The 1960s File Feature
The Cat
Jimmy Smith's "The Cat": Jazz Organ Royalty Briefly Crosses Into the Pop Charts In the late summer of 1964, an instrumental record by one of jazz's most dist…
01 The Story
Jimmy Smith's "The Cat": Jazz Organ Royalty Briefly Crosses Into the Pop Charts
In the late summer of 1964, an instrumental record by one of jazz's most distinctive voices entered the Billboard Hot 100 and found an audience that extended beyond the dedicated jazz listenership that had made its creator famous. "The Cat" by Jimmy Smith debuted on the chart dated September 5, 1964, at number 87, and climbed over six weeks to its peak of number 67 on the chart dated September 26, 1964, where it remained for two consecutive weeks before beginning its descent. The modest pop chart showing was a secondary measure of success for a record that was primarily understood as a jazz and soul-jazz release, and it represented the partial crossover of a performer whose core reputation was built on a body of work aimed at a more specialized audience.
Jimmy Smith, born James Oscar Smith in Norristown, Pennsylvania on December 8, 1928, had transformed the landscape of jazz organ playing with such thoroughness that it is nearly impossible to imagine the instrument's subsequent history without accounting for his influence. When Smith began recording for Blue Note Records in the mid-1950s, the Hammond B-3 organ was primarily associated with gospel music and the rhythm and blues of Black churches and roadhouses. Smith's appropriation of the instrument for jazz contexts, deploying it with the harmonic sophistication of bebop and the rhythmic drive of hard bop, created an entirely new stylistic territory that dozens of subsequent organists would explore without fully mapping.
"The Cat" was recorded for Verve Records, to which Smith had moved in 1962 after his celebrated run of Blue Note sessions. The Verve move represented a conscious commercial reorientation, with label head Creed Taylor developing a production aesthetic for Smith that placed the organist within lusher, larger-scale arrangements than the organ trio format he had pioneered. Taylor brought in orchestral arranger Lalo Schifrin for several Smith sessions during this period, and the combination of Smith's propulsive organ playing with Schifrin's atmospheric orchestrations produced a distinctive sound that was more immediately accessible to pop and easy listening audiences than pure jazz while retaining genuine musical quality.
The title track of the The Cat album exemplified this approach. Schifrin's arrangement surrounding Smith's organ work gave the piece a cinematic quality, evoking with considerable skill the atmosphere of a predatory feline in motion. The musical imagery was specific enough to be vivid but sufficiently abstract to reward repeated listening, and the groove Smith generated on the organ was compelling independently of the orchestral framing. The piece functioned simultaneously as a showcase for Smith's instrumental virtuosity and as an accessible piece of atmospheric pop-jazz that radio programmers and casual listeners could engage with without requiring specialist knowledge.
The soul-jazz idiom that Smith had largely invented was by 1964 one of the most popular forms of jazz for general audiences. Acts including Jack McDuff, Jimmy McGriff, and Richard "Groove" Holmes had followed Smith's lead in developing the Hammond organ trio format, and the combination of jazz improvisation with rhythm and blues groove had proven to have significant commercial appeal in African-American markets in particular. Smith's move to Verve and his adoption of orchestrated settings represented an attempt to translate that appeal into a broader, more demographically diverse market, with "The Cat" as one of the more successful examples of this strategy.
The album The Cat received positive critical reception alongside its commercial performance, acknowledging that Taylor and Schifrin had found a way to extend Smith's musical appeal without compromising his fundamental identity as a jazz musician of the first rank. Smith's improvisational intelligence was audible throughout the record, and the orchestral settings framed rather than obscured his playing. The Hot 100 appearance was therefore not an artistic compromise but evidence that a genuinely excellent jazz musician could find a broader audience when presented with sufficient skill and commercial intelligence.
