The 1960s File Feature
To Each His Own
To Each His Own: Frankie Laine's Late-Career FlourishA Voice That Refused to AgePicture the pop landscape in early 1968: the Beatles had Magical Mystery Tour…
01 The Story
"To Each His Own": Frankie Laine's Late-Career Flourish
A Voice That Refused to Age
Picture the pop landscape in early 1968: the Beatles had Magical Mystery Tour on their minds, soul music was crackling out of Memphis and Detroit with unrelenting energy, and rock radio was getting louder and more psychedelic by the week. Into all of that stepped Frankie Laine, a man whose big-barreled voice had been a fixture on the American charts since the late 1940s, delivering a song built on the oldest conviction in the romantic songbook: that love, properly understood, belongs to the people who feel it, and nobody else gets a say.
Laine had long since earned his reputation as one of the defining vocalists of the postwar era. The sweep and power of his delivery made him a natural for songs that asked everything of a singer, and by the mid-1960s he had moved comfortably into the territory of the seasoned professional, recording material that suited his instrument rather than chasing trends. To Each His Own fit that profile perfectly.
A Standard With Deep Roots
The song itself had been around for more than two decades before Laine brought it back into the public conversation. Written in 1946, it had already generated a handful of hit versions and accumulated the kind of track record that made it instantly familiar to older listeners while remaining fresh enough to reach younger ears if the performance was strong enough. The melody carries a certain old-world elegance, the kind that was going out of fashion in the age of electric guitars but that never actually stopped being beautiful.
Laine leaned into that elegance. His version did not try to modernize the song or dress it in contemporary production fashions; it trusted the material and the voice, which in 1968 remained a remarkable instrument. The recording debuted on the Billboard Hot 100 on January 20, 1968, entering at number 96 and beginning a slow but determined climb.
Climbing the Chart
The chart run was steady rather than spectacular. Week by week, the song moved upward: from 96 to 95, then 94, then 88, then 85. It reached its peak position of number 82 on February 24, 1968, spending six weeks on the Billboard Hot 100 in total. Those numbers place it well below the blockbuster hits of that season, but they tell a real story: in a year dominated by artists half his age and genres that had little use for the kind of formal, full-throated balladry Laine practiced, the record found an audience and held it for a month and a half.
Pop radio in 1968 was a contested and crowded space. Soul, rock, and psychedelia were all competing for the same dial positions, and the middle of the chart was full of records from artists navigating the gap between eras. Laine's entry into that space was a reminder that certain voices carry a gravity that does not require a trend to support them.
The Legacy of the Performance
Frankie Laine never became a household name for the 1960s generation the way he had been for the generation before them; that was not the point. By 1968 he had already given the world dozens of recordings that would endure, from his early barnstorming hits to the Western-tinged material that made him a soundtrack staple. To Each His Own in its 1968 form represents something slightly different in that catalogue: a late-career return to the kind of romantic standard that had first made him famous, offered without apology to whoever wanted to hear it.
The song's title functions almost as a personal statement. Each listener brings their own history to a love song, and what lands deeply for one person floats past another entirely. Laine's version seems to understand that and deliver its sentiment without demanding any particular response.
An Invitation to Listen Again
More than 156 million YouTube views have accumulated around this recording in the decades since, a number that suggests the audience for genuine vocal craft is considerably larger than any single chart position could reflect. When you find yourself wanting something that dispenses with the era's noise and simply trusts a great voice to carry a melody, press play. You will understand immediately why Frankie Laine still found willing ears in 1968.
"To Each His Own" — Frankie Laine's singular moment on the 1960s charts.
02 Song Meaning
What "To Each His Own" Says About Love and Autonomy
The Title as Philosophy
The phrase "to each his own" is so familiar in everyday speech that it can seem to lose its meaning entirely, flattened by overuse into a mild shrug. What Frankie Laine's 1968 recording does is restore the phrase to its full romantic weight. In the context of the song, the sentiment is not a dismissal but a declaration: love is personal, love is specific, and whatever the world may think of two people's attachment to each other, the bond belongs to them and to nobody else.
Romantic Loyalty as Theme
The lyrics circle around a speaker who is certain about whom they love and unmoved by any suggestion that they should feel otherwise. There is a quiet defiance in that posture, the kind that does not raise its voice or argue its case but simply holds its ground. The emotional core of the song is the conviction that one's own heart is the only authority worth consulting in matters of love, a conviction that Laine's delivery makes feel earned rather than naive.
This is not a complicated emotional landscape. The song does not dramatize conflict or internal struggle; it presents a settled certainty. What makes it moving rather than merely declarative is the warmth the performance brings to that certainty, the sense that the speaker's loyalty is not rigid but freely chosen.
Mid-Century Romantic Values
The song was written in 1946 and carries the emotional vocabulary of that postwar moment, when romantic stability felt hard-won and worth celebrating plainly. By 1968, popular music had moved into considerably more complicated emotional territory: songs about disillusionment, political protest, generational rupture, and the anxieties of a world that seemed to be reshaping itself too fast. A song about uncomplicated romantic loyalty sat at an angle to all of that.
That angle was part of its appeal for a segment of listeners who were not necessarily buying into the era's countercultural mood but who still wanted music that spoke to their daily emotional lives. The mid-1960s through early 1970s saw a persistent audience for adult pop and easy listening material, and that audience found genuine satisfaction in a performance that honored the romantic traditions of an earlier generation without irony or distance.
The Power of Vocal Sincerity
What the song ultimately asks of a listener is simple: that you trust the voice telling you about love. Laine's instrument, with its natural authority and physical depth, makes that trust easy. The meaning of To Each His Own is delivered not primarily through lyric complexity but through the conviction of the vocal performance. When a singer with Laine's history of romantic material sings about belonging to someone, the weight of that catalogue stands behind every note.
Sincerity, in the context of 1968 pop music, was its own form of radicalism. A song that meant exactly what it said, delivered by a voice that had nothing left to prove, occupied a particular and irreplaceable space on the dial.
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging