The 1960s File Feature
How'd We Ever Get This Way
How'd We Ever Get This Way: Andy Kim's 1968 Breakthrough The spring of 1968 was one of the most turbulent seasons in modern American history. The Tet Offensi…
01 The Story
How'd We Ever Get This Way: Andy Kim's 1968 Breakthrough
The spring of 1968 was one of the most turbulent seasons in modern American history. The Tet Offensive had shaken confidence in the Vietnam War; Robert F. Kennedy would be assassinated in June; the world felt like it was coming apart at its seams. And yet the Billboard Hot 100 of that spring was full of love songs , songs about connection, romantic yearning, and the specific confusion of new love. Into that context arrived Andy Kim, a Montreal-born singer-songwriter who had been working the fringes of the New York music industry, and he brought with him a record that climbed all the way to number 21.
Andy Kim Before the Breakthrough
Andy Kim (born Andrew Joachim) arrived in New York from Montreal in the mid-1960s with ambitions that placed him squarely in the Brill Building tradition , the world of professional songwriters and session-oriented pop production that had generated so many hits through the early decade. He connected with Jeff Barry, the producer and songwriter who had co-written numerous hits for the Ronettes, the Crystals, and the Dixie Cups, among others. That connection was the crucial one: Barry's production instincts and industry relationships gave Kim the platform to demonstrate what he could do as a performer and songwriter.
"How'd We Ever Get This Way" and Its Remarkable Chart Run
The single's chart trajectory was one of the more impressive ascending climbs of spring 1968. It entered the Billboard Hot 100 on May 4, 1968, at number 100 , the very bottom of the chart. Over the following weeks, the ascent was dramatic: 100, then 80, then 54, then 49, then 29, the momentum building with each passing week as radio play accumulated. The track peaked at number 21 on June 22, 1968, after spending 12 weeks total on the chart. That sustained run and that peak position were significant achievements for a debut single from a relatively unknown artist.
The Production Sound and Jeff Barry's Touch
The production on "How'd We Ever Get This Way" reflected Jeff Barry's mastery of melodic pop craft. The arrangement was full without being cluttered, with a rhythm section that pushed the track forward and a harmonic structure that made the hook feel inevitable rather than calculated. Kim's voice had a quality that was simultaneously youthful and emotionally present , the kind of voice that communicated vulnerability without fragility, that made romantic uncertainty sound appealing rather than pathetic. The combination of Barry's production experience and Kim's natural vocal charm created a record that felt both professionally crafted and emotionally authentic.
The Summer of 1968 and What Came Next
The chart success of "How'd We Ever Get This Way" established Andy Kim as a genuine commercial presence, and he followed it with a string of hits through the late 1960s and early 1970s. "Baby, I Love You" reached number 9 in 1969, and his version of "Rock Me Gently" became a number one hit in 1974, demonstrating a commercial consistency that few artists who debuted so modestly can claim. The 1968 debut was the foundation of that longer career, a record that introduced his particular combination of melodic instinct and emotional directness to a large national audience for the first time.
A Pop Gem from a Tumultuous Year
"How'd We Ever Get This Way" is a reminder that even the most historically dramatic years contain the full spectrum of human experience , that people were falling in love and navigating romantic confusion in the spring of 1968 just as they were processing political shock. Pop music served that function: acknowledging the emotional reality of ordinary life even when extraordinary events dominated the broader cultural conversation. Andy Kim's debut captured that ordinary emotional reality with genuine beauty. Press play and hear what young love sounded like in the spring of 1968.
The Legacy of the Jeff Barry Production Partnership
The collaboration between Andy Kim and Jeff Barry was one of the more productive in the Brill Building tradition's later phase, producing a string of releases that demonstrated consistent commercial instincts without sacrificing melodic quality. Barry brought to the partnership not just technical production skills but a deep understanding of how to build a record that could sustain repeated radio plays without exhausting the listener. The arrangement of “How'd We Ever Get This Way” was calibrated for exactly this kind of longevity, with enough musical detail to reward close listening and enough melodic clarity to work as background sound for daily life. The 12 weeks it spent on the chart, a longer run than most debut singles could claim, validated that approach entirely and set the foundation for what followed.
“How'd We Ever Get This Way” , Andy Kim's singular moment on the 1960s charts.
02 Song Meaning
The Question at the Center: Romantic Confusion in "How'd We Ever Get This Way"
The question in the title is grammatically unusual and emotionally precise. Not "why did we end up here" or "how did things get complicated" but "how'd we ever get this way" , the contraction giving it a colloquial directness, the "ever" suggesting genuine bewilderment, as if the singer cannot quite believe that two people could arrive at this particular emotional place through any logical sequence of events. That sense of loving bewilderment is the emotional core of the song, and Andy Kim communicates it with a naturalness that makes the feeling immediately recognizable.
The Phenomenology of New Love
The experience the song describes , the disorienting, slightly vertiginous feeling of finding yourself deeply in love without quite understanding how or when it happened , is one of the most universal in human emotional life. Falling in love does not typically feel like a decision or a process; it tends to feel like a discovery, as if a state that must have been developing for some time suddenly becomes conscious. Andy Kim captures this particular quality of romantic experience with a directness that bypasses cleverness in favor of simple emotional truth. The song does not try to explain the experience; it simply presents it with full-voiced wonder.
Jeff Barry's Pop Architecture
The track's emotional effectiveness is inseparable from its musical construction. Jeff Barry was one of the most skilled melodic architects of the Brill Building era, and his work on "How'd We Ever Get This Way" demonstrated why. The melody carries the feeling of the lyric , it swoops and reaches in ways that feel like the physical sensation of romantic overwhelm, like the slightly breathless quality of finding that your feelings have exceeded your expectations. The harmonic movement under the melody provides emotional context: moments of resolution that feel like emotional landing, moments of harmonic tension that mirror the uncertainty in the lyrical content.
The Late 1960s Pop Mainstream
1968 was a year of musical extremes. The late psychedelic era, the birth of heavy rock, the increasingly political content of folk and rock music , these were the genres and tendencies that received the most critical attention. But the majority of what the majority of people were actually listening to on AM radio was melodic pop: songs that communicated straightforward emotions with professional craft and genuine feeling. Andy Kim's debut belonged firmly in this mainstream tradition, and its chart performance reflected a genuine audience appetite for this kind of music. The critics were looking at Cream and the Grateful Dead; the listeners were buying Andy Kim.
Vulnerability as Strength
What distinguished Kim as a performer was his willingness to communicate vulnerability without self-pity. The question in the title could be sung as a lament , look at the mess we've made , but Kim sings it as something closer to grateful wonder. The fact that two people could find themselves this deeply connected is presented as extraordinary and positive, even bewildering. This orientation toward romantic feeling as gift rather than burden gives the song its emotional warmth. It is a record that makes the listener feel good about the capacity for love rather than anxious about its complications.
A Debut That Announced a Career
Looking at "How'd We Ever Get This Way" in the context of Andy Kim's subsequent career, it reads as a fully formed statement of artistic identity from the very beginning. The qualities that would make "Baby, I Love You" and "Rock Me Gently" hits , the melodic instinct, the emotional directness, the vocal warmth , are all present here in their first major commercial manifestation. The question the title poses was one that listeners in the spring of 1968 were happy to sit with, to let hang in the air, to feel rather than answer. That willingness to leave the question open rather than resolve it is the song's final and most enduring gift.
→ More from Andy Kim
View all Andy Kim hits →
→ More from the 1960s File
View all 1960s hits →
Keep digging