Jimmy Smith's career continued to flourish through the 1960s and beyond, and he remained an active performer until his death in 2005. His influence on jazz organ playing was so total that virtually every significant organist who followed him was working either within or in conscious reaction to the framework he had established, a legacy that a brief pop chart appearance in 1964 can only partially illuminate. "The Cat" was a crossover moment for an artist whose primary significance was always elsewhere, but it was a crossover moment achieved without artistic compromise, and that combination made it genuinely noteworthy.
02 Song Meaning
Motion, Predation, and the Swinging Grace of Jimmy Smith's "The Cat"
"The Cat" is a piece of musical portraiture, an attempt to render in sound the qualities associated with a specific animal: the fluid grace, the coiled power, the effortless predatory confidence of a cat in motion. As a piece of programmatic jazz-pop, the track succeeds through the alignment of its musical means with its thematic ends, and the combination of Jimmy Smith's organ playing with Lalo Schifrin's orchestral arrangement produced something that genuinely evoked its subject rather than merely naming it.
The choice of the cat as subject for an instrumental jazz piece was not arbitrary. The animal had occupied a significant place in jazz culture since the music's earliest decades, functioning as slang for a hip musician and appearing throughout the vocabulary of jazz sociability in ways that associated feline characteristics with musical sophistication, coolness, and improvisational agility. When Smith recorded a piece called "The Cat," he was working within this established cultural association while also making something more literal and specific: a musical portrait of the animal itself, not merely an invocation of its jazz-cultural associations.
The musical qualities that the arrangement and performance brought to this portrait were carefully chosen. Lalo Schifrin's orchestration established the atmosphere through long sustained tones and gradual builds that suggested stalking motion, the patient accumulation of tension before sudden release. The brass contributed an element of physical mass and occasional ferocity that suggested the powerful cat rather than merely the graceful one. The rhythm section, anchored by Smith's organ, provided the groove that kept the piece in the jazz tradition rather than allowing it to drift entirely into easy listening or film score territory.
Smith's improvisational contributions carried much of the piece's expressive content. The Hammond B-3 organ, when played with Smith's characteristic command, produces a sound that combines extraordinary sustain with remarkable dynamic flexibility, capable of roaring ferocity and intimate softness within the span of a few bars. These contrasts were well suited to the portraiture project: a cat is simultaneously soft and powerful, gentle and lethal, and Smith's organ captured this duality more effectively than any more conventional jazz instrument might have managed. The instrument's inherent theatricality served the piece's aims.
The relationship between jazz and the broader popular culture that surrounded it was a constant negotiation throughout the 1950s and 1960s, as jazz musicians and their labels worked to maintain artistic credibility while finding ways to sustain commercial viability in a market increasingly dominated by rock and roll and its derivatives. The strategy that Creed Taylor developed at Verve, pairing jazz soloists with sophisticated orchestral arrangements designed by composers of real ability, represented one of the more musically defensible approaches to this challenge. It acknowledged that the jazz audience alone could not sustain a major-label recording career while insisting that the accommodation to broader tastes need not involve artistic compromise.
"The Cat" demonstrated that Jimmy Smith's musical identity was sufficiently robust to survive the orchestral treatment without being distorted or diminished. His organ playing on the track was recognizably the playing that had made his Blue Note recordings so important to jazz musicians and enthusiasts; the orchestral setting around it changed the context rather than the content of his contribution. This is the crucial test of any such collaboration, and the record passed it.
The track's brief Hot 100 presence was less a measure of its artistic significance than of the limited commercial appetite in 1964 for instrumental jazz of any kind. The pop market in the period of the British Invasion was more focused on song and voice than at virtually any previous point in its history, and an instrumental jazz-pop fusion piece was always going to occupy a niche rather than dominate a mainstream. That "The Cat" reached number 67 at all was a tribute to its musical accessibility and the commercial intelligence of its production. That it remains a distinctive and pleasurable listening experience more than six decades later is a tribute to something more durable: genuine musical quality in the service of a clear and well-realized artistic vision.
→ More from Jimmy Smith
View all Jimmy Smith hits →
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging