in 1966. The song had been composed in a Tampa, Florida hotel room during a thunderstorm, and Floyd's original recording reached number twenty-eight on the Billboard Hot 100 that year. The composition drew on superstition, vulnerability, and the desire to protect something precious, themes rooted deeply in the blues tradition. When the decision was made to record a version by Redding and Thomas for their collaborative album King and Queen, released in the spring of 1967, the arrangement stayed close to the original Stax house-band template. The Stax rhythm section, anchored by drummer Al Jackson Jr. and bassist Donald "Duck" Dunn, provided the same propulsive foundation that had driven Floyd's hit, and Steve Cropper's guitar remained central to the texture.
The King and Queen album itself was a milestone document. Recorded in late 1966 and early 1967 at Stax Studio in Memphis, the sessions captured two artists operating at the height of their individual powers, finding in each other a complementary energy that sharpened both performers. The album's title was not accidental; it positioned Redding and Thomas as the reigning monarchs of soul, a royal pairing designed to evoke the great male-female duet tradition in rhythm and blues that included such forerunners as Sam and Dave, Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell, and Ike and Tina Turner.
"Knock On Wood" was selected as a single from the album and entered the Billboard Hot 100 on August 12, 1967, debuting at number ninety-two. Its chart climb was steady if not explosive, moving through the nineties before crossing into the fifties by early September. The record reached its peak position of number thirty during the week of September 23, 1967, spending nine weeks on the chart in total. The Stax/Volt label credit on the release connected the song to the entire sonic ecosystem the label had built over the previous decade, and radio play reinforced the impression that Memphis soul was then operating at an extraordinary creative peak.
The interplay between Redding and Thomas on the recording is what distinguishes it most sharply from Floyd's original. Where Floyd delivered the song as a solo supplication, Redding and Thomas turned it into a dialogue, a call-and-response between two voices equally matched in intensity. Redding's gritty, pleading tenor pushed against Thomas's cooler, more controlled soprano, and the tension between those two vocal personalities gave the duet an electric quality that transcended the mechanics of the material. Steve Cropper's choppy guitar riffs and the Memphis horns added layers of texture that made the track feel simultaneously tight and expansive.
Context matters for understanding the record's broader cultural position. The summer and autumn of 1967 represented one of the most turbulent periods in American domestic history, with urban unrest, the escalating Vietnam War, and the shifting landscape of the civil rights movement all commanding the national conversation. Stax Records, as an integrated label that employed Black and white musicians side by side in Memphis, Tennessee, occupied a symbolically charged position in that cultural moment. The success of duets like "Knock On Wood" carried resonance that extended beyond the purely musical.
Tragedy struck the Stax story just months later. On December 10, 1967, Otis Redding was killed when his private plane crashed into Lake Monona near Madison, Wisconsin. He was twenty-six years old. The loss was catastrophic not only for Stax but for soul music as a genre still in the process of defining its fullest possibilities. The recordings he had made in the months before his death, including his sessions with Carla Thomas, took on a retrospective poignancy that has never entirely faded. The duet version of "Knock On Wood" became part of the permanent record of what Redding was capable of in collaborative performance.
Carla Thomas continued recording for Stax into the early 1970s, though the label's trajectory grew increasingly complicated following Redding's death and a series of business crises. The duet recordings she made with Redding remained among the most celebrated work of her career, frequently anthologized and reissued across the decades that followed. The pairing's brief existence in the recording studio produced music that outlasted the commercial moment by a considerable distance.
Later cover versions of "Knock On Wood" by artists including David Bowie and Amii Stewart demonstrated the enduring vitality of Floyd and Cropper's composition. But within the particular tradition of soul duet recordings, the Otis and Carla version retains a special authority, a document of two extraordinary voices finding each other at the peak of the Memphis soul era and producing something that neither could have achieved alone.
02 Song Meaning
The Meaning Behind Knock On Wood: Protection, Vulnerability, and the Language of Soul
"Knock On Wood," as recorded by Otis Redding and Carla Thomas in 1966 and released as a single in 1967, operates on a theme that runs through the oldest veins of the blues and gospel traditions: the terror of losing something irreplaceable. The song's central impulse, the urgent, almost superstitious need to guard a precious relationship against forces that might dissolve it, gave the material an emotional universality that transcended any particular biographical circumstance.
The original composition by Eddie Floyd and Steve Cropper drew directly on the folk belief that knocking on wood could ward off bad luck or prevent a boast from tempting fate. That superstition carries roots in various cultural traditions, including the notion that spirits dwelling in trees offered protection to those who acknowledged them. By framing romantic devotion in the language of folk magic, Floyd and Cropper embedded the song in a worldview where love was not a given but a fragile gift requiring constant vigilance and active preservation.
In the hands of Redding and Thomas, the material gained an additional dimension through its duet format. The back-and-forth vocal structure transformed the song from a solo confession into something closer to a mutual covenant. Redding's voice carried its characteristic urgency, the quality of a man who understood that what he valued could be taken from him and who was determined to prevent that loss. Thomas's cooler, more refined delivery provided a counterweight, suggesting not passivity but a different kind of strength, one rooted in composure rather than rawness. The friction between those two vocal registers gave the song its peculiar electricity.
The soul idiom in which the song was embedded carried its own set of meanings in 1967. Soul music of the Stax school had by that point established itself as more than a commercial genre; it was an articulation of Black American experience, drawing on the church, the blues, and the specific sonic culture of cities like Memphis. The Stax house band, the Booker T. and the MGs rhythm section supplemented by the Memphis Horns, provided the musical language within which the emotional content of the song was communicated. The tight, disciplined groove was not merely a backdrop but an active participant in the song's meaning, suggesting both containment and release.
The song's emotional logic moves through vulnerability toward something like determination. The narrator is not passive in the face of potential loss; instead, the act of knocking on wood becomes a declaration of intent, an assertion that the relationship is worth protecting and that the speaker will take every available measure to preserve it. This transforms what might otherwise be mere superstition into an expression of agency within an uncertain world. The theological overtone is not incidental; in the gospel tradition that underlay so much of soul music's emotional vocabulary, the act of seeking protection from higher powers was entirely consonant with genuine faith.
When considered against the backdrop of 1967 America, the song's preoccupation with protecting something precious from mysterious threatening forces acquired additional resonance. The year was one of extraordinary upheaval, and the music that audiences embraced reflected their emotional conditions. A song about vigilance, about refusing to take good fortune for granted, spoke to a broader cultural mood in which stability felt perpetually at risk. The duet format reinforced the message: two people holding together against uncertainty, their voices intertwined as a form of mutual defense.
The recording's enduring appeal rests partly on its emotional honesty. Redding and Thomas did not aestheticize or distance themselves from the material; they inhabited it with the directness that characterized the best Stax performances. That quality of unmediated feeling, of artists who seemed to mean every syllable, is what has kept the record vital across more than five decades of subsequent popular music history.
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging